Deadly and delicious. Magic and mouthwatering. Ubiquitous and mysterious.
Welcome to the world of the Fungus Federation of Santa Cruz, whose love language for mushrooms includes all of the above and the taglines like โKeeping the fun in fungusโ and โWhen it rains, it spores.โ
Now that the mainstream holiday activities have passed, the FFSC is settling into the real celebration, and this year marks a biggie. After springing forth back in 1974, the Santa Cruz Fungus Fair is now in its 50thโyes, five zeroโinstallment.
The re-created woodland forest that displays hundreds of wild mushrooms remains a main draw, but thereโs a lot more going on than that.
A peek at the lineup proved tantalizing. Some talks that tingle my shroom senses in particular: โThe Magic Mushroom Class,โ โExploring the Unknown: Cryptic Mushroom Diversity In Your Backyard,โ and โMedicinal Mushrooms – Traditional Usage and Modern Science.โ
Meanwhile Chef Chad Hyatt oversees the 10th After Hours Mushroom Dinner with wine pairings by Frank Virgil of De Vincenzi Cellars.
More at ffsc.us.
EAT UP THE INFO
Bonus mushroom news, arriving right on time: The recent passage of Assembly Bill 261 means the California golden chanterelle is officially CAโs state mushroom, joining the likes of the California redwood (official state tree) and the golden poppy (state flower). The bill itself is actually a pretty fun read, announcing in part, โLong loved by Californians, scientists recently recognized it as a unique endemic species. Thus, Cantharellus californicus is a symbol of the rich and special biodiversity of California.โ
BIG NEWS BREWING
Female-powered Santa Cruz Mountain Brewing Company started making Westside proud with its organic ethics and progressive instincts way back in 2005, before the cityโs now thriving craft beer scene was a thing.
Now itโs been sold. Which scared me at first blush, until I learned the new leadership will involve Adair Paterno of internationally celebrated Sante Adairius Rustic Ales and Brad Clark of Private Press Brewing. SCMBC co-founder Emily Thomas, who describes the brewery as her third child, has been friends and colleagues with Paterno for a solid decade.
โWe believe that Adair and Brad will innovate, expand our reach and continue providing our loyal customers with exceptional craft beers,โ Thomas says.
NOTES AND NUGS Early returns from late December debut The Midway from chef Katherine Stern are good, thanks to farm-to-fabulous dishes like crispy Fogline Farm pork belly with pickled vegetables, jalepeรฑo, herbs and brown rice.โฆEat for the Earth screens Forks Over Knives, which explores the disease-preventing powers of a plant-free diet, for free (please RSVP), Jan. 22 at Sundean Hall, eatfortheearth.orgโฆThe Dry(ish) January grind is real here. My recent taste test rankings amid the so-called โsober-curiousโ drink market, in ascending order: 3) Lagunitas NIPA; 2) Sierra Nevada Hop Splash; 1) Athletic Run Wild IPAโฆAn awesome connective hub awaits at Environteers.org, where locals can plug into helpful updates and great opportunities to volunteer/hang/participate in Santa Cruz-centric and eco-savvy happenings, which often involve foodie-friendly side effectsโฆA final mushroom update: Yours truly will be down at the Big Sur Foragers Festival Jan. 20-21 serving as a judge at the Fungus Face Off. Happy mushrooming.
A.J. Ghimire combined his passion for entrepreneurship and interacting with people to the food service industry in Nepal, where he was born and raised. He came to America in 2019 to work in his familyโs restaurants. He says he began to mature and take the business more seriously, further learning the ropes of the industry from his uncle Dilip, the owner of Namaste.
When Dilip opened Namaste Bar & Grill in July 2023, he tasked A.J. with running the newest beachside location in the familyโs chain. A.J. says the placeโs concept is all about giving beachgoers what they want: a family-centered diverse and approachable menu with everything from pizzas to curries.
Pizza options range from outside-the-box choices like Indian Butter Chicken and Tandoori Chicken to pepperoni. Myriad curries with multiple vegetarian and meat options also highlight the menu, along with chicken wings in exotic flavors like Mango Masala and Aachari (a pickle-based flavor). The full bar features Indian-inspired options like the Spicy Mango-rita, Ginny Tamarind and Mumbai Mule. Dark on Mondays, hours are 12-10pm (until 10:30pm Fri/Sat) every other day.
Compare the industry in Nepal vs. America?
A.J. GHIMIRE: In Nepal, owning a restaurant is all about the customers coming in, having the food and then leaving. Thereโs not much personal connection or intimacy, or getting to know them on a personal level. But here in America, I enjoy the industry more because it is more like family and knowing whatโs going on in each otherโs lives.
What sets Namaste apart?
AJG: When we started, it was one family-based location and every time we added one, we had a different family member run it. Itโs all about baby steps and having the right team in place. The employees really know the food and recipes at all five locations, and this keeps the food extremely consistent and we never compromise quality. And the recipes are not overnight recipes, theyโve been developed over 15 years. The food is a collaborative effort amongst the family, and we constantly try and perfect our recipes to stay in line with the needs of the people.
303 Beach Street, Santa Cruz, 831-713-5430; namasteindiabistro.com
During the first month of the year most of the country is hibernating. Itโs winter, itโs cold and everyone needs a break after the tumult of the holidays. But not in our little town.
I thought in January we would get a breather, but musically, this month looks like July. Weโve got great national and local talents coming through. We have a surprisingly full schedule.
Every week managing editor Jeanette Bent and I wrestle with what articles will fit in the printed page and what we should run online. As one of the last bastions of print, we take the publication seriously and with reverence. Not everyone wants to read everything on their phone. We are one of the last free weeklies you can pick up and hold onto, combing through articles at your leisure, clipping them out and pasting them to your refrigerator or circling them and passing them on to friends.
So, this week we had six music articles to choose from and Jeanette came up with a brilliant idea: letโs scrap a cover story and let the music take over.
I wish I could tell you which of these shows you must see, because itโs like asking a parent which kid they liked best. The answer is all of them.
With Tommy Castro, youโve got a blues man trying a first blues opera; The Third Mind is a conglomeration of world famous artists coming together for the first time, each of whom plays sold out shows; Wynton Marsalis says a singer like Cecile McLorin Salvant only comes through โonce in a generation or twoโ.
The Santa Cruz Symphony has steadily brought in new music and new ways to play it. This weekโs performance features the U.S. premiere of Jean Ahn’s Jajang, Jajang for Gayageum and Orchestra, a world music mashup with roots in Korea. Then thereโs Victor Wooten, who is hailed by Rolling Stone as one of the โTop 10 Bassists of All Time.โ
Finally, John Wesley Harding, who is famous as an indy artist, also tours under his real name, Wesley Stace, and is playing an intimate gig in Watsonville.
Which of these would you choose, if you only had to pick one? Let our readers know in the online comments below.
Thanks for reading.
Brad Kava | Editor
PHOTO CONTEST
SUN RISE Spotted this pair enjoying the sunrise the beautiful morning by the Bay. PHOTO Kathy Isonio
โAt CDTFA, we give team members access to quality training, mentoring opportunities, and upward mobility programs to propel their careers,โ said California Department of Tax and Fee Director Nick Maduros.
GOOD WORKS
The City of Santa Cruz is now accepting applications for its 2024 Master Recycler Volunteer Training Program. Over five Tuesday evening and two Saturday morning sessions from Feb. 6 to March 5 participants will train to become โMaster Recycler Volunteersโ in areas related to waste reduction and recycling.
Saturday field trips will provide a behind-the-scenes tour of the Recycling Center where 30-50 tons of material is recycled every day, and a trip to the Grey Bears campus for a presentation on “Rethinking Your Purchases.”
QUOTE OF THE WEEK
“Not voting is not a protest. It is a surrender.”โKeith Ellison
After driving around for three weeks in my homeland of England in the fall, I was ready for a mini-break when I got back โ part of that due to covering close to 900 miles and driving a car with a stick shift!
So off we went to Mendocino for a few days โ one of our favorite coastal getaways famous for its superior Anderson Valley wines. There are so many wineries on the stretch of Hwy 128 that itโs hard to choose, but one we found to be charming and un-glitzy is Lula Cellars. One of the wines that caught my attention is their 2021 Guntly Red ($32), a red blend primarily made up of Pinot Noir from the Anderson Valley and Cabernet Sauvignon from the Pine Mountain-Cloverdale Peak AVA. Rounding out the blend is a touch of Zinfandel from the Fashauer Vineyard on Mendocino Ridge.
One of our favorite places to stay is Brewery Gulch Inn. Not only is the place warm and welcoming, but the food prepared is outstanding โ with the opportunity to try many complimentary local wines offered with dinner. Breakfast is cooked to order and service is excellent. Another place we love to stay is the Little RiverInn, which lies smack on the coast and is an icon in the area โ famous for its hospitality and stunning ocean views. We enjoyed a glass of wine on our balcony to the sound of waves crashing on the shore.
White Wine Weekend will be held Feb.17/18 with VIP White Wine & Sparkling Wine Experiences. A Pinot Noir Festival will be held May 17-19 with winery open houses, raffle, auction, and much more. And now you know of two fabulous places to stay when youโre there! AVWINES.com
Calling Cecile McLorin Salvant a jazz singer is kind of like calling Donald Trump a realtor. It’s a woefully incomplete description. Salvant is a jazz singer, but much more than that. As a vocalist, composer, bandleader, visual artist and filmmaker, the term โmultidimensional artistโ has been used more than once to describe her and really fits.
Salvant, who returns to Kuumbwa Jazz Center Monday night, has been drawing superlatives and awards from musicians, singers and critics since 2010, when she released her first album, Cรฉcile & the Jean-Franรงois Bonnel Paris Quintet. Then, at the age of 21, she went on to win the Thelonious Monk International Jazz Competition for vocalists.
She received three consecutive Grammy Awards for Best Jazz Vocal Album for โThe Window,โ โDreams and Daggersโ and โFor One To Love,โ and was nominated for the award in 2014 for her album โWomanChild.โ
In 2019, opera icon Jessye Norman chose Salvant for the Twelfth Glenn Gould Prize, an award not normally awarded to jazz singers. Norman described McLorin Salvant as a โunique voice supported by an intelligence and full-fledged musicality which lights up every note she sings.โ
Brian OโNeill of the Glenn Gould Foundation Podcast extolled her โmusical adventurousness, willingness to voyage across centuries and make music of different times, cultures and mindscapes uniquely her own.โ
Salvant has toured with the Jazz at Lincoln Center Orchestra, whose music director Wynton Marsalis, said, โYou get a singer like this once in a generation or two.โ
Salvant grew up in Miami, Fla., the daughter of a French mother and Haitian father, Salvant heard all kinds of music growing up. โMusic was always on in the house, great singers and music from all over the world.โ
She started classical piano studies at five, began studying voice at the age of eight and didnโt crossover into jazz until 2007, while studying at the Darius Milhaud Conservatory in 2007, Salvant says that her main jazz influence is Sarah Vaughan.
Salvant received a bachelorโs in French law from the Universitรฉ Pierre-Mendes France in Grenoble while also studying baroque music and jazz at the Darius Milhaud Music Conservatory in Aix-en-Provence, France.
Her wide-ranging curiosity and quest for artistic fodder makes her a more worldly version of a โcrate-digger,โ mining jazz, blues, vaudeville, blues, musical theater, jazz, baroque and folkloric music to create new art.
One project in the works is a feature-length, animated film based on her album โOgresse,โ a musical fairy tale in the form of a genre-blending cantataโusing her own drawingsโwhich Salvant will direct. Her idea for โOgresseโ was sparked by a painting by Haitian artist Gerard Fortune depicting an Erzulie, or Vodou deity. Salvant brought it to life with a 13-piece chamber orchestra.
Salvant talked about her penchant for challenging herself, fellow musicians and audiences.
โAs an audience member, I love to be stimulated and challenged. I donโt want something regurgitated and spoon fed to me. But I also donโt think music or art needs to be the spinach you feel you have to eat because itโs โgood for you.โ I am for pleasure and laughter. Truthfully, though I am much more process-driven than impact-driven. I can only say for certain that I would like to move people and connect with their emotions.โ Has her multicultural, multilingual background been an asset?
โI think different languages give you different sounds to work with. Writing is the product of thinking, but sometimes thinking is the product of writing. I feel like sometimes I think slightly differently in different languages.โ
Being placed in a stylistic category can be anathema for a free-range creator like Salvant.
โI think there is a certain creativity required in the act of categorization. Itโs a natural process, something we do all the time for everything in our lives. It can be fun. But I think itโs only fun when youโre doing the categorizing, not when youโre being categorized. As a musician, it can be paralyzing to be placed in a genre. You start to believe in the genre everyone has said youโre in. It exists as an entity separate from other genres, there is no bleed-through. Then it even becomes a responsibility to keep it โaliveโ, or โauthentic.โ You start making music in harmony with that category, or sometimes in conflict with it. Either way, you must contend with it, thereโs no escaping being labeled by others.
Salvant has performed enough times at Kuumbwa to become an audience favorite, according to creative director Bennett Jackson. This upcoming visit will be her first visit to Santa Cruz since 2019, B.C. (Before Covid)
Her band at Kuumbwa will include her most frequent creative partner, pianist Sullivan Fortner. โMy favorite thing is how open he is, spontaneous, and willing to try anything,โ she says. Salvant will be singing with the bandโs bassist, Yasushi Nakamura. โI love his sound, his feel, and his freedom as a musician. He has a freakish memory as well.โ
Up and coming drummer Savannah Harris is the other member. She has worked with a wide range of today’s top indie and experimental artists, and jazz people. โHer playing is infectious, really creative, and she has incredible time and versatility,โ Salvant says.
Referring to her band, Salvant says, โWhat I love about these three musicians is how dedicated they are to the music they make, and how much they want to grow even though they are masters at their craft.โ
Spontaneity and in the moment creation could be considered the essence of jazz, and itโs ultra-important to McLorin Salvant.
โI follow my intuition,โ she says. โI donโt like for any song or arrangement to be written in stone. Everything we do needs to be flexible, needs to allow for change. Sometimes we play the structure of the song upside down, sometimes we skip sections, sometimes we play it at half speed, in a different key, sometimes I add a poem at the end of a song, that I improvise a melody to on the spot. Last March, Nonesuch Records released her latest recording, โMรฉlusine,โ an album mostly sung in French, along with Occitan, English and Haitian Kreyรฒl. What music will she be doing at Kuumbwa?
โI donโt know this yet, but I want to add some new songs to the mix. I often pick songs in the moment but Iโd like to start sticking to set lists! The set lists change every night, especially since Iโm often coming up with what weโre doing in the moment! But that might change this year, I think.โ
7 and 9 pm, Jan. 22, Kuumbwa Jazz Center, 320-2 Cedar St, Santa Cruz $31.50โ$57.75 kuumbwajazz.org
HOLDING COMPOSURE This season, Daphnis & Chloรฉ offer an exciting sound that weaves between cultures. Photo: Santa Cruz Symphony
Winter Romance
By CHRISTINA WATERS
Live music to enthrall new and experienced concert-goers alike will be performed by the Santa Cruz Symphony Jan. 20 and 21 under the direction of Daniel Stewart joined by guest soloist Hwayoung Shon.
Daphnis & Chloรฉ, a musical landscape by Maurice Ravel gives its name to this winter concert, that begins with the sumptuous Adagio from Symphony 10 by Gustav Mahler. Following the Mahler will be the US premiere of Jean Ahn‘s Jajang, Jajang for Gayageum and Orchestra.
The work has been created to highlight the haunting zither-like sound of the traditional Korean gayageum. Sensitively working at the edge of contemporary orchestral music, yet maintaining the distinctive authenticity of the gayageum, award-winning composer Ahn brings a rare entwining of cultures to audiences in this new work.
Soloist Hwayoung Shon, a master of the Korean stringed instrument, performs worldwide, enchanting audiences with her virtuoso performances of an exciting sound that many in the West are just getting to know. Shon, 48, made her performance debut at the age of 10 and has been working extensively ever since with jazz practitioners, world musicians, K-pop stars and classical orchestras. The blend of traditional Korean music with contemporary styles gives her performance at this concert added excitement.
Gustav Mahler was one of the giants of early 20th century Expressionist music. Big, bold, sweeping and experimental, his work sits at the very center of the repertoire for worldwide orchestral performances.
In addition to creating enthralling songs for solo voice, he is renowned for his ten symphonies, each of which explores the depth of huge emotions, including the anguish of heartbreak, utilizing the full sonic reaches of the orchestra. Famed for the sheer intensity of color and rhythm, Mahlerโs 10th Symphony was his final statement on love, betrayal and the oceanic sweep of human desires. Thereโs not a boring moment in this Adagio, large-scale orchestral music intended to move and inspire each listener. Mahlerโs long, slow build-up of sound leads to a spectacular climax.
And about the Ravel, Daphnis & Chloรฉ is an early 20th century Impressionist suite originally created for the Russian superstar dancer Vaslav Nijinsky. Highly romantic, the music tells the story of two children, found and raised by shepherds, who fall in love.
Taken from a Greek myth written in the 3rd century, Ravelโs music paints an orchestral picture of the two young loversโDaphnis the goatherd and Chloรฉ the shepherdessโtheir adventures and the music that the god Pan taught Daphnis to play.
Created for ballet, a musical story intended to be danced, Daphnis & Chloรฉ is a highly popular part of the orchestral repertoire. The music seems to guide us through the love story, the adventures, utilizing four recognizable leitmotifsโmusical themesโthat helped underscore the dance choreography when the piece was played for ballet dancers.
With lush harmonies, and passionate instrumentation this piece is considered Ravelโs masterpiece for orchestra. Many listeners will already be familiar with Ravel through his entrancing Bolรฉro, a 1928 piece for large orchestra that is not only his most famous work, but his final completed musical composition. As with the Bolรฉro, Ravelโs Daphnis & Chloรฉ Suite no. 2 places us in the midst of the story as it unfolds. Ravelโs highly accessible music is emotionally compelling, and completely engaging.
The upcoming Santa Cruz Symphony concertโDaphnis & Chloรฉโoffers innovative programming with broad appeal: Mahler’s Adagio, a US premiere concerto for Gayageum and orchestra, and finally Ravel’s Daphnis & Chloรฉ, Suite no.2.
7:30pm Jan 20, Santa Cruz Civic, 307 Church St., $40-$110
2pm Jan. 21, Mello Center for the Performing Arts, 250 Beach St., Watsonville, $40-$110.santacruzsymphony.org
The Third Mind | Photo: Leslie Campbell Photography
Uncertainty Principle
By BILL KOPP
From one perspective, the sounds made by The Third Mind, a 21st century collective of artists each acclaimed in his and her own rightโhas little to do with the music each of its members has made before. The group features Dave Alvin, co-founder of powerhouse proto-roots rockers The Blasters, along with bassist Victor Krummenacher, bassist with indie rock heroes Camper Van Beethoven.
Other members of the group include folk-rocking singer-songwriter Jesse Sykes, Michael Jerome (in-demand drummer for Richard Thompson, John Cale and many others) and multi-instrumentalist David Immerglรผck of Counting Crows and Camper Van Beethoven. (For the tour, Ratdog guitarist Mark Karan will take the place of Immerglรผck.)
And while itโs true that The Third Mindโs improvisational approach places it well outside the scope of nearly all of those groups, Alvin and Krummenacher donโt view their latest collaborative project as an outlier. โIn my other bands,โ Alvin explains, โthere are certain songs of mine where we donโt know how theyโll end. That keeps everybody on their toes, and they donโt get like, โโOh, Iโm so tired of this.โโ
โAnd thatโs why I come and see you play a lot,โ Krummenacher tells him. Because although Krummenacherโs journeys have taken him to wildly different musical places, he says that The Third Mind represents the realization of a long-held desire. โI think there’s something special,โ he suggests, โabout having a song as a general guidebook, and then working with people who are crazy enoughโand competent enoughโto use that script and then go off.โ
That kind of unpredictability and reliance upon spontaneity and communicationโwrit largeโis at the core of The Third Mind aesthetic. Using classic folk-rock songs of the โ60s as raw material, The Third Mind embarks upon musical excursions that soar well beyond the parameters of the songs in their original form.
The group tackles songs both beloved and obscure. The Third Mindโs 2020 self-titled debut featured Fred Neilโs โThe Dolphins,โ and the bandโs latest (The Third Mind/2, released last October) included reinterpretations The Electric Flagโs โโGroovinโ is Easyโ and The Jaynettsโ haunting โSally Go Round the Roses.โ
โOne of the reasons why Iโm leaning toward the โ60s sort of underground songs,โ explains Alvin, โis that all of those [artists] came out of the folk/blues/garage band kind of thing.โ He says that within tradition is where he has always worked. โItโs a different way of playing it,โ he admits, โBut itโs the same stuff; itโs the same starting point.โ
Only on an improvisational classic like The Butterfield Blues Bandโs โEast Westโ (featured on The Third Mind) does the group present an arrangement with more than a passing resemblance to the original. And even in the case of โEast West,โ Alvin and his band mates are never reined in by preconceived ideas as to where the song โshouldโ go.
Yet neither Krumenacher nor Alvin is comfortable with the label โjam bandโ being applied to what The Third Mind does. Alvin admits that โall of us have been involved in enough jamsโ to concede that thereโs a fine line between the two. But with a chuckle, he observes that in group improvisation, โyouโre listening to each other more than thinking, โBoy, I got off a good lick!โ And youโre going toward something. Where in jamming, itโs like, โFuck it; I donโt care!โโ
Krummenacher agrees. โRock and roll jamming does leave a bad taste in my mouth,โ he says. But the give-and-take of improvisation at its best is something that he has grown to love. โWhen I came up, the Grateful Dead were poison,โ he admits. โNow I listen to them and love it.โ
Alvin says that with most of his other musical endeavors, โthere are those one or two places where we donโt know whatโs going to happen.โ That keeps things interesting for the players and the audience alike. โBut with The Third Mind,โ he emphasizes, โthatโs the whole show!โ
Asked to what degree that spontaneity extends with The Third Mindโdo they even use a set list?โKrummenacher and Alvin cast glances at each other before breaking into laughter.
โWe did, the one time we played live!โ Alvin cackles. For these dates on the bandโs first-ever tour, audiences will simply have to show up and find out.
Playing together during the completely improvised sessions that yielded their debutโand more recently its followupโhas helped the five musicians develop a kind of mind meld, unspoken communication between them. So while theyโre conforming to structure ever so briefly as each tune lifts off, from there itโs anybodyโs guess. โItโs in the interior of the songs where things are going to happen,โ says Alvin.
At this point in their respective careers, the members of The Third Mind are willingly facingโinviting, evenโthe unknown. โWeโre trying to embrace the good, forward-thinking elements in the music,โ Krummenacher explains. โThe idea is really rooted in what great music [represents]: freedom, exploration, fun.โ
โSo much of contemporary pop music is choreographed completely,โ Alvin says. โRoots music, too.โ He says that he gets bored with โdance moves and AutoTune.โ And taking that into consideration, he chuckles and suggests, โSo maybe the most punk rock thing to do is have a group like The Third Mind.โ
Wooten Brothers from left, Victor, Joseph, Roy “Futureman” and Regi Wooten. PHOTO: Steven-Parke
Welcome to Wooton
By BILL FORMAN
If youโre a bass player who suffers from frequent bouts of career envy, you may want to skip this introduction and head straight to the interview.
That way, you wonโt have to dwell on the fact that Victor Wooten has won five Grammy Awards and been hailed by Rolling Stone magazine as one of the โTop 10 Bassists of All Time.โ
Youโll also be able to overlook his work as a founding member of Bรฉla Fleck and the Flecktones, his solo albums for the legendary Vanguard jazz label, his power trio with bass legends Stanley Clarke and Marcus Miller, and his session work with artists ranging from Bill Evans and Jaco Pastorius to Govโt Mule and Kebโ Moโ.
Wootenโs professional career began earlier than most. He was 6 years old when he and his older brothersโRoy, Regi, Rudy and Josephโgraduated from performing in their front yard to touring as the opening act for Curtis Mayfield.
Moving from base to base with their military parents, The Wooten Brothers were naturally drawn to playing USO shows overseas, and went so far as to record a not-so-successful self-titled album for Arista Records. Not long after, the brothers disbanded to pursue other musical projects, with Victor and Roy going on to form the Flecktones with the multidisciplinary banjo player Bรฉla Fleck.
Wooten has also written a pair of critically acclaimed allegorical novels, The Music Lesson and The Spirit of Music: The Lesson Continues. The Washington Post praised the latter as โa book that stands happily against traditional music pedagogy and canned notions of achievement.โ
Now, Wooten is back out on the road with brothers Joseph, Regi and Roy for a winter tour as the Wooten Brothers. We caught up with him between rehearsals to talk about legendary bassists, being compared to Carlos Castaรฑeda, and what happens when you canโt get your fingers to play the right notes.
Q: Youโve been pretty busy over the past few decades: 15 albums with Bรฉla Fleck, 10 albums of your own, the bass collaborationsโฆ
Victor Wooten: Iโve been fortunate, Iโve been very fortunate.
Q: Youโve also played on tons of other artistsโ albums. Was there a point where you realized you were becoming a kind of โhot-callโ session player?
Wooten: That didnโt happen until I started playing with Bรฉla Fleck. Iโd grown up playing as the bassist with my four older brothers, the five of us, The Wooten Brothers. I always thought my whole career was gonna be with them. And it was a bad record deal in the early โ80s that caused the five of us to not be playing exclusively together.
And then, a few years later, I met Bรฉla, and I wasnโt doing much, so I did some stuff with him. And here we are, 35 or so years later, and weโre still doing it. But I didnโt know that was going to be my kind of call to fame, where people started to recognize me. Once the Flecktones became very popular, then I started getting more calls.
Q: And how old were you when you figured out that the bass would be your primary instrument?
Wooten: Oh, I knew that from birthโฆ
Q: How does that work? Were you listening to a lot of Stanley Clarke in the womb?
Wooten: Not in the womb, unfortunately. I was born in 1964, and by the time they [Return to Forever] hit the scene, I was already out playing gigs. Iโd started playing gigs before I started kindergarten.
Q: Seriously?
Wooten: Iโm not joking. My brothers got me doing it, because they needed a bass player.
Q: How did you even hold a bass at that age, let alone play it? I mean, maybe if it was a short-scale Hofnerโฆ.
Wooten: Thatโs exactly what my first bass was. Well, it was a Univox copy of a Hofner, and it looked just like Paul McCartneyโs Hofner.
But actually, my very first instrumentโI was looking at photos of me playing my first gigsโwas a four-string guitar. Reggie took two of the strings off his electric guitar, and I used that as a bass in those first early days. But then my parents found that Univox.
Q: Were your parents musicians?
Wooten: No, but they were very musical. They grew up in a Baptist church where instruments werenโt allowed. They were allowed to sing, but there were no instruments.
Q: In โThe Music Lesson,โ you write about a teacher who appears out of nowhere to guide a young musician on his journey. Were there teachers you encountered in your life who played that kind of role?
Wooten: Absolutely, absolutely. And weโve all had them. Thatโs how we learned to talk, walk, or do anything, is through teachers. Whether they were labeled a teacher or not, thatโs how we did it.
One of my biggest influences was Stanley Clarke. And I remember exactly when those records came out, even though I was very young. My brothers were into it, and so I was into it, too. Stanley played with fire, in a way that bass players werenโt doing at the time. So when Stanley came with that heavy attack and those rapid-fire notes, it woke all of us bass players up to something new.
But heโs not the only one Iโve learned from. Larry Graham, Bootsy Collins, Jaco Pastorius, thereโs a bunch of them. James Jamerson, of course, Chuck Rainey, Carol Kaye, Bob Babbitt, Duck Dunn, all the people that played on the music that a lot of us players grew up with in the โ60s and โ70s. But Stanley was reallyโand still isโmy No. 1 hero when it comes to electric bass.
Q: So going on to record with Stanley Clarke and Marcus Miller, two very different and very legendary bass players, I canโt imagine not being freaked out by just the idea of that. I know you were well into your career at that point, but what was that like for you?
Wooten: Yeah, there were some freak-out moments. Because I met Stanley Clarke when I was 9, and I was much older by the time I met Marcus. So every time Iโm near Stanley Clarke, I feel 9 again. It was hard to get over that, because I was being treated as an equal. And, in my mind, Iโm not. Iโm the little brother.
Q: When your second novel came out โThe Washington Postโ critic Ben Ratliff compared it to Carlos Castaรฑedaโs books about Don Juan, the Yaqui Indian guide that he insisted was real, and others say was fictitious. But you donโt make any claims that the teacher in your novels is real.
Wooten: Well, you know, the main thing with these storiesโwhether itโs the teacher in my story, or Don Juan, or whateverโis that you werenโt there. So to you, itโs just a story, right? And whether I say itโs real or not, itโs just whether you believe. So whatโs real or false? Itโs up to you.
Q: Iโm sure a philosopher could debate that with you endlessly.
Wooten: Yeah, and heโd be wrong. Because you decide what truth is.
Q: So the authorโs intent doesnโt matter?
Wooten: No, itโs up to you. Iโd like to know the authorโs intent. But I donโt want the author to decide for me.
Q: A lot of lyricists wonโt reveal to fans or critics what a song is about, because that can spoil it for the listener.
Wooten: Yeah, I mean, it can. But thatโs also up to you, too. I approach my book as fiction, just to try to alleviate the argument of what was real and what was false, because it doesnโt matter. Whatโs real are the lessons. The story may not be. And I read every story that way. Whether you tell me itโs real or not, whether itโs the Bible, I donโt care whether itโs real, I wasnโt there. By the time it reaches my ear, itโs a story. So I put my attention on what I can learn from it.
Q: Thereโs a book devoted to James Jamerson, who you mentioned earlier, called โStanding in the Shadows of Motown,โ which has nearly 200 pages of transcripts of his basslines. The problem is that thereโs really no way to get the feel of that music onto the page. Was that something you contended with doing your own book of transcripts, and were there tricks you used to get around that?
Wooten: Well, what I did in my transcriptions is, I would not only write the notes, but I would put a number under the note. In other words, if I wrote a C, I may put a 3 underneath it. That lets you know, I play that C on the A string, third fret. And then, if I was hitting the note with my thumb, I put the letter T under the 3. So I put as much technique in this as possible. And the hope is for you to listen to it and get what itโs supposed to feel like, at least when I played it. But itโs allowed to be different when you play it.
Q: The James Jamerson book did include two CDs. But itโs still impossible for meโI mean, Iโm a white guyโto get that vibe. I hope that doesnโt sound racist, butโฆ.
Wooten: No, not at all. I get it. The same way you have a certain voice, I have a certain voice. Our accents are going to be different, and itโs supposed to be that way. The thing is, if Jamerson played it, he would not be able to play it like you.
Q You mean like a metronome thatโs not working quite right?
Wooten: I mean, if thatโs what it is. But either way, James Jamerson only has his voice. Everybody has their own voiceโthey play the way they playโand itโs hard to be able to speak someone elseโs voice.
Q: One last question. I read an interview a while back in which you mentioned having an affliction where your brain tells your fingers to play the wrong notes. Is that a real thing? Because if it is, that means Iโve had it ever since I first picked up an instrument.
Wooten: [Laughs.] Itโs totally legit. Itโs called focal dystonia, and people from all walks of life get it. And what ends up happening is you lose the ability to do what youโve done all the time, whether itโs writing, whether itโs golf, whether itโs gymnastics, whether itโs walking. And itโs something that takes over your brain and tells your limb or your digit to do it the wrong way.
Q: How have you managed to deal with that?
Wooten: Iโve had to learn to play around it as I work on it. The thing is, my fingers work perfectly without the bass. I can still imitate playing it. But as soon as I pick up a bass, three of my fingers on my left hand curl into a ball and donโt want to operate. So Iโm working with a woman whoโs helping me retrain my brain. But itโs a struggle to get them to hit individually on the string. Itโs just the brain has learned to tell the fingers the wrong thing.
Q: There are times, maybe not frequently, where the wrong note can be a good thing.
Wooten: Of course. Mistakes are usually just things I didnโt mean to do. It doesnโt mean itโs wrong. Itโs sort of like when youโre driving, you take a wrong turn, that road will still get you to where youโre going. Any road will get you there. And when you take that wrong turn, it might mean that you see something you didnโt expect.
So wrong doesnโt mean wrong, it doesnโt mean bad. And wrong notes can definitely take you into a better place than you were headed in the first place. If life happened exactly as you wanted it to every time, you would be bored.
7:30pm,Jan 19, Rio Theatre, 1205 Soquel Ave., Santa Cruz, $42-$63, riotheatre.com
MASTER JUGGLER Harding offers a spicy mixing bowl of artistic cookery to stimulate the imagination. Photo: Ilya Mirman
Wonders Never Cease
By ADDIE MAHMASSANI
Wesley Staceโalso known by his former stage name, John Wesley Hardingโanswers questions in the most delightful way. In his English accentโheโs originally from Hastingsโhe flits and swoops and dives like a thoughtful bird, the kind that folds itself into a bullet every so often. Iโm sure I have this image in mind based on something he once said to a class I was in: for him, making music is like juggling a feather, while writing is like juggling a much heavier thing.
Whatever the case, heโs juggling.
Stace is doing a tour up the West Coast this month, playing in Watsonville at Studio Judy Gโs on Wednesday, January 24th before heading north to Novato. During the pandemic, he recorded an album that has proven pivotal in his careerโ2021โs Late Styleโbut to catch up with Stace involves much more than harvesting a few new tales from the studio. In the last year alone, he has edited and written the introduction for the Music Stories anthology for the Everyman Pocket Classics collection (a stunning hardcover, out on February 13), published several high-profile book reviews, begun teaching a public class on 18th century writer Laurence Sterne, seen his libretto for Errollyn Wallenโs opera Didoโs Ghost produced in San Francisco, andโalas, for the sake of this articleโs word count, I have to stop there.
Astounded by the breadth of what heโs been up to, I ask him the loftiest question right off the bat: Wes, you span genres, mediums, and centuriesโฆwhatโs at the core for you?
โI like stirring the artistic pot,โ he says, โand seeing how you can make things that are quite different from each other all cohere.โ
This ethosโsomewhere between mad scientist and unbridled collector of curiositiesโfinds perfect embodiment in Staceโs Cabinet of Wonders, a variety show that he curates at City Winery in New York City, just a hop from his homebase in Philadelphia. Billed as โa little bit vaudeville, a little bit literary and a lot rock โnโ roll,โ the ongoing series brings together eclectic mixtures of musicians, literati and comedians for a madcap night. Around this time last year, CAB104 included bassist Toby Leaman of the rock band Dr. Dog, singer-songwriter Langhorne Slim, actor/writer Amber Tamblyn, comedian David Cross, and more.
โWhatโs basically happening with the Cabinet is Iโm taking a lot of disparate things that are all quite distinct from each other and trying to mold them into a coherent beautiful showโ Stace says. Time Out New York described the show, wonderfully, as โan awesome mythological beast.โ The same description could go for Staceโs whole career.
Comfort with risk is a key ingredient in Staceโs creativity, and lately it has led him toward an unexpected genre evolution. After decades of albums in the folk-rock lineage of Bob Dylanโwhose 1967 album John Wesley Harding inspired the name Stace used to record underโthe songwriter has moved toward jazz in Late Style on Omnivore Recordings.
โI just got to a bit of an impasse with my own kind of folk-rock albums,โ he says, โand I just was like, why canโt my music swing a bit more like the jazz that I listen to in the kitchen?โ
With artists that have successfully merged jazz, folk and pop in mindโJoni Mitchell, Mose Allison, Randy Newman, etc.โStace turned to long-time friend David Nagler for help breaking out of familiar folk chords, rhythms and melodies.
โI suddenly thought, why donโt I just give him some lyrics? Why donโt I just give up the tunes?โ he says. โBecause weโve been traveling in vans and cars and doing shows together for ten years, we speak the same music language. He knows what I want without me having to explain it for him.โ
The resulting album is smoother (and more relaxing to sing, according to Stace) than the rest of his oeuvre. The songs retain his signature playful storytelling, tinged this time with undertones of a pandemic. On โDo Nothing If You Can,โ for example, Stace snaps his fingers and croons a strangely menacing refrain: โHereโs the plan / Do nothing if you can.โ
A second album in this hybrid, jazzy domain is already deep in the works. Stace is enjoying the challenge of arranging the songs for his upcoming solo acoustic performances.
Oh, and heโs writing another novel, which will soon join Misfortune and the three others he has published. โIโm trying to make it the most beautiful thing I can possibly imagine writing, because I think lockdown affected us in those kind of ways. I just wanted everything to be nice and beautifulโthat everything would seduce you and be lovely.โ
I canโt help but wonder how this push toward polish and elegance in all his work of late squares with Staceโs longtime association with the rough world of rock โnโ roll. (This is the same musician who opened for and performed with Bruce Springsteen in the 90s.)
โThere are certain rock bands I love, but itโs generally not for that strutting-around-the-stage kind of thing. I donโt like that,โ he says. โWhat I like is brilliantly beautifully thought-out lyrics and songs. And they can be in any genre because I love words.โ
7pm, Jan. 24, Studio Judy G, 430 Main St. $20 donation, studiojudyg.com
HOMELAND San Jose native and self-taught guitarist, Castro rose to play with huge
names in the music scene before becoming one himself. Photo: Victoria Smith
Tommy in Town
By Bill Forman
From the Whoโs โTommyโ and โQuadropheniaโ to Green Dayโs โAmerican Idiotโ and Beyonceโs โLemonade,โ the pop music world has produced more than its fair share of rock operas and concept albums. But unless you count Muddy Watersโ โElectric Mudโโa psychedelic blues project that producer Marshall Chess described as โa concept album like David Bowie being Ziggy Stardustโโblues artists have steered clear of all of that.
So when Tommy Castro first hit upon the idea of writing and recording a blues operaโor, as he puts it, โsort of a blues operaโโhe was surprised that no one had thought to do it before. Soon, the six-time Blues Music Award winner was in the studio with Nashville producer Tom Hambridge, co-writing and recording tracks like โChild Donโt Go,โ โWomen, Drugs and Alcoholโ and โI Want to Go Back Homeโ for a concept album about an aspiring guitarist who leaves the family farm in search of success, gives in to the temptations of life on the road, and realizes that there is, in fact, no place like home.
โTommy Castro Presents A Bluesman Came to Townโโwhich came out in September 2021 on Alligator Records and debuted at No. 2 on the โBillboardโ magazine Blues Chartโmay not have the most original plotline, but that wasnโt really the point.
โI knew it wasnโt going to be as epic as, you know, the Whoโs โTommyโ or โThe Wallโ (by Pink Floyd) or โAmerican Idiot,โ where people had giant recording budgets and all kinds of amazing creativity,โ said the soulful singer and guitarist in a recent phone interview. โBut the idea of telling a story from the beginning to the end, that appealed to me. I kicked the idea around with the record label, and then I talked to my producer, who got really excited about the concept. So thatโs how it came about, and then it was just a matter of doing it and hoping it was good.โ
โA Bluesman Came to Townโ is also a departure for Castro because his band The Painkillers doesnโt play on it. โI usually prefer to use my own bandโIโve done that on 18 out of 19 recordsโbecause theyโre out on the road with me doing all the hard work,โ said Castro.
โBut Tom Hambridge wanted to use his studio guys, and heโs kind of a big deal. Heโs got a few Grammys under his belt, and heโs worked on the last few Buddy Guy albums, as well as with ZZ Top, George Thorogood, Johnny Winter and Joe Bonamassa, you know, a lot of people. So I kind of followed his lead on this album.โ
Since the albumโs release, Castro and the Painkillers have returned to the more than 150 shows per year schedule that the San Jose native has maintained for most of the past four decades. Along the way, heโs earned a loyal fan base as well as the respect of artists like John Lee Hooker, who did his final session on Castroโs โGuilty of Loveโ album. All of which still amazes him.
โWhere I grew up was a notch or two below a working-class neighborhood, and nobody there was going to college or getting music lessons or any of that stuff,โ said the self-taught guitarist, who spent his early years playing along to records by his favorite blues artists.
โI tend to like the slower guysโlike Michael Bloomfield, B.B. King, Albert King, Muddy Waters and Elmore Jamesโbecause I could figure out what they were doing,โ he said.
As time went on, Castro realized he was going to be making his living playing music. He tried taking guitar lessons and studied music theory. โBut it was too late,โ he said. โIโd already learned to play the way I did, and I couldnโt really switch over to the proper way of doing it.
โI still work on my guitar technique every day, trying to learn something new, even if itโs just some new licks,โ Castro said. โBut Iโm no virtuoso, Iโm no Bonamassa, Iโm not that kind of guitarist. Iโm more of a cross between John Lee Hooker and, I donโt know, Michael Bloomfield, maybe. Somewhere in there. I kind of just play the way I play, and it works for me, you know?โ
Yes, we do not give enough credit to the Indigenous people of our county . The Awaswas are long gone, but the Amah Mutsun are still here. and YES, they deserve the right to rename the college . The two campuses of our community college are ON THEIR LAND. Thanks for your continuing tribute to our predecessors on this land, and their contributions to our beautiful state of CA.
Steve L. Trujillo
CAR WORSHIP?
I am always fascinated by other people’s fascination with the internal combustion engine, which, when prettied up with a curvaceous body, fancy trim, custom wheels and a shiny paint job, suddenly becomes an object worthy of unquestioned worship. To see a group of car lovers staring slack-jawed with admiration while peering under the hood is to witness these lovers lost in cultish reverie.
Time to wake up. This god-awful thing that we call the automobile is responsible for more death and destruction, more despoiling of the environment, more checkerboard, unwalkable neighborhoods, more pollution, and more cost to our wallets and peace of mind than practically any other invention we’ve come up with. In fact, if Henry Ford had it all to do over again, he’d probably think twice. A car at rest is 3,000 pounds of potential violence. But when gussied up and showroom ready, it’s apparently a real thing of beauty.
Allow this contrary opinion: cars suck. And I own one of the damn things!
Tim Rudolph
Donโt Forget the Insurrection
As we mark the third anniversary of the January 6th insurrection, itโs important to remember how we got to that moment and who was responsible for it. Donald Trump and his allies engaged in a months-long criminal conspiracy after the 2020 election. They spread lies about voter fraud and used those lies to put pressure on state officials to illegally overturn election results. When their scheme to interfere with Congressโ certification of the 2020 election results failed, Trump and his co-conspirators incited a violent mob to attack the U.S. Capitol on January 6th, 2021.
MAGA Republicans nationwide have continued this assault on our democracy by introducing radical voter suppression bills in Congress and state legislatures, spreading false election conspiracy theories, and threatening to overturn election results they disagree with.
If Trump is re-elected, he plans to pardon himself and his supporters, use the Department of Justice to exact revenge on his enemies, and purge the federal government of anyone who doesnโt agree with him until thereโs no one left to say no.
Just last month, Trump said if he was reelected, he would attempt to be a dictator on โday one.โ We need to take him at his word. Itโs up to all of us to say no to a second Trump presidency before itโs too late.
ARIESMarch 21-April 19 Aries chemist Percy Julian (1899โ1975) was a trailblazer in creating medicine from plants. He patented over 130 drugs and laid the foundation for the production of cortisone and birth control pills. Julian was also a Black man who had to fight relentlessly to overcome the racism he encountered everywhere. I regard him as an exemplary member of the Aries tribe, since he channeled his robust martial urges toward constructive ends again and again and again. May he inspire you in the coming weeks, dear Aries. Donโt just get angry or riled up. Harness your agitated spirit to win a series of triumphs.
TAURUSApril 20-May 20 Taurus actor Pierce Brosnan says, โYou struggle with money. You struggle without money. You struggle with love. You struggle without love. But itโs how you manage. You have to keep laughing, you have to be fun to be with, and you have to live with style.โ Brosnan implies that struggling is a fundamental fact of everyday life, an insistent presence that is never far from our awareness. But if youโre willing to consider the possibility that his theory may sometimes be an exaggeration, I have good news: The coming months could be less filled with struggle than ever before. As you deal with the ease and grace, I hope you will laugh, be fun to be with, and live with styleโwithout having to be motivated by ceaseless struggle.
GEMINIMay 21-June 20 Gemini author and activist William Upski Wimsatt is one of my role models. Why? In part, because he shares my progressive political ideals and works hard to get young people to vote for enlightened candidates who promote social justice. Another reason I love him is that he aspires to have 10,000 role models. Not just a few celebrity heroes, but a wide array of compassionate geniuses working to make the world more like paradise. The coming weeks will be an excellent time for you to gather new role models, dear Gemini. I also suggest you look around for new mentors, teachers and inspiring guides.
CANCERJune 21-July 22 I want you to fulfill your desires! I want you to get what you want! I donโt think that yearnings are unspiritual indulgences that divert us from enlightenment. On the contrary, I believe our longings are sacred homing signals guiding us to our highest truths. With these thoughts in mind, here are four tips to enhance your quests in the coming months: 1. Some of your desires may be distorted or superficial versions of deeper, holier desires. Do your best to dig down and find their heart source. 2. To help manifest your desires, visualize yourself as having already accomplished them. 3. Welcome the fact that when you achieve what you want, your life will change in unpredictable ways. You may have to deal with a good kind of stress. 4. Remember that people are more likely to assist you in getting what you yearn for if youโre not greedy and grasping.
LEOJuly 23-Aug. 22 I regard Leo psychologist Carl Jung (1875โ1961) as a genius with a supreme intellect. Hereโs a quote from him that I want you to hear: โWe should not pretend to understand the world only by the intellect; we apprehend it just as much by feeling. Therefore, the judgment of the intellect is, at best, only the half of truth, and must, if it be honest, also come to an understanding of its inadequacy.โ You may already believe this wisdom in your gut, Leo. But like all of us, you live in a culture filled with authorities who value the intellect above feeling. So itโs essential to be regularly reminded of the bigger truthโespecially for you right now. To make righteous decisions, you must respect your feelings as much as your intellect.
VIRGOAug. 23-Sept. 22 Poet Rainer Maria Rilke exalted the physical pleasure that sex brings. He mourned that so many โmisuse and squander this experience and apply it as a stimulant to the tired spots of their lives and as a distraction instead of a rallying toward exalted moments.โ At its best, Rilke said, sex gives us โa knowing of the world, the fullness and the glory of all knowing.โ It is a sublime prayer, an opportunity to feel sacred communion on every level of our being. Thatโs the erotic experience I wish for you in the coming weeks, Virgo. And I believe you will have an expanded potential for making it happen.
LIBRASept. 23-Oct. 22 Even if you are currently bonded with a spouse or partner, I recommend you consider proposing matrimony to an additional person: yourself. Yes, dear Libra, I believe the coming months will be prime time for you to get married to your own precious soul. If youโre brave enough and crazy enough to carry out this daring move, devote yourself to it with lavish abandon. Get yourself a wedding ring, write your vows, conduct a ceremony, and go on a honeymoon. If youโd like inspiration, read my piece โI Me Wedโ: tinyurl.com/SelfMarriage
SCORPIOOct. 23-Nov. 21 Talking about a problem can be healthy. But in most cases, it should be a preliminary stage that leads to practical action; it shouldnโt be a substitute for action. Now and then, however, there are exceptions to this rule. Mere dialogue, if grounded in mutual respect, may be sufficient to dissolve a logjam and make further action unnecessary. The coming days will be such a time for you, Scorpio. I believe you and your allies can talk your way out of difficulties.
SAGITTARIUSNov. 22-Dec. 21 Sagittarian cartoonist Charles M. Schulz wrote, โMy life has no purpose, no direction, no aim, no meaning, and yet Iโm happy. I canโt figure it out. What am I doing right?โ I suspect that in 2024, you may go through a brief phase similar to his: feeling blank, yet quite content. But it wonโt last. Eventually, you will be driven to seek a passionate new sense of intense purpose. As you pursue this reinvention, a fresh version of happiness will bloom. For best results, be willing to outgrow your old ideas about what brings you gladness and gratification.
CAPRICORNDec. 22-Jan. 19 We all go through phases that feel extra plodding and pedestrian. During these times, the rhythms and melodies of our lives seem drabber than usual. The good news is that I believe you Capricorns will experience fewer of these slowdowns than usual in 2024. The rest of us will be seeing you at your best and brightest on a frequent basis. In fact, the gifts and blessings you offer may flow toward us in abundance. So itโs no coincidence if you feel exceptionally well-loved during the coming months. PS: The optimal way to respond to the appreciation you receive is to ratchet up your generosity even higher.
AQUARIUSJan. 20-Feb. 18 In the fall of 1903, The New York Times published an article that scorned human efforts to develop flying machines. It prophesied that such a revolutionary technology was still at least a million years in the futureโpossibly 10 million years. In conclusion, it declared that there were better ways to apply our collective ingenuity than working to create such an unlikely invention. Nine weeks later, Orville and Wilbur Wright disproved that theory, completing a flight with the airplane they had made. I suspect that you, Aquarius, are also primed to refute an expectation or prediction about your supposed limitations. (Afterward, try not to gloat too much.)
PISCESFeb. 19-March 20 Your sweat and tears are being rewarded with sweets and cheers. Your diligent, detailed work is leading to expansive outcomes that provide relief and release. The discipline youโve been harnessing with such panache is spawning breakthroughs in the form of elegant liberations. Congrats, dear Pisces! Donโt be shy about welcoming in the fresh privileges flowing your way. You have earned these lush dividends.
Homework: Indulge in “Healthy Obsessionsโโnot “Melodramatic Compulsions” or “Exhausting Crazes.โ
A group of people affected by the storms and floods that occurred in the area between Dec. 31, 2022 and March 11, 2023 have filed two lawsuits against various government entities alleging they did not take the proper measures to stop the damages caused by those disasters.
The lawsuits, filed on Dec. 22, 2023, was brought against Santa Cruz County, Monterey County, the City of Watsonville and the California Department of Transportation
The plaintiffs allege that the defendants allowed the flood control systems of the lower Pajaro River watershed to remain in a โstate of complete disrepair,โ even after 10 flood events that occurred in the decades after the levee system was built in 1949.
More than 500 plaintiffs are named in the lawsuits, from both Santa Cruz and Monterey counties. This includes property owners, renters and business owners. The suits were filed by Los Angeles-based Kabatek LLP, and El Segundo-based Greenberg and Ruby Injury Attorneys.
โOne of the most tragic parts about this is that the same thing happened decades ago, should have been fixed, should have been prevented, this was absolutely foreseeable and preventable,โ says attorney Emily Ruby, whose family lives in the Royal Oaks area.
The lawsuits took shape after the March 11 flood, during an informal community meetingโduring which no more than 15 people were expectedโwhich instead drew more than 70, Ruby says.
โWe just realized there was a huge need for help in that area,โ she says.
Governmental officials and agencies typically do not comment on pending litigation. As of press time Thursday, none had responded to requests for comment.
Ruby says the attorneys are seeking financial compensation for their clients that includes their losses, and for emotional damages.
โWe want to obtain justice for our clients, and for the community as a whole,โ she says. โWe want to have them compensated financially for all their damages and all their losses.โ
The trouble began on New Yearโs Eve 2023, when an atmospheric river storm swept through the Central Coast, swelling rivers and streams.
The Corralitos and Salsipuedes creeks overtopped their banks, sending flood water into several Watsonville neighborhoods, and filling many homes with mud, leaving residents with unlivable houses and hefty repair bills.
โThe community was completely shell-shocked and obviously devastated by what happened,โ Ruby says. โAnd there was no immediate response or support for them by the government entities who were responsible for this, and should have been jumping to be proactive about taking care of them.โ
At the heart of the lawsuit is the claim that after 10 flood events spanning from 1955 to 2018โwith a major one in 1995โstate and local officials should have been prepared to lessen or prevent the 2023 flood.
By the early 1990โs, the lawsuit alleges, the Pajaro Flood Control Project reached an โunprecedented state of disrepair,โ which heightened flood risks.
โThis never should have happened in 1995, and it never should have happened after 1995,โ Ruby says. โWe really want to make sure that this never happens again, that this community is never victimized again.โ
The Santa Cruz City Council voted unanimously on Tuesday to pass a version of the Wharf Master Plan that removed proposals for a controversial pedestrian pathway or large warehouse at the Santa Cruz Municipal Wharf.ย
The decision comes after years of litigation, with council members expressing a desire to move forward on applications for Federal and state funding. To do so, they removed plans for a controversial โLandmark Building,โ a 35 ft. warehouse at the end of the wharf, and a โWestern Walkway,โ a low-lying pedestrian pathway that would have also acted as a protective-barrier
The city has $6 million in funding from the Coastal Conservancy lined-up, pending the dismissal of the on-going lawsuit from Donโt Morph the Wharf.
In 2022, a court ruling found that the Wharf Master Plan violated the California Environmental Quality Act. Community-founded group Donโt Morph the Wharf brought forward the litigation, but agreed to forgo any future lawsuits if the Western Walkway was removed from the plan.
Supporters of the walkway, like ex-wharf Superintendent Jon Bambaci, marshaled a defense for the path, explaining its importance to the wharfโs structural integrity. The walkway would act as another emergency access point and block ocean-debris.ย
โWhile I like the Western Walkway, I am also going to support this because it is time we move on. We just need to protect the infrastructure,โ said Council Member Renee Golder.
Council Members Golder and Martine Watkins had not previously supported this version. Golder apologized to Council Member Sandy Brown for not supporting a similar measure Brown brought two years before.
In 2020, Brown was part of a minority that voted against the Wharf Master Plan, on the grounds that the Western Walkway and landmark building were opposed by members of the community. Brown expressed relief that now, her fellow council members and staff agreed with her.
The city plans to focus on new parking gates and expanding the Eastern Promenade for a 2026 construction start date, if the Coastal Commission approves the plan.
Gillian Greensite, leader of Donโt Morph the Wharf, said she was โsurprised and very pleasedโ with the councilโs decision. According to Greensite, โby dropping the walkway, the city has fulfilled the Writ. Nothing more to pursue.โ
The Santa Cruz City Council meeting erupted in emotion early Wednesday morning as attendees supporting a council resolution calling for a ceasefire in the ongoing Israel-Gaza war lambasted the city council for passing an amended version.
At around 3 a.m.โafter 10 hours of a public comment period that began at 5 p.m.โthe city council passed a resolution in a 5-2 vote that did not call for a ceasefire, but โaffirmed our shared humanity and wish for peace,โ and emphasized the cityโs commitment to peace.
The original resolution, drafted by council members Sonja Brunner and Sandy Brown, included language supporting a ceasefire. On Dec. 9, the city council directed Brunner and Brown to draft a resolution that delineated the city’s stance on the Israel-Gaza war. The direction came in response to hours of public comment where attendees called upon the council to formally declare a ceasefire.
The initial version of the resolution called for โa permanent, sustainable, and immediate ceasefire by all parties such that a future can be created where Palestinians and Israelis can live together with dignity in peace, equality, and justice.โ Additionally, it urged for the release of all hostages and for humanitarian aid to be let into Gaza.
Around 300 people spoke during public comment, with the majority making statements supportive of the ceasefire resolution as it was originally drafted.
Sometime around 3 a.m., council member Scott Newsome made a motion to replace the original resolution with a substitute version drafted ahead of the meeting. No language related to a ceasefire was included in that version.
In response, pro-Palestinian activists in attendance then proceeded to shout at the council members in a show of dismay over the move. In a video posted to Palestine Solidarity Central Coastโs Instagram page, people can be heard in the council chambers yelling and denouncing individual council members.
There were multiple police officers at the meeting, and as the crowd became agitated, officers stepped in to clear the chambers. During the uproar, individuals in the crowd also threw objects at council members.
โOfficers were on scene all night, people were throwing food and their signs,โ said Santa Cruz Police Department spokesperson Joyce Blaschke.
Blaschke also said that two windows were broken inside the council chambers.
After the chambers were cleared, the council approved Newsomeโs motion and proceeded to vote on the amended resolution. The council voted to pass a โPeace Resolution.โ Brunner and Brown opposed the resolution.
Mayor Fred Keeley was among those that voted in favor of the amended โPeace Resolution.โ
โWe received 10 hours of testimony on both sides of this and then the council made their decision. I’m comfortable with the decision I made. I very much support peace in the Middle East. I think it is a resolution that makes it clear that Santa Cruz is on the side of peace. I can also understand the disappointment of those who wanted a ceasefire resolution rather than a peace resolution,โ Keely said.
โI took the vote that I’m comfortable with that states my values,โ he said.
Meanwhile Brown said she was disappointed with the voteโs outcome.
โItโs hard to find words to describe the feeling of last nightโs council meeting. Of course I was disappointed by the outcome, after spending so much time in dialogue to try to craft a resolution that responded to differing perspectives and concerns. However, Iโm heartened that so many people showed up (many standing outside in the rain and cold for over 7 hours) to share their experiences and pain over the violence, suffering, and profound humanitarian crisis unfolding in Palestine and Israel,โ said Brown.
Musically, this month looks like July. Weโve got great national and local talents coming through. Wynton Marsalis says a singer like Cecile McLorin Salvant only comes through โonce in a generation or twoโ.
Spontaneity is Key
By DAN EMERSON
Calling Cecile McLorin Salvant a jazz singer is kind of like calling Donald Trump a realtor. It's a woefully incomplete description. Salvant is a jazz singer, but much more than that. As a vocalist, composer, bandleader, visual artist and filmmaker, the term โmultidimensional artistโ has been used more than once to describe her and really...
Yes, we do not give enough credit to the Indigenous people of our county . The Awaswas are long gone, but the Amah Mutsun are still here. and YES, they deserve the right to rename the college.
ARIES March 21-April 19Aries chemist Percy Julian (1899โ1975) was a trailblazer in creating medicine from plants. He patented over 130 drugs and laid the foundation for the production of cortisone and birth control pills. Julian was also a Black man who had to fight relentlessly to overcome the racism he encountered everywhere. I regard him as an exemplary member...
The Santa Cruz City Council voted unanimously on Tuesday to pass a version of the Wharf Master Plan that removed proposals for a controversial pedestrian pathway or large warehouse at the Santa Cruz Municipal Wharf.ย
The decision comes after years of litigation, with council members expressing a desire to move forward on applications for Federal and state funding. To do...
The Santa Cruz City Council meeting erupted in emotion early Wednesday morning as attendees supporting a council resolution calling for a ceasefire in the ongoing Israel-Gaza war lambasted the city council for passing an amended version.
At around 3 a.m.โafter 10 hours of a public comment period that began at 5 p.m.โthe city council passed a resolution in a 5-2...