Pajaro Valley Unified School District’s governing body on July 30 took the first step toward allowing students to vote in district elections and help choose the trustees that represent them.
The board voted to form an ad-hoc committee that will talk to students, families and community members and research the legal implications of lowering the voting age to 16. The committee will report its findings to the board.
Trustee Gabe Medina, who created the “Student Promise Proposal,” said that he promised students during his campaign that he would give them a voice at the table.
“Students suffer direct impact from school board decisions, yet lack formal representation,” he said.
If ultimately approved—Medina estimated that could take about four years—it would lower the voting age to 16 for PVUSD trustees.
Allowing them to participate could boost attendance and activism, Medina said.
“Students who already lead walkouts, advocacy campaigns and coalition building now need the ballot to match their voices,” he said.
He pointed to Oakland Unified School District, where 67% of voters supported Measure QQ, which gave young people the right to vote in elections there. The measure added some 8,000 new voters to the roster.
‘We Need the Right to Vote’
Several people spoke about the issue, all of them in favor.
“The students should be able to hold the trustees accountable for their actions,” said Pajaro Valley High School junior Maximiliano Barraza Hernandez, who pointed out that former board members “expressed indifference and even antagonism” when students addressed them.
“As a 16-year-old, I know it would be a game-changer to be able to vote for board members, because I remember having to fight really hard just to be able to support people who represented me,” he said.
PVHS sophomore Ixel Barraza said she has been speaking at board meetings for two years.
“I feel like as students we need the right to vote, because I don’t want adults speaking for me without even asking what I think,” she said. “We are affected by the decisions of the board members who we don’t even get to elect. It’s unfair for us to not have a voice.”
Trustees Medina, Jessica Carrasco and Carol Turley volunteered to be on the committee.
Trustee Misty Navarro warned that a similar issue came before the Watsonville City Council, and that the city’s charter only allows citizens 18 and older to vote.
“Hopefully you can figure out a way around that,” she said.
Navarro also said that the district comprises two counties, and that lowering the voting age in only one could create equity issues.
No-Confidence Vote Rejected
In other action, the trustees rejected a vote of no confidence against Board President Olivia Flores, Vice President Misty Navarro and Superintendent Heather Contreras.
Medina, who brought the issue to the board, said he has seen a failure of leadership that includes unequal treatment of schools, blocking his requests to place items on the board agenda and disrespect during closed meetings that has not been addressed.
“What we’re seeing is not just dysfunction,” Medina said. “It’s leadership that abandons transparency, fairness and core values of public service.”
As one example, Medina said that the board declined to discuss the removal of critical youth programs, but held a vote on placing uniformed police officers on high school campuses that Trustee Joy Flynn requested—and during a meeting when she was absent.
“That’s not procedural oversight, that’s political opportunism,” Medina said.
He also said that the board has failed to hold Contreras accountable when she did not respond to trustees’ request for information.
In addition, Flores did not address “micro-aggression and racially charged comments” during closed-session meetings, Medina said.
“Silence in the face of this behavior is complicity,” he said.
The trustees rejected a motion by Medina to table the issue until Trustee Joy Flynn could be there.
Navarro said that the agenda-setting committee has been grappling with packed agendas, and that the decisions they made had nothing to do with Flynn’s absence.
“Had trustee Flynn asked us to table this, we would have, but she did not,” Navarro said.
‘Let’s Work on Real Stuff’
Several people addressed the board, both in favor and against the proposal.
“Of all the things we should be talking about—the budget, closing schools, declining enrollment, improving academic performance—we’re here to consider a no-confidence vote,” said Bill Beecher. “Talking about the pot calling the kettle black. Trustee Medina wants a no-confidence vote when he has been the major source of disruption for this board.”
Beecher asked that the issue be “tabled forever.”
“Let’s work on real stuff,” he said.
Eli Davies said that they have appreciated Medina’s stances on issues they feel are important to the community.
“If you look at actual items and policy, (Medina) speaks for the community, thinks about what the community needs,” Davies said. “To call him the divisive one is really coming from a place of not knowing the intricacies of what’s happening here.”
Gabriel Barazza said that Martin Luther King Jr. was criticized as being divisive during the Civil Rights movement.
“I always find it amusing that people who want to preserve the status quo and systems that are unjust and are not serving the community always tend to hide behind civility and respect,” he said.
What a mess this school district is.