WATSONVILLEโSanta Cruz METRO has taken a big step in combating greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions with the launch of two new electric buses, which will operate on a new route through the city of Watsonville.
On Tuesday METRO staff, along with city officials, representatives from electric vehicle technology manufacturer Proterra and other community members gathered at the Watsonville Transit Center to celebrate the unveiling of the new buses.
METRO CEO Alex Clifford said that the introduction of the fleet has been years in the making. In 2018, the agency received funding for four e-buses for the countyโtwo of which would be used in Watsonville.
But as the deal was being made, a new generation of Proterra buses was unveiled. The new vehicle had a much more efficient charging time, with the capability of traveling between 205 and 329 miles per charge.
โOur aspiration is to always have as long a range as possible,โ Clifford said. โOnce we pull out that bus in the morning, we want it to run all day. So this was a blessing.โ
Since 2002, METRO has been ahead of the curve with adopting sustainable bus fleets. This began with moving to buses that use compressed natural gas, followed by hybrid vehicles. The agency was awarded a federal grant in 2015 for its first three electric buses, which are now in use on the Highway 17 Express service.
In 2017, the agency adopted a goal of achieving a fully zero-emissions fleet by 2040โone full year before the state mandated the same.
โThe buses provide an opportunity for METRO to further explore the use of zero-emission vehicles,โ said Donna Lind, a member of the METRO board who also serves on the Scotts Valley City Council. โThe project will contribute to sustainable transportation, reducing miles traveled, GHG emissions and congestion.โ
Lind thanked the Regional Transportation Commission, CalTrans, the California Air Resources Board, METROโs grant team, her fellow board members and other local and state partners for securing funding for the project.
Proterraโs Regional Sales Director Mark Hollenback called the moment a โhistoric dayโ for Santa Cruz County. The company, which designs, engineers and manufactures entirely in the United States, is headquartered just over the hill in Burlingame.
โItโs great to be here, in our home turf in Northern California, to help Santa Cruz and the city of Watsonville mark the deployment of your new buses,โ he said.
Hollenback alluded to the importance of green technology, and counties like Santa Cruz that are taking action to utilize it. Every time a Proterra e-bus replaces an e-bus, he said, about 230,000 pounds of carbon pollution are avoided each year.
โWeโve witnessed, just in the past few weeks, the growing signs of climate change,โ he said. โThe importance of zero-emissions transportation has never been clearer.โ
Watsonville Mayor Jimmy Dutra has been a member of METROโs board since 2014. He and others lobbied for years, locally, statewide and to the federal government to procure the buses and the infrastructure for them.
โWe told the stories of Watsonville โฆ from our farmworkers, who depend on this as their only mode of transportation,โ he said. โTo our seniors using this to go to their doctorโs appointments and get their medication. Or our students, who use this to go to Cabrillo and UCSC โฆ The only way they can get an education is to use this bus system.โ
The buses will run on a new route known as the circulator, which will connect the Watsonville transit center with primary retail and medical destinations within the city, both clockwise and counter-clockwise. It will roll along Main and Lincoln streets, Green Valley Road and Freedom Boulevard, connecting commuters with other bus routes.
Clifford called the new route โvery unique,โ referring to how it runs both clockwise and counter-clockwise.
โWe donโt do anything like this anywhere else in the system,โ he said. โItโs very new for us. Weโre so excited to start the circulator.โ
The service begins Sept. 16 and will run seven days a week with 16 daily round trips. For the first year of operation, rides on the circulator will be free of charge. This, said Clifford, is to encourage as many people as possible to use it.
โWeโre hoping to build ridership fast, and keep it going,โ he said.
Added Dutra: โWe envision this route becoming a critical link for our community.โ
For information about the circulator route, visit scmtd.com.
The hubbub at the Santa Cruz County Courthouse Tuesday morning was so loud a sheriffโs deputy had to tell the 50-plus Bonny Doon community members to pipe down.
They were awaiting a hearing on whether or not convicted rapist Michael Cheek would be allowed to move in, upon release from a state psychiatric institution, and they were united.
โHe just doesnโt belong in the neighborhood,โ said John Ancic, a 74-year-old Bonny Doon resident of the Pine Ridge area, on the concrete steps outside the courthouse. โItโs just not a place for him to be.โ
Reminiscent of an airport checkpoint, the metal detector line snaked out to the courtyard.
Outside Department 6, 60-year-old Stephanie Jessen, whoโs lived in Bonny Doon for 40 years, said the crowd size surprised herโbut not because so many showed up.
โI was expecting a little bit more,โ she said. โWhen things come down the pike, we stand together.โ
In August 1997, Cheek was committed to the Department of State Hospitals, in Coalinga, and in 2009, was officially deemed a violent sexual predator.
Officials say Cheek has been successfully progressing through the stateโs rehab program for sex offenders, and Santa Cruz County Superior Court Judge Stephen Siegel ordered Cheekโs conditional release on Oct. 7, 2019.
But Bonny Doon residents are outraged about his possible move to the area, particularly given the realities of life in the remote reaches of the Santa Cruz Mountains, where families are still reeling from last yearโs devastating fires.
Santa Cruz Superior Court Judge Syda Cogliati ultimately gave Cheek and his representatives until Sept. 30 to address the additional questions raised about the location and set the next hearing for Oct. 14 at 9am. She also ordered the company representing Cheek to seek another home for him, as an additional option.
When Judge Cogliati called Cheek to court via Zoom around 9am, he was nowhere to be found.
โIโm reluctant to go forward,โ the judge said.
Rob Cureton, the clinical director of the stateโs Conditional Release Program for Sexually Violent Predators (CONREP SVP), said heโd try to reach Cheek.
The judge ordered him to do so and called the opposing lawyers to her chambers.
Around 9:20am, Cureton was able to patch Cheek through.
โOK, Iโm on the phone,โ Cheek said. โSorry.โ
The judge started by giving those in attendance a heads up that she wouldnโt be dealing with whether or not Cheek should stay locked up in a mental health care facilityโthat had already been decided (and not appealed to a higher authority) two years back.
And, she said, the same thing goes for his ability to reside in Santa Cruz County, and whether or not the government should have to pay his rent.
What is left to be determined, she explained, was if she should approve Cheekโs proposed move to a Wild Iris Lane address.
Judge Cogliati acknowledged the โhundredsโ of messages she received from the communityโnone of which supported Cheekโs plan to move in.
โI did read, and consider, that public comment,โ she said, adding, while itโs โextremely importantโ she doesnโt allow them to sway her perspective, she said they did raise important points.
โTodayโs hearing is about those issues,โ she said.
This step was to decide if Liberty Healthcare Corp., the company in charge of CONREP for sex offenders since 2003, could properly supervise Cheek at the remote Santa Cruz Mountains site.
Judge Cogliati had received, within the previous 24 hours, responses to questions about how Liberty might manage Cheekโs release effectively.
โI just want to say thereโs still additional issues outstanding,โ she said.
One Liberty rep talked up the companyโs 24/7 security detail provided automatically during the first month of release, a โGPS domeโ that creates a geofence with a 75-foot radius around the house, and video monitoring she could order.
Judge Cogliati asked about the policing response time in the area, which the sheriffโs office has admitted is quite slow, given Cheekโs crimes put him โon the very high, high endโ of the sex-predator spectrum.
The Liberty rep said while itโs โnot at all ideal,โ 35-45 minutes is not out of the ordinary for some of the places they place reforming sex criminals.
Judge Cogliati asked how the company would monitor Cheek if the power went out, eliminating GPS capabilities.
The rep explained there would be a generator on the property Cheek can turn on with the flip of a switch.
A slight gasp was audible from the crowd, where about 20-30 people had squeezed in under modified Covid-19, 3-foot social-distancing rules.
โYouโre not in the courtroom to hear the sounds that just went through the courtroom,โ Cogliati said, asking for further clarification.
โWe believe that Mr. Cheek will comply with the terms and conditions,โ the rep said, promising the company would dispatch someone to the location โas soon as thereโs an electrical outage,โ and pledged theyโd establish a line of communication via satellite telephone.
โThis is a highly-compliant individual, and a highly-treated individual,โ he said.
According to the judge, community concerns not addressed by Libertyโs assessment included a home-based school in the area, a bus stop for school children nearby and the trailhead of a popular hiking route located not far from the residence.
The rep said their investigations turned up no evidence of a school on the street, and said Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park appeared to be quite far away.
Deputy District Attorney Alex Byers asked the rep to confirm that, if Cheek somehow dropped out of the treatment program, โhis risk would be highโ to reoffend.
โThat is correct,โ the rep said.
Byers said there were more than 900 public comments submitted.
โThey brought forth most of the issues weโre talking about today,โ he said. โThese issues canโt be remedied.โ
After all, itโs not like you can suddenly make Bonny Doon less remote, he said.
โThose roads close all the time; the power goes out all the time,โ he said. โWe share the Bonny Doon communityโs concern that this is a high risk.โ
If, indeed, there is a school nearby, placing Cheek on Wild Iris Lane would technically be illegal, he added.
โI see a one-size-fits-all plan,โ Byers said, adding locals werenโt happy the companyโs approach wasnโt more tailored to the reality of life in the Santa Cruz Mountains. โThis is our place. This is Bonny Doon.โ
After the hearing, 58-year-old Laurie Sage, who lives just over the ridgeline in Brookdale, said she believes Cheek doesnโt belong in her neck of the woods.
โIโm actually for rehousing criminals that need another chance,โ she said. โI absolutely believe in it.โ
But, she says, Libertyโs current plan isnโt realistic, something that was underscored for her by a PG&E outage she says she experienced that very morning.
โThere are 30 trucks on my road trying to restore the power today,โ she said. โIt goes on and off, on and off, on and off.โ
And, speaking as a grief counselor whoโs been quite busy in the last year, Sage adds thereโs plenty of anxiety rippling through the redwoods, already.
โWe canโt have this in our community while weโre still in crisis from the CZU lighting fire,โ she said.
But the dayโs hearing hit even closer to homeโliterallyโfor the teenage girls in the hallway pondering the judgeโs ruling. Thatโs because 14-year-old identical twins Zoey and Nina live on Wild Iris Lane.
It was Zoeyโs first time attending court, so on the one hand she said it was โvery coolโ to experience such an official process in person.
But on the other hand, it was under โless than idealโ circumstances, considering the case was about whether a sexual predator gets to live down the street from her and her sister.
Plus, Zoey says she didnโt appreciate what appeared, to her, to be โdeflectingโ comments by the Liberty reps.
โThis situation is really chaotic,โ she said, thinking ahead to what they might do if Cheek gets his wish. โWeโre going to have to move out.โ
Thatโs because of how far away it is from help, her sister Nina chimed in.
โIt takes, like, ages to get up there,โ she said, โโ30 minutes on a good day.โ
But they feel even worse for their 14-year-old neighbor Elise. She lives right across the street.
โItโs completely ridiculous,โ Elise said of Libertyโs plan. โAny other place would be better than that one.โ
Elise says she felt the judge handled the case โpretty wellโ given the heightened emotions at play.
However, she wishes Cheek wasnโt given more time to argue why he should be allowed to become her newest neighbor.
โI wouldnโt feel safe at all,โ she said. โAnd thatโs not fair.โ
ANTHONY ARYA BIRTHDAY CELEBRATION SHOW & SPECIAL ACOUSTIC LIVE RECORDING Felton Music Hall Presents Anthony Arya Birthday Celebration and Going Away Party with a live music recording. Anthony Arya is a singer, guitarist and songwriter raised in Santa Cruz, California. In Fall 2018, at age 15, Anthony was on Season 15 of NBCโs The Voice. Shortly after he released his debut album Going To California. His second album, The Road followed a year later in 2020. Arya was awarded the 2020 Presidential Scholar in the Arts in the category of singer/songwriter. Recently he released Listen to The Voice of Anthony Arya, a collection of songs he performed on The Voice and for the auditions. Don’t miss this special solo acoustic show on Anthony’s birthday, which will be recorded live before Anthony heads off to college. $12 advance and $14 day of show. This is a fully seated show; seating will be first-come-first-served. Tickets: available at anthonyarya.com/events/felton-music-hall-presents-an-evening-with-anthony-arya-for-a-live-music-recording-1 . Monday, Sept. 13, 8pm. Felton Music Hall, 6275 Hwy. 9, Felton.
BANFF CENTRE MOUNTAIN FILM FESTIVAL VIRTUAL FESTIVAL Bring the adventure home! Fluff up your couch cushions, grab a snack of choice, and make sure you have a good internet connection because the Banff Centre Mountain Film Festival World Tour is virtual! Travel to the most remote corners of the world, dive into daring expeditions, and celebrate some of the most remarkable outdoor achievements, all from the comfort of your living room. Films can be purchased individually or as a bundle. Banff will also be screening Award Winners: Monthly Film Series; join us online for a mixed program of award winners from the 2020, 2019 and 2018 Banff Centre Mountain Film and Book Festivals. Catch up on missed films or relive some of the best that Banff has to offer. Just announced is the Encore Classic Films from the past 10 years. Audience favorites. Don’t miss out! Screening until Oct. 24, 2021. Visit riotheatre.com for more information about the online programs and how you can support your local screening. You may also go directly to the Banff affiliate link for the Rio filmfest.banffcentre.ca/?campaign=WT-163945. Rio Theatre, 1205 Soquel Ave., Santa Cruz.
SHEDM: THE FEMALE CREATORS OF DANCE MUSIC Sundays: DJs are mixing in the darkest bass beats by our favorite female and LGBT producers. Donโt miss out. Starts at 9pm. Guest DJs every week. Motiv nightclub is open and fully remodeledโthere are all-new bathrooms and state-of-the-art dance floor lights. Add to your calendar: facebook.com/events/3008160246139834. Sunday, Sept. 12, 9pm. Motiv, 1209 Pacific Ave., Santa Cruz.
DOWNTOWN SANTA CRUZ ANTIQUE FAIRE The Santa Cruz Antique Faire is on the second Sunday of every month from 8am-5pm. Vendors offer an eclectic blend of antiques and unique items, vintage clothing, collectibles, LPs, clothing, furniture, memorabilia, home decor and more! Sunday, Sept. 12, 9am-5pm. Downtown Santa Cruz Antique Faire, Lincoln St. between Pacific and Cedar, Santa Cruz.
COMMUNITY
GREY BEARS BROWN BAG LINE Grey Bears are looking for help with their brown bag production line on Thursday and Friday mornings. Volunteers will receive breakfast and a bag of food if wanted. Be at the warehouse with a mask and gloves at 7am. Call ahead for more information: 831-479-1055, greybears.org. Thursday, Sept. 9, 7am. California Grey Bears, 2710 Chanticleer Ave., Santa Cruz.
SANTA CRUZ BLOCK PARTY FOR CLEAN WATER The Santa Cruz Block Party will be an evening full of local food, drinks, music, art, and community! Jam to Matt Masih & The Messengers and get your creative juices flowing with our Community Art Mural hosted by the Made Fresh Crew. Enjoy food by Sauceyโz Food Truck, beer provided by Shanty Shack and HumbleSea and wine by Water from Wine. Enter our raffle to win exclusive prizes provided by local businesses, artists, and more! All proceeds from the event will go towards Gravity Waterโs work abroad building clean water projects to provide access to underserved students in Nepal and Vietnam. Come join us in celebrating the end of the summer in support of a great cause! For more details and ticket information, check out our website: gravitywater.org/events.html Sunday, Sept. 12, 4-8pm. Edgewater Events, 535 7th Ave, Santa Cruz (behind Harbor Cafe).
GROUPS
COMMUNITY PILATES MAT CLASS Come build strength with us. This very popular in-person community Pilates Mat Class in the big auditorium at Temple Beth El in Aptos is in session once again. Please bring your own mat, small Pilates ball and Theraband if you have one. You must be vaccinated for this indoor class. Suggested donation of $10/class is welcome. Thursday, Sept. 9, 10am. Tuesday, Sept. 14, 10am. Temple Beth El, 3055 Porter Gulch Road, Aptos.
COMPASSIONATE FRIENDS OF SANTA CRUZ Parents of a child who died at any age, from any cause, any length of time ago, are invited to join The Compassionate Friends of Santa Cruz for our monthly grief support meeting. Opening circle followed by smaller connection groups. Sharing is optional. Grief materials are available. Bereaved grandparents and adult siblings are also welcome. Non-religious. Monday, Sept. 13, 7-8:30pm. Quaker Meeting House, 225 Rooney St., Santa Cruz.
ENTRE NOSOTRAS GRUPO DE APOYO Entre Nosotras support group for Spanish speaking women with a cancer diagnosis. Meets twice monthly. Registration required, please call Entre Nosotras 831-761-3973. Friday, Sept. 10, 6pm. WomenCARE, 2901 Park Ave., Suite A1, Soquel.
S+LAA MENS’ MEETING Having trouble with compulsive sexual or emotional behavior? Recovery is possible. Our small 12-step group meets Saturday evenings. Enter through the front entrance, go straight down the hallway to the last door on the right. Thursday, Sept. 9, 6pm. Sutter Maternity & Surgery Center, 2900 Chanticleer Ave., Santa Cruz.
WOMENCARE ARM-IN-ARM WomenCARE Arm-in-Arm Cancer support group for women with advanced, recurrent, or metastatic cancer. Meets every Monday at WomenCAREโs office. Currently on Zoom. Registration is required, call WomenCARE at 831-457-2273. All services are free. For more information visit womencaresantacruz.org. Monday, Sept. 13, 12:30pm. WomenCARE, 2901 Park Ave., Suite A1, Soquel.
WOMENCARE TUESDAY SUPPORT GROUP WomenCARE Tuesday Cancer support group for women newly diagnosed and through their treatment. Meets every Tuesday currently on Zoom. Registration required, call WomenCARE 831-457-2273. Tuesday, Sept. 14, 12:30-2pm. WomenCARE, 2901 Park Ave., Suite A1, Soquel.
WOMENCARE: LAUGHTER YOGA Laughter yoga for women with a cancer diagnosis. Meets every Wednesday, currently via Zoom. Registration is required, please call WomenCARE at 831-457-2273. Wednesday, Sept. 8, 3:30-4:30pm. WomenCARE, 2901 Park Ave., Suite A1, Soquel.
OUTDOOR
CASFS FARMSTAND Organic vegetables, fruit, herbs and flowers are sold weekly at the CASFS Farmstand, starting June 15 and continuing through Nov. 23. Proceeds support experiential education programs at the UC Santa Cruz Center for Agroecology & Sustainable Food Systems. Friday, Sept. 10, Noon-6pm. Tuesday, Sept. 14, Noon-6pm. Cowell Ranch Historic Hay Barn, Ranch View Road, Santa Cruz.
EVERGREEN AT DUSK: CEMETERY HISTORY TOURS Welcome back to our second year of Evergreen at Dusk historical tours. We invite you to discover the stories and secrets found within Evergreen Cemetery, one of the oldest public cemeteries in California, on a self-guided or private tour of the grounds. Bring your curiosity as you explore the final resting place of Santa Cruz’s early settlers. The 45-minute tour uncovers the stories and tombstones of the people who made Santa Cruz what it is today. Designed for the daring, the curious, and the history-loving, this tour is great for all ages! Each tour should take 30-45 minutes to complete. The time you select is when your group/household tour begins, we recommend arriving 5-10 minutes early to ensure you can begin right on time. Upon arrival, find the MAH table near the iconic Evergreen Arch. We will give you the printed map and guide with a brief introduction to Evergreen. Following the welcome, you are then free to follow the scavenger hunt map and travel back in time uncovering the stories buried across the grounds. Go at your own pace and begin your adventure. We’ll be there on-site to help you get from tombstone to tombstone if assistance is needed. Please note that Evergreen Cemetery is currently not ADA accessible. Thursday, Sept. 9, 4-7pm. Evergreen Cemetery, 261 Evergreen St., Santa Cruz.
SEYMOUR CENTER OUTDOORS! Activities include tide pool investigation: hone your observation skills and watch animals such as sea stars, sea urchins, and hermit crabs gracefully move in their environment; outdoor scavenger hunt: explore the pathway of giants and find nine outdoor objects hidden around the Seymour Center; larval fish geocache: why do baby fish look so different from their adult forms? What kinds of strategies do fish use for raising their young? And just what kind of fish live in Monterey Bay anyway? Find the answers to these questions in five secret containers located throughout the Coastal Science Campus. Marine Animal Selfie Station: Grab a selfie with one of our life-sized wooden marine animalsโbe sure to use #SeymourCenter on your social media profiles. The Seymour Center Outdoors is free to visit with a suggested $10 donation per household. Become a sustaining supporter of the Seymour Center, and purchase a membership! To learn more visit seymourcenter.ucsc.edu/visit. Saturday, Sept. 11, 11am-2pm. Seymour Marine Discovery Center, 100 McAllister Way, Santa Cruz.
SUNSET BEACH BOWLS Experience the tranquility, peace and calmness as the ocean waves harmonize with the sound of crystal bowls raising vibration and energy levels. Every Tuesday one hour before sunset at Moran Lake Beach. Call 831-333-6736 for more details. Tuesday, Sept. 14, 7:15-8:15pm. Moran Lake Park & Beach, East Cliff Drive, Santa Cruz.
YOU PICK ROSES We are growing over 300 roses, deeply fragrant, lush and in every color, and we want to share them with you! Get out of the house and enjoy cutting a bucket of roses for your pleasure or to share with family and friends. Visit birdsongorchards.com to make a reservation. Once you have made a purchase, you will be sent a calendar link to pick a time for your reservation and directions to our farm in Watsonville. Friday, Sept. 10, 11am. Sunday, Sept. 12, 11am.
Even the biggest fans of Texas singer-songwriter Guy Clarkโof which there are many in these parts, thanks to the fact that heโs a KPIG favorite who played many shows here over the years for Snazzy Productionsโare likely to find a lot of surprises in Tamara Savianoโs Without Getting Killed or Caught. I am one of them, in fact, and I can attest that my fellow Clark fans are actually the most likely to be surprised by what comes out in the documentary, which screens on Sept. 15 at the Rio Theater, since weโre the ones who probably thought we had a good understanding of his story and his art.
But after seeing Savianoโs film, I have to admit there was a lot about Clark I didnโt know, and some of the ways Iโve always thought about his music are, it turns out, exactly the opposite of how he wanted to be seen.
For instance, youโd imagine the man who wrote โStuff That Works,โ had albums titled Boats to Build and Workbench Songs, and was known for his woodworking (especially his guitars) would have fully embracedโif not created himselfโthe image that rose up around him as a song โcraftsman.โ But incredibly, he hated it.
โGuy and I had a lot of discussions about this,โ Saviano tells me. โWhen it came to his songwriting, he wanted to be known as a poet and an artist. He thought of himself as a craftsman when he was building guitars, but he just thought that songwriting is art and poetry, and there’s no, you know, craft to it. I disagree, and I’ve talked to many other songwriters who think the same thingโyes, it’s an art, but you do craft. Especially with Guyโs songs, because every word mattered, every line mattered. So it was odd to me that he felt that way.โ
The film also tells Clarkโs personal story, through the eyes of his wife Susanna Clark (narrator Sissy Spacek reads convincingly from her journals), who was a successful songwriter herself. In a way, the film is as much a documentary about Susanna, and also about their close friend and fellow Texas songwriter Townes Van Zandt. It provides a window into the sweet and tender side of Van Zandt, which came out most in how he related to the people he loved; this warm look at the troubled Texas musical legend is completely different in tone than the 2004 Van Zandt documentary Be Here to Love Me.
This trio of subjects is at the center of Without Getting Killed or Caughtโs most startling revelation: that there was basically a love triangle between the three of them, with Susanna deeply committed to both Guy and Van Zandt, in different ways. โI think what blew my mind the most is that they were all just so nonchalant about it,โ says Saviano. โIโm 20 years younger than Guy, so I grew up in a different time. But they were in the โ60s, all the free love, and they just didn’t feel the same way about monogamy that some of us feel. Townes and Susanna had this cosmic connection, they were both much more vulnerable. Guy was very stoic, and I think Townes took some of the pressure off of Guy. Guy really wanted to focus on his songwriting and focus on his career. Thereโs no doubt he loved Susanna. They loved each other. But Townes could just take up some of that slack.โ
With co-writer Bart Knaggs, Saviano adapted the documentary from her biography, Without Getting Killed or Caught: The Life and Music of Guy Clark, which came out in 2016, the same year Clark passed away after battling cancer for years. Her co-director Paul Whitfield, whoโs worked on a number of Bruce Springsteen documentaries and concert films, is also her husband.
Saviano began working with Clark on her book in 2008, and co-produced the tribute album This Oneโs For Him: A Tribute to Guy Clark in 2011. At that point, she had no idea she would also be making a film.
โI had no intention of doing a documentary,โ she says. โI was going to write a book, and that was going to be it. But what happened was in 2014, a filmmaker approached Guy about doing a documentary, and Guy was telling me about it. And he just said, โLook, I donโt want to start over with someone new. You already know everything. If thereโs going to be a documentary about me, I think you need to do it.โโ
In other words, Without Getting Killed or Caughtโwhich features interviews with Rodney Crowell, Steve Earle, Terry Allen, and many othersโis a true labor of love.
โI thought, โWell, okay, [Guyโs] not going to let anybody else do it. I’m kind of stuck with the job, right? So I asked my husband Paul, who is a video guy and a production guy, if he would work on it with me. Of course, I had no idea how expensive and difficult it would be when we startedโitโs so hard to make a film like this. But Iโm really glad we did it. Weโre really proud of it. And we want everybody that loved Guy to see this film.โ
โWithout Getting Killed or Caughtโ will be shown at 7:30pm on Wednesday, Sept. 15 at the Rio Theatre, 1205 Soquel Ave., Santa Cruz. Tickets are $15, go to snazzyproductions.com. Proof of vaccination or a negative Covid test taken within 72 hours of the show are required.
In California as well as the U.S., greenhouse gas emissions from transportation are going up instead of down. People are driving more. This outweighs improvements in vehicle efficiency. Does this reflect a moral failing? Are more people deciding to drive rather than walk to close destinations? Or are there systemic reasons? Evidence suggests the increase in vehicle miles traveled is due to poor land-use planning, as well as high housing prices.
In Santa Cruz County, the high cost of housing near job centers is causing longer commutes, according to UCSC commute studies. Poor land-use planning is exemplified by the application to locate a large medical office building in Live Oak, across Highway 1 from Sutter Hospital and Dominican. Itโs a mile to the nearest bus stop on Capitola Road. This location makes a transit commute impractical, forcing up transportation costs for employees who drive.
In recognition of its auto-dependent location, the plan calls for a 730 space parking garage, becoming the largest garage in the county, surpassing the 500-space garage at UCSC.
A far better location for the facility would be on the other side of the highway: the 6.2-acre vacant lot at the corner of Soquel Dr. and Thurber Lane, a block from Dominican Hospital. This location has the highest frequency transit service outside of the Downtown-to-UCSC route. The county recently won a grant for transit, bike and pedestrian improvements on Soquel Drive. This includes bus prioritization at 23 traffic signals between La Fonda Avenue and State Park Drive, protected bike lanes, and sidewalk and crosswalk improvements.
Though the Draft Environmental Impact Report for this project does not mention Kaiser, it is no secret that Kaiser is the prospective tenant for this building. The Draft EIR makes a remarkable claim. In spite of its massive parking structure and location in a transit desert, the EIR claims that the new facility will result in a net reduction in vehicle miles traveled. The EIR figures that Kaiser patients who would have traveled out of the county for appointments will now be staying local. The problem with this logic is that there is no proposed condition on this project that limits tenancy to Kaiser. Further, it cannot be assumed that a Kaiser tenant would not expand its membership based upon its increased service capacity in Santa Cruz County.
The possibility that the future tenant would be Kaiser does not absolve the EIR from its obligation under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) to examine an alternative to the project that would have lower environmental impact. Incredibly, the EIR minimizes the benefit of locating the facility on Soquel Drive, a major transit corridor: โTransit use for medical services would be minimal.โ
Our county leaders should be able to make a good decision without a community group resorting to a lawsuit. Will our Board of Supervisors approve a project that violates the General Plan policy: โEncourage โฆ land use patterns which reduce urban sprawl and encourage the reduction of vehicle miles traveled per personโ?
Rick Longinotti | Co-chair, Campaign for Sustainable Transportation
This letter does not necessarily reflect the views of Good Times.To submit a letter to the editor of Good Times: Letters should be originalsโnot copies of letters sent to other publications. Please include your name and email address to help us verify your submission (email address will not be published). Please be brief. Letters may be edited for length, clarity and to correct factual inaccuracies known to us. Send letters to le*****@*******es.sc.
Re: โWild Rideโ (GT, 8/25): Just read your article about the huge Santa Cruz Ride Out biking event in Santa Cruz Saturday. We donโt appreciate your minimizing the lawlessness and mayhem that this event created in our town. From the top down, from organizers to the participants, this event was a show of disrespect to our town and our citizens. The inability of our law enforcement agencies to stop, contain or even manage and protect our streets exposes our town as a soft target. Litter, aggressive behavior and intimidation was their overall rule of the day. The โKarenโ comment directed at anyone that was offended pretty much tells us what their real intentions are in staging the event here.
Kenny Jay
Santa Cruz
This letter does not necessarily reflect the views of Good Times.To submit a letter to the editor of Good Times: Letters should be originalsโnot copies of letters sent to other publications. Please include your name and email address to help us verify your submission (email address will not be published). Please be brief. Letters may be edited for length, clarity and to correct factual inaccuracies known to us. Send letters to le*****@*******es.sc.
This week is sort of an unofficial Americana Issue, thanks to Adam Josephโs cover story on Ramblinโ Jack Elliott, and my feature on the new Guy Clark documentary Without Getting Killed or Caught. Granted, we could put out an outlaw-country-folk-themed issue just about every week in Santa Cruz thanks to the musicโs rich history here, and constant influx of touring and local Americana talent, but with Elliott coming to Moeโs Alley this month, and Tamara Savianoโs documentary screening at the Rio on Sept. 15, this is a chance to dive in to the history of two music legends.
Joseph dives deep in his cover story, and he brings an appropriately freewheeling feel to his profile of 90-year-old maverick Elliott. Interestingly, one of the musicians he quotes when discussing Ramblinโ Jackโs influence is Clark, who once said he picked up โthat talking thingโ in his songwriting from Elliott. Without Getting Killed or Caught, in turn, delves into Clarkโs influence on other songwriters, and packs plenty of surprises in regards to the Texas singer-songwriterโs life and work. It also has a great section on the rise of Americana music in the โ90s, when Clark reached a new level of critical and popular appreciation, and fans who were around here in that era will remember the thrill of that time. But whether you were or not, I think the stories in this issue capture the raw, unpredictable energy that makes us love the music so much.
ย
STEVE PALOPOLI | EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
PHOTO CONTEST WINNER
Submit to ph****@*******es.sc. Include information (location, etc.) and your name. Photos may be cropped. Preferably, photos should be 4 inches by 4 inches and minimum 250dpi.
GOOD IDEA
ROAM IMPROVEMENT
For anyone interested in working on the hiking trails that wind through Santa Cruzโs redwoods, the Trail Academy is offering free trail building courses this month. Starting Sept. 11, learn the ins and outs of trail building and the rigging systems that keep our trails safe. The Trail Academy also offers courses to become a Trail Crew Leader for those interested in leading other volunteers in working on local trails. Email Emma at em**@*************ls.org or visit santacruztrails.org to learn more.
GOOD WORK
CABRILLO UNVEILING
Food, music, Native American and Folklorico dancers, and Latinx art? Count us in.ย
Cabrillo Collegeโs first Latinx-inspired mural will be unveiled on Sept. 14. Francisco Alonso, who graduated from Cabrillo College in the 1990s, was commissioned as the muralist. While he was at Cabrillo, Alonso was involved in multiple efforts to bring cultural and educational events to Cabrillo. Since then, Alonso has traveled across the Americas and around the world painting murals. The mural set to be unveiled is titled โUnity.โ RSVP to this event by calling 831-479-6306.
QUOTE OF THE WEEK
โIf music is a place, then jazz is the city, folk is the wilderness, rock is the road, classical is a temple.โ
Folk hero Ramblinโ Jack Elliott is one of the countryโs great storytellers. Still, his own storyโa meandering tale of winding roads, chance encounters and lots of nautical-themed side streetsโis the most intriguing of all. And Elliottโs story isnโt over. When he turned 90 on Aug. 1, there was a large backyard gathering to celebrate; Tom Waits, one of the countless singer-songwriters influenced by Elliott, attended. The birthday boy basked in the company of friends and loved ones, many of whom he hasnโt been able to see in more than a year. In typical Ramblinโ Jack fashion, he morphed emotion into humor.
โI was inviting people to my hundredth birthday,โ Elliott jests. โThree people accepted. I thought it was pretty amazing that three people were ready to come to my hundredth birthday in 10 years. Maybe Iโll have to [celebrate] in five years if I donโt make it past 95. Celebrating your hundredth birthday when youโre 95 is kind of like a showbiz trick. Itโs done with ropes. Iโm studying up on my trick-roping. Iโve never been very good with my trip-roping. Iโm good with knot tying, though. I worked as a rigger on sailing vessels. There are a lot of knots you have to use.โ
Recently, Elliott and a buddy took a 16-foot dory out on Tomales Bay in Marin County, about 30 miles north of San Franciscoโmaritime-related subjects regularly slip into Elliottโs conversations.
โSailboat rigging is almost like tuning a guitar,โ Elliott explains. โEach one of those strings has to be the right tension. Boating is a good way of relaxing from the stresses of performing. Thereโs a lot of pressure, trying to stand on stage and entertain a bunch of people with strings and stories and songs. Thereโs also an understanding and appreciation between the artist and the audience if theyโre paying attention and enjoying [the performance]. The same holds true when youโre trying to make a boat go straight and keep her on course.โ
Other than boats and the landmark birthday celebration, everything came to a halt when Covid hit. Like every other musician, Elliott had to cancel shows and stay home. But the forced hiatus became an opportunity for him to reflect on his life while reconnecting with longtime friends.
Ramblin’ Jack and his daughter, filmmaker Aiyana Partland, ca.1996. PHOTO: Michael Avedon
โ[Elliott] spent a fair amount of time with his friend and neighbor [the Grateful Deadโs] Bob Weir,โ says Elliottโs daughter, filmmaker Aiyana Partland. โHe also saw quite a lot of his friends [actor] Peter Coyote and [bluegrass legend] Peter Rowan. We started making audio recordings, sort of like an oral history project done in conversationโsometimes with Peter Coyote, sometimes with Bob Weir and sometimes with Peter Rowan. Thatโs been a great way for [Elliott], and maybe for all of them, to pass the time during the pandemic.โ
Partland stresses the importance of capturing her fatherโs legacy and detailing his life and his impact on music and beyond. Partlandโs 2000 documentary, The Ballad of Ramblinโ Jack, which earned a Special Jury Prize at the Sundance Film Festival, brought a new level of cultural attention to her father. The only other official work highlighting Elliottโs legacy is Hank Reinkeโs Ramblinโ Jack Elliott: The Never-Ending Highwayโthough itโs comprehensive, many readers criticized Reinkeโs biography for failing to include an interview with the man himself.
โ[Elliott] is falling through the cracks of history a little bit,โ Partland says. โI feel a tremendous weight to be doing more, like a Jack Elliott Archives or exhibit. Something needs to be created for the agesโweโve got the Woody Guthrie Museum, and now the Bob Dylan Museum.โ
STEAL SOMETHING GOOD
Born Elliott Charles Adnopoz in 1931, Elliott was raised in Brooklyn by a loving family. Elliottโs father was a respected doctor and surgeon who โspent a lot of time thinking about his patientsโ problems.โ โI felt that seeing a doctorโs life from the inside made me never want to be a doctor,โ Elliott says. โI just wanted to be a sailor, a cowboy or a truck driverโIโve explored a bit of all three of those professions.โ
Elliott has spent most of the past 70 years sailing, restoring and learning everything he could about boats; heโs driven 16-wheeler trucks across the country; worked on rodeos, doing everything from shoveling shit to roping to riding; and he performs 50-60 shows every yearโreluctantly at times.
Elliottโs rambling focus and various interests outside of music may help to explain the reason why heโs never enjoyed the fortune and fame that so many who regard him as a musical genius and primary influence have had, such as Bob Dylan.
โThere were a lot of people who tried to make me angry about that,โ Elliott told Esquire magazine. โโ[Dylanโs] stealing the wind out of your sails,โ theyโd tell me, but I still had plenty of wind left. And besides, I was flattered. Dylan learned from me the same way I learned from Woody [Guthrie]. Woody didnโt teach me. He just said, โIf you want to learn something, just steal itโthatโs the way I learned from Lead Belly.โโ
Elliott first heard Guthrie perform in 1950 on the Oscar Brand radio show. The honesty flowing throughout the tapestry of Guthrieโs lyrics grabbed hold of Elliott and never let go. The 19-year-old Elliott managed to talk his way into the Guthrie household, where he would live for nearly two years, soaking up everything about Guthrieโs music that he could. At the time, Guthrieโs health had already begun to decline, so he welcomed the wide-eyed Elliott into his lifeโhis family accepted Elliott; his curiosity and determination lifted Guthrieโs spirit at a time when death loomed close.
Ramblin’ Jack and Bob Dylan in New York City in the early 1960s . PHOTO: D. Gilbert
From โBuffalo Skinnersโ to โ1913 Massacre,โ Elliott mastered Guthrieโs songbook in fullโGuthrie once said that Elliott played his songs better than he ever did. Meanwhile, Elliott had developed his own fingerpicking style from watching pickers like Cisco Houston, Jessie Fowler and Bessie Smith. By the mid-1950s, word spread about an unknown โfast and furiousโ flat-picking folk musician seen hanging around Washington Square, New York Cityโs go-to spot for folkies at the time. Elliott eventually moved out of the Guthrie house, but remained a constant in the familyโs lives. โAs 10-year-old kid, I was thrilled to see [Elliott] riding in on a motorcycle,โ recalls Woodyโs son Arlo. โI begged my mom to let Jack take me for a ride. She was naturally reluctant, but eventually gave in, and Jack took me for a ride on the back of his bike. It was the first time Iโd ever been on a bike of any kind. It was thrilling and instilled in me a love for motorcycles that Iโve maintained for the rest of my life. Itโs funny how one little insignificant event can influence a life. Jack was primarily an influence on me as a performer, a mentor, a family friend, and a million other things. But, of all of those things, the thing I remember most vividly was the ride we took together a long time ago.โ
Without Woody Guthrieโs mentorship, there may have never been a Ramblinโ Jack Elliott; without Ramblinโ Jack Elliott, there might not have been a Bob Dylan.
โComing from out there in Minnesota and suddenly finding himself in New York City must have been overwhelming for [Dylan] as a kid,โ Elliott says. โHe was 19 years old; that was the same age I was when I first met Woody 10 years before. I just got back from Europe and was visiting Woody at the hospital, and hereโs Bob.โ I think [Dylan] had four or five of my records on the Topic label. My very first record, which was orange-colored and eight inches in diameter, was called Woody Guthrieโs Blues. Bob said he had that record, and he liked a lot of the songs on it, so we became friends.โ
Coincidentally, Elliott and Dylan both stayed at the Hotel Earle in Washington Square. Another up-and-coming Greenwich Village folk musician Peter La Farge lived on the same floor, just down the hall. Elliott says the joint became known as โthe guitar playerโs home away from home.โ
โThose were interesting times and pretty exciting,โ Elliott says. โGerdeโs Folk City was just a little neighborhood bar, and lots of the people who came there werenโt folk music fans; they were local drunks. Not a good audience. They didnโt tolerate anything that wasnโt top-notch. Even then, they were too busy drinking and talking to pay attention to some of the best performers who were brave enough to get on that stage: Cisco Houston, Sister Rosetta Tharpe, Brother John Sellers, and me and Bob. We all served out apprenticeships on that rough little stage at Gerdeโs on West Fourth Street. It wasnโt even the proper name of the street because it was two blocks east of Fifth Avenue. The same drunks drinking in that bar probably put the wrong street sign up on that corner.โ
While every set Elliott plays sounds like they are made up of songs that come directly from his heart, he only has four or five originals to his nameโhe did co-write some songs with Roy Rogers. However, one of Elliottโs rare originals, โ912 Greens,โ is considered by many to be one of the greatest folk songs youโve never heard.Alongside his frantic yet crisp fingerpicking, Elliott talks through bourbon-soaked prose that paints a simple and visceral portrait of New Orleans: โAnd a grey cat with three legs named Grey that used to lope along and fall down / โCause Grey he had a stroke, couldnโt run too good on them three legs no how.โ
Elliott only sings the final two lines of the song: โDid you ever, stand and shiver / Just because you were, looking at a river.โ
Guy Clark told American Songwriter that he used โ912 Greensโ as an archetype for his now-famous โLet Him Roll.โ
โI was trying to write that talking thing, which I got from Ramblinโ Jack,โ Clark said. โTrying to re-create Jackโs approach to doing that kind of stuff, like โ912 Greens,โ the best talking blues.โ
Jackson Browne described โ912 Greensโ as a โtime-traveling, spoken-word masterpiece.โ
Folk hero Ramblinโ Jack Elliott is one of the countryโs great storytellers. PHOTO: Venta Leon
ROAD WORK Since his early years with Guthrie, Elliottโs life has been a continuous roundtable of some of the worldโs most highly-regarded figures of literature, film, and of course, music. The folk musician is a natural magnet who attracts artistic genius. He may be known for rambling stories that sometimes last for hours, but heโs also a perceptive listener, as well as an active and thoughtful observer whoโs both genuine and generous. Also, there arenโt many singers who can hold a note for as long as Elliott or say theyโve yodeled to a packed house at Madison Square Garden.
Before one of Elliottโs many Newport Folk Festival performances, he noticed that a fellow musician on the bill, who also happened to be a significant influence, Mississippi John Hurt, had a junky old guitar. Before Hurt took the stage, Elliott insisted he borrow his Martin. Hurt jumped at the offer and was forever grateful.
After meeting then-unknown writer Jack Kerouac in 1953, Elliott and his girlfriend at the time were invited to his apartment to listen to him read the book he had just finished, On the Road. It took three days and three large bottles of wineโalong with some other substancesโfor Kerouac to get through the transcript. The Beat classic wouldnโt be published for another four years.
โHe had this quiet strength about him,โ Elliott says of Kerouac.
The same can be said about Elliott.
โOn stage, he [Elliott] sings folk songs, but at the same time, heโs talking from a pretty personal place,โ Partland says. โHe can be pretty intimate with an audience.โ
Elliott says he no longer performs Tim Hardinโs โIf I Were a Carpenter,โ but the tune was a longstanding show finale for many years. And, of course, he has an accompanying anecdote.
โI did [โIf I Were a Carpenterโ] sort of like a circus trick to end the show,โ Elliott begins. โI would leap off the stage, strumming the guitar and walk up and down the aisles or around the tables. [The audience] would become really charged by the proximity, the closeup deal. In one such moment, I jumped off the stage and was serenading the crowd individually. When I got to the rear of the room, there was my friend, an actor, Dennis Hopper. He was wearing some kind of a Spanish Fandango hat with a flat brim and a flat top, and he beckoned me to sit down with him. He said, โJack, Iโve got a part for you in a movie. Itโs the lead. Itโs a cowboy.โ
โHe handed me a token script to take home and read and then gave me a screen test. The movie was called The Last Movie, and it was going to be filmed in Mexico. But my daughter was born a week before that. I enjoyed reading the script, and I did the screen test, but then I realized that I didnโt want to go to Mexico with a new babyโI was afraid that she might get sick, so I told Dennis, โIโm sorry, but I canโt accept this job.โ So, Dennis played the role himself, and Kris Kristofferson was in the movie. I think they ended up filming it in Peru.โ
After mentioning Kris Kristofferson, Elliott smoothly transitions to a related topic.
โI think I was the second person to record [โMe and Bobby McGeeโ] after Kris [Kristofferson],โ Elliott says. โHeโs been a very strong booster of my spirits. Janis [Joplin] was the third, I think. I met Janis at Newport [Folk Festival] and danced with her, and she shared her bottle of Southern Comfort with me. She was a great singer. Marvelous!โ
The conversation moves to the subject of boats, as it usually does, and Elliottโs first trip to San Francisco.
โI discovered that the Schooner Vandenberg was [in Sausalito], so I met the people who lived on board, Gwen Tompkins and her son the Commodore,โ Elliott says. โHer husband was the skipper of the boat when they sailed around Cape Horn in 1936โthe Commodore was four years old at the time. Must have been a great trip through 60-foot waves. I read the book, and now here I was. I asked if it would be alright to have a look at the schooner. โCome on board at 7pm and have dinner with my mom and me,โ he said. I told them my name was Buck Elliott, which was the name I was using. I knocked on the hull, and they came out of the accommodation onto the deck, and the Commodore introduced me to his mother: โThis is Jack Elliott.โ I didnโt want to embarrass him by correcting him in front of his mom, so I said, โOkay, Iโll be Jack for a while.โ And the name stuck. Itโs as simple as that.โ
The โRamblinโโ moniker came later. โI was fascinated with Model A Fords,โ Elliott says. โI had just bought one for $15. Took me 10 days to get it running. I was telling [activist/folk musician] Odetta about resuscitating this old rusty Model A Ford. Her mother was listening and must have thought that was kind of weird because one day, I visited and overheard Odettaโs mother say, โThat Jack Elliott, he sure can ramble.โ Thatโs when I became Ramblinโ Jack.โ
NO STRANGER
After nearly 60 LPs, reissues, rare 78s, EPs, 45s, contributions, compilations, soundtracks, festival recordings and guest appearances, the name Ramblinโ Jack began to pick up more mainstream notoriety in the โ90s. Elliott received a Lifetime Achievement Award from the Folk Alliance and a National Medal of Arts from President Bill Clinton in 1998. In 1995, he scored his first Grammy for Best Traditional Folk Album for South Coast; in 2009, he won the Best Traditional Blues Album Grammy for A Stranger Hereโhe has an additional three nominations to add to the list.
โWell, I was a good guitar player for a while,โ he says. โI had a little stroke about two years ago, and I lost a lot of ability in my left hand, you know, playing chords going up and down the neck, fingering and all that. But Iโm working on it. I may have to take some guitar lessons. I still enjoy trying to play guitar, but itโs not as easy as it used to be.
Iโm far more interested in boat-building, actually. You know, the construction of a guitar is like building a ship model.โ
Aside from โgoing from one doctorโs appointment to another,โ Elliott hasnโt been doing a lot of ramblingโmeaning traveling, in this caseโlately.
โIโve got two memory cells left, and one of them is swollen, and the other one is leaking,โ he says with a laugh. โI canโt remember what I did five minutes ago.โ
Elliott is still a dedicated troubadour. On Sept. 17, he heads out on his first tour in over a year. After a show at Moeโs Alley in Santa Cruz on Sept. 23, Elliott heads down to Big Sur to play Fernwood Resort on Sept. 25 and the Henry Miller Library on Sept. 26. Then, heโll be in Texas, Missouri and Illinois through late November.
When asked if he has any regrets, Elliott pauses for a couple of minutes.
โWell, I regret that I never sailed around Cape Horn when I was young enough to do it,โ he answers before leading into a joke about MaineโElliott lived in Maine for about a year following his fatherโs 1984 death.
โHave you heard this one?โ he begins. โThere was a tourist lost in a little town in Maine. He drives up to a house, and a man sits on the porch on a rocking chair. The driver rolls the window down and says, โCan I take this road to Portland?โ The man in the rocking chair thinks for a minute, and then he says, โYou can, but theyโve got one there already.โโ
Ramblinโ Jack Elliott with special guests Dirk Powell and Rainy Eyes perform at 7pm on Thursday, Sept. 23 at Moeโs Alley, 1535 Commercial Way, Santa Cruz, $35-40. folkyeah.com.
Elizabeth, who requested GT withhold her last name, was on her way to FedEx when we spoke.
โI donโt have internet in my home, so Iโm going to FedEx for wifi,โ she says, her three children chattering in the background. โI havenโt been able to pay my bills and Comcast hasnโt been really nice about my service. Yeah, so itโs kind of hard for me also to just find the time to go and redo my whole application.โ
She is referring to her Covid-19 rent relief application. The state-funded rent relief program aims to provide financial aid to tenants like Elizabeth, renters who were financially hit the hardest by the pandemic. Elizabeth and her husband have been unable to pay rent in its entirety for the past few months, due to both of them losing their jobs at the start of the pandemic.
Since she applied in May, Elizabeth has been trying to move her application along. When GT spoke to her in July, the program had just revised its application with the goal of making it more accessible to renters and speeding up the processing time. But Elizabethโs application has not budged.
Representatives at the state program and Community Bridges, a local nonprofit helping renters with their applications, continue to cite missing information as the reason her application is stagnant.
But Elizabeth is often given mixed feedback about what information is missing. And without anyone following up on her case, she is left to speculate about the status of her application, or spend hours tracking down someone to give her an update on if she included the right information this time. As a mother of three, prioritizing her rent relief application competes with the everyday concerns of motherhood.
โItโs been close to three months and I havenโt been able to get what I owe. Iโm getting more in debt with my family and friends. Itโs been so hard, and especially right now that the moratorium is going to expire Iโm starting to stress. My kids are back to school, and I donโt have any internet resources,โ Elizabeth says.
Last month, in order to cover rent, Elizabeth forfeited paying her Comcast bill, and is now without internet. Not only do her children not have access to the web for school purposes, but no internet means another hurdle, since the rent relief application is completely digital.
Recently, a representative from the state told her she would need to redo her application completely.
Elizabeth laughed when asked how much time she had spent on her application.
โI would say at least four weeks worth,โ she says.
New, (Sort Of) Improved
Greg Chanski is a landlord who also submitted an application with his tenant in May. He owns four houses in Santa Cruz County, and his tenant owed him around $16,000 in back rent.
In late July, Chanksi was notified via email that their application was approved, and on Aug. 20 he was paid the back rent in full. The payment came as a relief to Chanksi, and eased tensions with his tenant, but had he not been so proactive he questions if the payment would have come through at all.
โEvery step of the way I had to call and remind the agent, and he had to push it along because youโd get to a certain point and nothing would happen. And then youโd call again and then the next step would happen,โ Chanski tells me during his routine morning hike through the redwoods.
When GT reported on this issue in July, representatives at Community Bridges and Watsonville Housing Manager Carlos Landaverry did not know of any tenants who had received payments. According to the state rent relief dashboard, the state has received 1,328 applications from Santa Cruz County. 1,274 of those applications are complete, and the state has issued 331 payments.
One reason for the high number of complete applications in comparison with the number of payments issued is that the state attempts to contact landlords three times to give them the money directly. This hold-up accounts for 262 applications in the que, which are approved but pending a landlord response.
Both Communities Organized for Relational Power in Action (COPA), a faith-based nonprofit addressing issues like affordable housing, and Community Bridges are working to create solutions to this problem, and speed up the process in general.
But as tenants continue to wait out these bureaucratic hurdles, they lose faith that the money is coming at all, Landaverry says.
โThereโs a bag of mixed feelings. Thereโs mistrust. People don’t believe us that help is on the way,โ Landaverry says.
A Tale of Two Systems
When the Covid-19 rent relief program began, local governments were given three options for how they would distribute the money and process the applications.
First, they could let the state process applications and distribute funds. Or they could distribute funds and process applications themselves, while using the same application guidelines that the state put forth. Or, alternately, they could use different application guidelines and distribute the funds locally.
Santa Cruz County chose the first option. โThe county staff are overwhelmed in Santa Cruz County, so they just didnโt have the capacity to manage a program like [the second option],โ CEO of Community Bridges Ray Cancino says.
Monterey County chose the second option.
When the CARES Act was passed in March, United Way Monterey County, an organization fighting for the financial stability of Monterey County families, created a system that distributed the funds provided by the CARE Act to local families via local organizations. So Monterey County had a model in place that would, theoretically, distribute money from Covid-19 rent relief with similar efficiency.
In some ways, having control over how the applications are processed allows United Way Monterey County more freedom to eliminate some of the logistical barriers inherent in the state model, says United Way CEO Katy Castagna.
The 14 organizations spread across Monterey County who help people fill out applications are also the ones who process the applications, making information more centralizedโapplicants only have to call one place to receive an update.
Also, the application is not solely digital. Applicants can dial 211, and a representative will submit an application on their behalf over the phone, eliminating one of the biggest hurdles for people without digital literacy or the internet, like Elizabeth.
Although the percentage of funds distributed compared to requested is similar (Monterey County has paid 26% of its total funds requested, compared to Santa Cruz Countyโs 25%), the number of households who have received payment points to a larger discrepancy: Monterey County has served 932 households while Santa Cruz County has served 331.
Project Manager at Hartnell College Ana G. Ibarra-CastroI speculates there are multiple reasons as to why Monterey Countyโs system has served more households. Hartnell College is one of the partners that helps process applications.
โI think it is extremely helpful to localize applications,โ Ibarra-Castrol says. โEspecially if thereโs a need to meet in person to deliver documents, or thereโs that technology gap, localizing the interface with the community is definitely helpful.โ
Additionally, partners frequently provide feedback on what is working best, and itโs easy for the organizations to implement these recommendations. The partners also quickly realized that having landlord cooperation is key to processing applications efficiently, and moved to prioritize establishing these relationships.
โThere are a lot of repetitive tasks that go away after establishing that relationship,โ Ibarra-Castrol says. Such as the three contact policy, which Ibarra-Castrol says she does not think is a hindrance to processing applications the way it is for the state.
While Montereyโs system has served more households than the stateโs, Cancino points out a problem with having different systems in neighboring counties. Residents in North Monterey County, which includes parts of Pajaro Valley, will seek help from Community Bridges, which usually provides services to Pajaro Valley residents.
โIf you live in Pajaro Valley, or on one side of Watsonville, you have two different systems,โ Cancino says. โWe donโt have access to Monterey Countyโs Housing Assistance Program, so weโre telling a Pajaro resident who lives less than a mile from a Watsonville resident, โSorry, we canโt help you.โโ
Moratorium Ends
With Californiaโs eviction moratorium ending Sept. 30, and the Supreme Court rejecting the federal eviction moratorium in a 6-to-3 vote, processing applications is more important now than ever.
One of the largest issues with the eviction moratoriumโs pending expiration, according to Landaverry and Attorney John Subranni, is the informal evictions that are currently happening. Both are seeing tenants who are unable to pay rent preparing to move out, if they havenโt already.
Elizabeth is one of those renters. Her landlords are frustrated that her application is still in progress, and she worries what will happen after Sept. 30.
But Subranni stresses that tenants are protected from eviction if they fulfill the qualifications listed on the Covid-19 related financial distress form, and pay 25% of their back rent starting Oct. 1 (this can be monthly or a lump sum) or have an application for Covid-19 rent relief processing.
Still, Subranni expects to see an uptick in nonpayment eviction cases come fall.
โA lot of folks are only partially reemployed. We see a lot of people who lost a lot of work and income, and then sort of got their work back, but itโs not quite the same. So, I expect a lot of people will not be able to pay their rent.โ
Chanksiโs tenant falls into this category, unable to fully resume the same hours of work due to the pandemic. And Chanski says that even though his tenant is now caught up, they have no way to pay for rent going forward, and the relief program will not cover him in the future.
โIโm going to start having to put pressure on him,โ Chanski says.
Even though tenants are protected from eviction for nonpayment of rent if they meet the requirements listed in the distress form, beginning Nov. 1, landlords can take tenants to small claims court for outstanding rent payments.
But for now, the tenants who have pandemic-related financial reasons for nonpayment should stay put, says Landaverry.
โIf youโre behind in rent or utilities, talk to one of the nonprofits before you move out. Before you do anything, talk to an attorney right away,โ Landaverry says.
Even though she qualifies for protection from eviction, Elizabeth is unsure what she will do. She has more than $7,000 of debt owed to family and friends, and her recent exchanges with her landlords have been tense. She plans on making one last attempt at getting her rent relief application processed.
โI honestly donโt know if Iโm going to be able to get it, I have been waiting since May. So Iโm kind of hopeless right now,โ Elizabeth says, trailing off for a moment. โYeah, itโs just, itโs really sad. And all the time that I have put into getting this to work for me,โ Elizabeth says, releasing a short humorless laugh. โItโs hard, not being sure where I am stepping next.โ
A 17-year-old Aptos High School student died on Aug. 31 after he was stabbed multiple times on campus, and two of his classmatesโa 14- and 17-year-old who Santa Cruz County Sheriff Jim Hart said are โgang-involvedโโare facing murder charges for the attack.
The unprecedented act of on-campus violenceโthe first Hart says he has seen in his 33 years in law enforcementโhas sent shockwaves through the Pajaro Valley Unified School District community, and sparked calls for, among others things, the return of the districtโs School Resource Officer (SRO) program, which its board of trustees voted to remove last year.
The PVUSD board is expected to hold a special meeting on Sept. 15 at the Watsonville City Council Chambers to possibly revisit its decision. Neither law enforcement nor school district officials have suggested that having an officer on campus would have prevented the attack. But concerned parents and residents are asking the district to make campuses safer after the incidentโand several others involving young people in and around PVUSD schools.
Just four days prior, an 18-year-old was arrested by officers with the Santa Cruz County Anti-Crime Team for having a loaded handgun at the heavily attended annual Belgard Kup football game between Watsonville and Pajaro Valley high schools. The teen was not a student of either school at the time.
And a day after the deadly Aptos stabbing, a 13-year-old student at Cesar Chavez Middle School in Watsonville was arrested after pulling out a knife on a classmate during a confrontation. In addition, Hart said during a community forum on Sept. 2 that video evidence showed there had been an uptick in fights on the Aptos High campusโincluding one involving one of the suspectsโleading up to the stabbing.
โItโs imperative that this violence stops, and that students can attend school safely and without fear,โ Hart said.
โSenseless tragedyโ
Around 2:30pm, the Sheriffโs Office received calls of a stabbing at Aptos High. About 15 patrol cars from the Sheriffโs Office and the California Highway Patrol raced to establish a crime scene and shut down the entrance and exit from the campus at Freedom Boulevard. Hart said deputies found a boy suffering from multiple stab wounds near the campusโ swimming pool and that a deputy performed CPR until paramedics arrived. The school was put on lockdown as search teams combed the campus with guns drawn and a K9.
Central Fire set up a landing zone at the school baseball field where a CALSTAR rescue helicopter flew over the campus before landing in the outfield of the diamond. The victim was taken from the crime scene to the field by paramedics from American Medical Response and loaded into the helicopter before being taken to a trauma center outside of the county.
Aptos High remained on lockdown until about 5:30pm.
A huge logjam of traffic, mostly parents trying to pick up their children, lined up along Freedom Boulevard back to Highway 1, where a CHP officer grappled with traffic control. Near the entrance to the campus, a clutch of parents hugged one another, some in tears, as they yearned for information about the unfolding events. They took turns making frantic phone calls while trying to comfort one another.
About 25 people are assigned to the case, Hart said during a press conference later that night. He added that witnesses may have recorded the attack on their cell phones, and asked them to come forward. Witnesses, Hart said, would not face criminal charges.
By Sept. 7, more than 960 people had donated roughly $53,000 to a GoFundMe page set up to help the family of the victim defray funeral costs. The creator of the page wrote that she gained the familyโs permission to โgrieve their loss and have them not to worry about how theyโre going to pay for upcoming bills and expenses.โ The author wrote that the student was described as โa kind-hearted and respectful young manโ by neighbors and family.
โOur hearts are heavy tonight as we mourn the death of our Aptos High student,โ Rodriguez said. โThis senseless tragedy is a loss for all of us who knew the student, his parents, his friends and our community but most importantly his family.โ
The campus was closed for two days after the stabbing and all school activities were canceled. PVUSD offered grief counselors at Cabrillo Collegeโs Aptos and Watsonville campuses. During the community forum on Sept. 2, Aptos High Principal Peggy Pughe said that school counselors also proactively reached out to students through phone and video calls and emails.
When students returned to campus on Sept. 3, there were two sheriffโs deputies on site. A deputy will also be on campus this week. It is unclear how long law enforcement will have a presence at the school after that.
Student Safety
The attack occurred nearly one year after the PVUSD board ended the districtโs SRO program, which placed law enforcement officers on high school campuses. The district opted instead to shift the funds to social-emotional supports for students. At the time, numerous people urged the board to make the shift, reasoning among other things that the presence of law enforcement made students uncomfortable. Others said that a focus on law enforcement was the wrong approach to deal with studentsโ issues.
PVUSD Trustee Maria Orozco said the decision to end the SRO program was made after listening to community input. She says she stands by the decision to increase support services for students, and that there are no plans to shift that funding.
โWe heard that loud and clear,โ she says. โAnd even now, with the increase of the services that were provided to students, itโs still not enough.โ
During the emergency meeting, the trustees and district officials will likely discuss how to fund the SRO program, should they elect to relaunch it. The program cost $405,265 annually for one Watsonville Police officer at Watsonville High School and another at Pajaro Valley High School, and one Santa Cruz County Sheriffโs deputy at Aptos High.
โFor me, itโs always been about the safety and well-being of students, and I think itโs a conversation we need to have as a community,โ Orozco says. โI donโt think weโre able to ignore what happened and the impact itโs having on everyone.โ
WPD Interim Chief Thomas Sims says that, even if the district immediately funded the program, it would take around one year to bring the officers back, since they were reassigned and those positions were eliminated. That is unfortunate, Sims says, since many students said they liked the program and felt safer with an officer on campus. Many consulted the officers for law enforcement issues and guidance.
โThere are so many positives that come from having an officer on campus,โ he says. โIt builds community, it builds relationships between officers and students.โ
Sheriffโs Office spokeswoman Ashley Keehn says that a deputy would be available to return to the Aptos High campus immediately, should PVUSD restore the SRO program. Sims stresses that WPD has a good relationship with PVUSD, and will support the district in whatever decision is made.
Sims says that, during the discussion last year to remove the officers, a small fraction of the community said the program is a โgateway to the prison system,โ a notion he calls โsilly.โ SROs receive special training to work on school campuses, including implicit bias and de-escalation. They also conduct welfare checks and home visits and connect at-risk students to diversion programs.
โTo take that away from the school system was unfortunate,โ Sims says. โThe presence of police officers prevents crime from happening. That is a fact. And everybody knows that.โ
Hart several times throughout the Sept. 2 forum championed the program that had been at Aptos High for 22 years before last yearโs decision. But when asked during the forum to present data that shows police presence keeps students safe, he referred to anecdotal experience and told attendees that there are several articles about the effectiveness of SROs.
โHere in Santa Cruz County, weโve been in the schools for many, many years โฆ and there hasnโt been any serious cases of violence like this,โ he said. โLocally, we know it works.โ
PVUSD Board President Jennifer Holm says the issue is a complex one, and that there are many different ways of looking at safety. She pointed out that Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland, Fla., where in 2018 a shooter killed 17 people and injured 17 others, had an SRO on campus.
โWhen you have a senseless tragedy like this, itโs important to reevaluate and take another look,โ she says.