Biden’s Election Brings DACA Recipients New Hope

0

Yoni Espinoza says he was just 6 years old when his mother told him that they were going to go on a “long, long walk.”

He says he had no idea the trek would be a three-day journey through excruciatingly hot days and numbingly cold nights across the U.S.-Mexico border.

“We just kept walking,” he said. “For some stretches, I walked. For other ones she carried me …. We just kept moving.”

Espinoza and his mother were fleeing the Chiapas Conflict, what he equated to a “small civil war” in the Mexican state in the ’90s. They were hoping to start a new life in the United States.

Today, Espinoza is a father, an older brother, a loyal partner, a college graduate and, in his eyes, an American.

“If you ask me if I’d ever leave to live in Mexico, I’d say ‘no,’” he said. “I am Mexican, but I’ve lived here my entire life. Everything I know is here. This is my home.”

In the eyes of the U.S. government, however, Espinoza is stuck in limbo with roughly 800,000 other people living in the country.

A recipient of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, Espinoza, 27, can call the U.S. home, but he can’t officially say it’s his home country. And realizing his dream of becoming a first responder is out of the question too, as being sworn in as a firefighter or police officer requires U.S. citizenship at most departments.

But with former Vice President Joe Biden, who championed DACA on the campaign trail, set to step into the White House next year, Espinoza says he has a new resolve that in the near future he will be able to do all of that and more.

“There’s hope for us that wasn’t there before,” he said. “[Biden’s presidency is] going to open more doors for us, for the DREAMers.”

WHAT IS DACA?

In short, DACA is an immigration policy established by then-President Barack Obama in 2012 that allows certain undocumented people to temporarily avoid deportation and obtain work permits if they were brought to the U.S. as children at age 16 or younger.

Since its inception, the program has often been used interchangeably with the Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act, also known as the DREAM Act, a bill introduced in 2001 that has for two decades not received enough legislative support to become law.

Much of the DREAM Act—which spurred the DREAMers movement and moniker still around today—is embedded in DACA, except for one very important aspect, says Matthew Wisner: a path to citizenship.

“For a lot of these recipients, [to become a citizen] is something that they’ve always wanted,” said Wisner, the directing attorney for the Community Action Board’s Immigration Project.

Wisner said the Immigration Project serves a “tremendous” number of DACA recipients and other immigrants of various statuses throughout Santa Cruz County. Many of those DACA recipients, he said, are young adults in the workforce or in higher education who “don’t know any other home.”

Nationally, that is also the case. Numerous surveys, reports and studies have found that the program benefits the economy, and that recipients have reached higher levels of education and higher salaries than those not in the program. Employment levels for DACA recipients have held steady at more than 90%, according to a report from the Committee on Small Business. The Center for American Progress said that their deportation would cost the country more than $400 billion over 10 years.

“This election was really consequential,” Wisner said. “We were kind of at a crossroad for this large population of our community.”

THE LAST FOUR YEARS

President Donald Trump moved to scrap the program, which he called illegal and unconstitutional, during his first year in office, but that move was rejected by the Supreme Court earlier this year.

Though that decision was tabbed as a major victory for DACA recipients, the Trump administration following that ruling announced that it would no longer be accepting new applications, and that it would reduce the renewal period from two years to one and reject most requests from recipients to travel outside of the country.

The decision by the current administration to undermine the Supreme Court’s ruling was not surprising, says Doug Keegan, Wisner’s predecessor who retired from his post on Nov. 1.

Trump’s tough stance on immigration and brash attacks on programs such as DACA, Keegan says, often left the Immigration Project scrambling to assure the numerous immigrants they serve that they were safe and that their status would not be affected. Biden’s win, he said, will alleviate some of those anxieties.

“It was like putting out fires every day,” he said. “It was exhausting for us, and you can imagine it was stressful for the people we serve.”

Both Wisner and Keegan say Biden can quickly overturn many of Trump’s more than 400 immigration policy changes with executive actions. Restoring DACA fully, they both said, should be at the top of Biden’s priority list when he enters office.

The president-elect has said he will do that and more. The Biden campaign said that DREAMers and their parents should have a path to citizenship through legislative immigration reform. It also said that Biden will ensure DREAMers are eligible for federal student aid and are provided access to community college without debt. His campaign also said he would invest in historically Black colleges and universities, Hispanic-serving institutions and minority-serving institutions, “which will help DREAMers contribute even more to our economy.”

The former of those plans, Keegan said, will be a much tougher task.

“Those are easy fixes that he can do with executive actions,” he said. “Lobbying Congress to address immigration reform, that’s much harder.”

HOLDING OUT ‘HOPE’

Espinoza says he realizes that his path to citizenship might not be realized for some time.

“But I’m hopeful,” he said. “I hope to be a citizen before I’m 35.”

His optimistic outlook on his situation comes from seeing his family’s success. He has two younger sisters, Yvette, 16, and Kimberly, 11, who he says excel in school, and have no immigration status limitations placed upon them.

His younger brother, Angel Luis Hernandez, 19, was a star soccer player at Watsonville High School—his alma mater—and now plays at Hartnell College in Salinas. Espinoza said his brother is thinking of becoming a police officer after college. He says he hopes that one day he can join his younger brother as a first responder.

“I want to help my community,” he said. 

And he says becoming a U.S. citizen would assure him that he will never be torn apart from his 1-year-old daughter, Sofia.

Espinoza says he plans to get married to his partner of 10 years, Yesenia Lara, and begin the “naturalization process” that way. There is no guarantee that he will receive a marriage-based green card, but he says that will not stop him from trying.

“I’m going to keep going—I’m going to keep moving,” he said. “You can’t give up hope.”

‘Love You Madly’ Livestream Features Bonnie Raitt, Boz Scaggs and More

In Alecia Haselton’s video for the “Love You Madly” fire relief campaign on the santacruzfirerelief.org website, she’s sitting on a horse in a river, singing a cappella while she slaps her leg as musical accompaniment. 

The song, “Haulin’ 2 Horses,” is a recent one that she wrote while actually hauling horses out of the CZU Lightning Complex fire burn zone in her truck and trailer. It’s short—less than two minutes long—unusual, and moving.

It’s just the kind of powerful statement by musicians that “Love You Madly” organizer Jon Luini wanted to bring to this fundraising effort, which is subtitled “Artists for Santa Cruz Fire Relief” and aims to inspire viewers to donate to the Community Foundation of Santa Cruz County’s Fire Response Fund. 

With help from Event Santa Cruz’s Matthew Swinnerton, Luini has now posted performances and messages of support from more than 50 artists, sharing new videos every week. He’s hosted big names from both the national music scene (Joe Satriani, Los Lobos, John Doe) and the local scene (Good Riddance, Chris Rene). With the announcement of an upcoming “Love You Madly” livestream on Dec. 5 that will feature Bonnie Raitt and Boz Scaggs, Sammy Hagar, Los Lobos, Colin Hay, the String Cheese Incident, Rogue Wave, Laurie Lewis and more, he’s upping the profile of the campaign’s artist roster yet again.

And yet, Luini admits it can be a video from a relatively unknown local artist like Haselton that surprises him the most.

“It was a shock,” he says of seeing the unorthodox video for the first time. But when he heard Haselton describe the backstory of the song in the video, he realized it was everything “Love You Madly” is about. 

“It tied in perfectly,” he says. “I thought that was wonderful.”

Show Time

The musicians who’ve contributed to “Love You Madly” have turned in everything from full-on productions to iPhone videos. But what has impressed Luini is that they’re never phoning it in, even when they’re literally phoning it in. It’s evident from their contributions—for instance, Louie Perez’s incredibly touching message that prefaces Los Lobos’ performance of “Anselma”—that it’s as emotional for these musicians to create these videos as it is for us to watch them.

Still, it’s hard to keep awareness of the fire’s many victims in the public consciousness week after week—especially in disaster-ridden 2020. That’s why Luini began thinking about doing a livestream, even though the initial concept for “Love You Madly” had been the opposite of the “one big event” model of fundraising.

“It’s a bit of a rollercoaster,” he says of doing the campaign. “There was a lot of excitement in our first month. Week seven is where I started feeling like, ‘I wish I had a whole staff.’ That’s when I started feeling like maybe it’s time to build up an event. I wanted to get people’s attention back to the recovery. It’s going to be a decade. It’s a long haul, and we’re only at the beginning.”

The “Love You Madly” livestream also makes it easier for big-name artists who get requests for benefits all the time and worry that having too many floating around on the internet at once will diminish their impact. They may not be comfortable submitting something that will be on the “Love You Madly” site forever, but they can contribute a performance to a livestream (the videos will be pre-recorded).

“Then there’s the space for the next thing they want to support—because there are so many good causes,” says Luini.

Horse Sense

While the livestream is sure to make a splash, the campaign relies week to week on artists like Haselton to allow their own connections to the community to inspire them. During the fire and in its aftermath, Haselton was obsessed with saving horses and later returning them to their families. Her first save came after she first heard about the fire, and called some people she used to housesit for on Ice Cream Grade to find out if they needed help getting their horse out. They did, so she hijacked her mom’s truck and trailer and made her way into the burn zone, getting the horse to safety.

“I led it down the road, and there were literally flames to the sides of us,” she remembers.

Most of her rescue work, though, actually came after the fire, after she got herself on a social media list of people who were available to help evacuees transport their horses.

“I was so pumped on it,” she says of helping evacuees with their horses. “Everything revolved around it.”

So it makes sense that she would choose to do her “Love You Madly” song on a horse in the mountains, but she was still very aware she was making it weird for everyone. Like when she rode the borrowed horse to the river where she was going to shoot with videographer Katey Schoenberger—bareback, in a white dress.

“I was riding through the neighborhood, and I felt like some sort of weird pageant queen, or someone from Game of Thrones,” she says.

She’s thrilled that people are appreciating her offbeat take on the concept. Swinnerton certainly does, and he says his young daughter may be the biggest fan of all.

“She’ll come over and slap her leg, like ‘I want that song,” he says. “It’s by far her favorite song of the year.”

‘Love You Madly: A Stream For Santa Cruz Fire Relief,’ featuring Bonnie Raitt and Boz Scaggs, Sammy Hagar, the String Cheese Incident, Los Lobos and many more will be broadcast on Dec. 5 at 7pm. Free. For more information, visit: santacruzfirerelief.org. The campaign also has a ‘Love You Madly Santa Cruz Fire Relief’ T-shirt available at bonfire.com, with original art by Chris Gallen and 100% of proceeds going to Community Foundation Santa Cruz County.

LGBTQ Community Makes Big Strides in Local Elections

The 2020 U.S. Election saw a record turnout, with a higher percentage of Americans voting than in any election in at least a century. With that high number of voters came plenty of landmark wins—including for LGBTQ candidates in all levels of government.

LGBTQ representation in Congress will hit an all-time high in 2021, and a record-breaking number of candidates have been elected to state legislatures. In Delaware, Sarah McBride became the first transgender person elected to any state senate in the U.S. In Florida, Shevrin Jones became his state’s first LGBTQ senator.

Local candidates also secured historic wins this year. Jimmy Dutra, who served on the Watsonville City Council from 2014 to 2018, will be the city’s first openly gay mayor after winning the race for his District 6 seat. 

In Santa Cruz, Vice Mayor Donna Meyers, who was elected to the City Council in 2018, is the presumptive choice to serve as the city’s next mayor. The Santa Cruz City Council won’t vote to appoint the next mayor until December, but assuming it all goes as expected, Meyers would become the city’s first-ever lesbian mayor.

Dutra says he’s “thrilled” that the mayors of the two largest cities in the county will be LGBTQ.

“It is definitely a moment in history that will be archived and remembered,” he says. “But it’s more than that. It’s hope for our future leaders …. It will give them hope that anything is possible, no matter who you are or who you love.”

In addition to Dutra and Meyers, there were other LGBTQ candidates who won local races. Steve Trujillo won a seat on the Cabrillo College Board of Trustees. Nancy de la Peña is now the first LGBTQ judge elected to the Santa Cruz County Superior Court.

Meyers is “very excited” about the progress nationwide toward getting more kinds of representation in office.

“Communities are made up of diversity,” Meyers says. “It is so important to have all perspectives … to identify the needs of everyone.”

TRUE TRAILBLAZER

When it comes to LGBTQ representation, Dutra and Meyers credit the career of current California State Senator-elect John Laird with leading the way. 

Santa Cruz city voters first elected Laird to the City Council all the way back in 1981. Laird says he didn’t hide the fact that he was gay, but many residents didn’t know. In November 1983, shortly before his fellow councilmembers appointed him mayor, a reporter asked Laird if he was gay. He confirmed that he was. Pretty soon, the news was all over newspapers across Santa Cruz County and beyond. TV news crews from across the state showed up for Laird’s swearing-in. At the time, there were only a few LGBTQ elected officials anywhere in the U.S. That year, he and two others became the three first openly gay mayors in the country.

Laird says he didn’t know how the news would go over. Looking back now, he is glad he was so open about who he is.

“My job was to be the best mayor I could … but to be clear about who I was,” he says. “Whatever credibility I gained I’d spend on making clear that it’s a good thing to be LGBT. It changed people’s views. That was my goal.”

Laird went on to become one of the first two openly gay men to serve in the California legislature, with the other being then-Assemblymember Mark Leno of San Francisco. Laird also helped form the first LGBTQ caucus and served eight years as California’s secretary for natural resources.

Meyers says that Laird’s legacy has been “instrumental” in paving the way for progress.

“This community has always been supportive, and now we also have the ability to be on the frontline of policy,” she says.

Much of that local support has come from organizations like the Diversity Center Santa Cruz County, which has been advocating for LGBTQ rights since 1989. Local historian Rob Darrow says the center has remained a safe space for people to discuss their political aspirations.

“What we are seeing today [is] the result of the longstanding programs and spaces provided in the past,” he says.

LOOKING AHEAD

Santa Cruz County has been a progressive region for LGBTQ rights for decades. In the 1970s, Santa Cruz adopted anti-discrimination ordinances and was the third city in California to organize a Pride event. In 1978, the county helped stop the Briggs Initiative, which proposed to outlaw gay or lesbian teachers in public schools.

The results of the 2020 election may be a culmination of all that history and progress. Still, Dutra says, everyone has a long way to go.

“It’s an exciting moment, but it does give me pause. Why did it take so long?” he asks, noting that he and Meyers will be only the first and second LGBTQ mayors elected in the county since Laird left office. “It’s been nearly 40 years.”

It was not until 2008 that Watsonville had its first Pride event. The Pajaro Valley Pride organization was formed in 2016, aiming to transform the somewhat socially conservative area into a more accepting place for LGBTQ residents.

Having representation in office, Dutra says, is crucial to the city’s future. There’s immense value, he explains, in constituents being able to see themselves reflected in their elected officials, no matter their race, religion or sexual orientation.

For his part, Dutra is focused on returning to elected office. He says he’s extremely thankful to the community and eager to serve his hometown.

“I’m overwhelmed by the support I received,” he says. “I promise to work for all of us—no matter who you are.”

Additional reporting by Jacob Pierce.

Ballet Theatre Filming Virtual ‘Nutcracker’ Performance

0

For years, the annual “Nutcracker, Clara’s Dream” was a winter holiday staple put on by the Santa Cruz Ballet Theatre (SCBT). They typically stage their take on Tchaikovsky’s ballet at the Santa Cruz Civic, Cabrillo College’s Crocker Theatre and the Mello Center in Watsonville. This year, something new is in the air.

The ongoing pandemic has shaken things up this season, but the show is still in the works, according to Artistic Director Diane Cypher. She said an alumni-driven film is being brewed up to replace the stage version and will be aired on the TV screen and possibly at an area theater.

“Covid has been difficult, as we all know,” Cypher said. “We thought that the film would be a way of giving back to local sponsors and as a good project to keep our dancers motivated.” 

Featuring 44 dancers and four “character artists,” the choreography by alumna Flora Chatwin tells the story of “Clara’s Dream.” This year, various scenes have been filmed on locations around Santa Cruz featuring SCBT, including longtime sponsors of SCBT and local landmarks such as the Santa Cruz Beach Boardwalk and the Mark Abbott Memorial Lighthouse.

The film will be directed by alumna Georgina Wilson. A third alumna, Alicia Houser, rounds out the creative team with directing rehearsals, filming rehearsals, helping direct the dancers on set, scouting locations, photography and more. 

“SCBT is lucky to have such a dream team working on our holiday offering this season,” SCBT organizers said. “

Wilson, a graduate from the University of Texas at Austin with a BFA in dance, embarked on a freelance career which took her to the U.K. After relocating to California, Wilson contacted SCBT when Covid-19 hit and mentioned she was interested in filmmaking. Her interest sparked the idea for the “Nutcracker” film. 

Jace Hardwick started his own production company in the LA area and his Action Studios crew will provide the cinematography. Filmography will include drone footage at West Cliff Drive and a local Christmas tree farm. 

Music Director Pamela Martin conducts the score, which was recorded at last year’s performance at the Civic Auditorium by Devi Pride. Composer and audio expert Jerome Begin arranged and “cleaned up” the recording from last year at the Civic and made the sound track suitable for the movie.

“Our 2019 orchestra was phenomenal and we are thrilled that the score of our film is played by these wonderful musicians,” Cypher said. “Many of them have also volunteered to be featured visually in the movie, adding an extra layer of artistry to the product. Be ready for something different than our normal production, in almost every way.”

“We all need something fun right now, and we thought that a family could stream this into their living room and be entertained with something joyful for 40 minutes,” Cypher added.

For more information on “Nutcracker, Clara’s Dream” visit: scbt.org/season-and-tickets/tickets.

New Environmental Report Out on Highway 1 Widening, Bus Lanes

0

Santa Cruz County transportation planners have released a new environmental report detailing the impacts of a partial widening of Highway 1.

The new draft environmental impact report (EIR) studies the impact of extending the congested highway’s width from the Capitola/Soquel area to Aptos. The Santa Cruz County Regional Transportation Commission (RTC) already finalized the high-level EIR for the entire project, as well as a detailed analysis of widening from Soquel Avenue to 41st Avenue, in January 2019. 

The latest EIR, released Thursday, covers the final legs of the proposed project from Bay Avenue and Porter Street area to State Park Drive. A public comment period is now open.

The RTC’s plan is to build new merge lanes, or auxiliary lanes, very much like the ones between Morrissey Boulevard and Soquel Avenue that opened in 2013.

Auxiliary lanes are a get-what-you-pay-for version of highway widening. These aren’t through-lanes that allow people to cruise through for miles on end. Instead, they run from each onramp to the subsequent offramp. Building axillary lanes doesn’t increase a highway’s road capacity in the same way that building actual carpool lanes—or high-occupancy vehicles (HOV) lanes—would. Auxiliary lanes also don’t incentivize ridesharing. If all someone cares about is getting places faster by car, these are both downsides. The upside is that auxiliary lanes are far cheaper to build than full-blown highway widening. 

That may be why a transportation sales tax measure built mostly around a plan to build new HOV lanes failed disastrously at the polls in 2004. 

So in 2016, the RTC crafted a cheaper sales tax measure, Measure D. In the reboot, transportation stakeholders took a different tack. Only one quarter of the money—the second-biggest slice in the measure—would go toward new auxiliary lanes. Measure D then passed, with voter support coming in 24% higher than it did in the 2004 version. That gave the auxiliary lanes the funds to move forward, and the RTC is proceeding accordingly. (The RTC is still signaling an intention to build HOV lanes, but that would be after 2035, and it has no idea at this point how to pay for them.)

Simultaneously, RTC staff is studying a concept called bus-on-shoulder, which is what it sounds like. The plan would allow buses to drive down the shoulder on the edges of the highway.

One issue, though, is that, when engineers also put in an auxiliary lane, that doesn’t leave a whole lot of room for buses trying to avoid heavy traffic flows. It’s something environmental activist Rick Longinotti has been thinking about.

“They’re calling it bus-on-shoulder, which is to me a sleight of hand,” says Longinotti, a leader of the Campaign of Sustainable Transportation, which has opposed various highway widening proposals over the years. In general, Longinotti is optimistic about the potential for bus-on-shoulder, depending on how it’s done. He has started reading through the new draft EIR and will be submitting comments.

The RTC’s current bus-on-shoulder plans call for buses to drive down the auxiliary lanes, which are mostly meant for cars merging onto and off of the highway, and they can get quite congested in their own right. There are also stretches between certain offramps and onramps, which will be for buses only, but those sections are rather short, typically less than 100 yards long.

Although he acknowledges that it may not be exactly what voters approved, Longinotti thinks the RTC should use the auxiliary lanes for buses only. He also wrote the California Transportation Commission Tuesday asking its members to deny grant requests to the RTC for auxiliary lanes as they are currently planned.

In addition to auxiliary lanes, the new EIR covers the impacts of bus-on-shoulder and a proposed Mar Vista Bicycle/Pedestrian Overcrossing. That bridge, which Mar Vista Elementary School families first requested some 18 years ago, should begin construction in 2023, according to an informational video released in September.

The public comment period on the latest EIR runs through Jan. 11 at 5pm. 

There will be a virtual public hearing Tuesday, Dec. 8, from 5-6:30pm. Attendees should register ahead of time at bitly.com/Highway1-SC (URL is case sensitive).

As Broad Shutdowns Return, Weary Californians Ask ‘Is This the Best We Can Do?’

By Anna Maria Barry-Jester and Jenny Gold

For Tom Davis, being told by the state this week that he must close his Pacific Edge Climbing Gym for the third time in six months is beyond frustrating.

The first time the rock-climbing gym and fitness center shut down, co-owners Davis and Diane Russell took out a government loan to pay employees. The second time, they were forced to lay everyone off — themselves included. Now, as they face another surge of COVID cases across California, he fears he may lose the business for good.

California’s ping-ponging approach to managing the virus — twice reopening large portions of the service-sector economy only to shut them again — doesn’t seem just or reasonable, Davis said. As of Tuesday evening, he was planning to defy the order, keeping the gym open but with additional restrictions on capacity.

“The government is essentially saying, ‘We’re just picking you to personally go bankrupt and all the people who work with you,’” said Davis. “Nobody can afford to live in Santa Cruz on unemployment.”

It’s a grim time in the pandemic. California has surpassed 1 million cases of COVID-19 and 94% of Californians — more than 37.7 million people — live in a county considered to have “widespread” infection. Santa Cruz is one of 41 California counties now under the most restrictive orders in the state’s four-tiered COVID blueprint for determining which businesses can stay open amid the pandemic, and under what proscriptions.

Until Monday, Santa Cruz was in the red tier — the second-most restrictive — meaning Pacific Edge could be open at 10% capacity. Now, its owners are being told to close entirely.

For business owners and workers, a backward slide on the blueprint represents yet another financial setback in a bleak year, leaving some residents angry, exasperated and wondering if this is really the best the state can do.

It’s a question reverberating nationwide as every state experiences a deadly rise in COVID cases and a growing number of hospitals say they are simply out of beds. Among states, California is performing relatively well, ranking 40th in cases per capita and 33rd in deaths, according to a New York Times tracker.

But even here, the virus is too pervasive in its spread — and the public health infrastructure too enfeebled — to make the reopening of businesses and schools an easy proposition. Some experts say that during a pandemic, when the virus is everywhere, the push and pull California businesses are enduring may be what success looks like in much of the U.S. for months to come.

“The yo-yo nature of this is a feature of the pandemic,” said Dr. Ashish Jha, dean of the School of Public Health at Brown University. “And in fact, when I look at really successful countries like South Korea, Taiwan and New Zealand, they all have a yo-yo feeling to them.”

Experts say a crucial factor in being able to reopen safely is getting cases low enough that time-tested public health tools like quarantines and contact tracing can work. Most U.S. hot spots, including broad swaths of California, have never achieved those low levels.

In California, Gov. Gavin Newsom, like many other governors, is trying to thread the needle, to keep cases to a minimum while also allowing many businesses to remain open. It’s a sensitive equation, said Dr. Aimee Sisson, public health officer for Yolo County.

“It’s really hard to dial in the balances of getting our economy going again, which is important for public health, and maintaining our health, which is important for the economy.”

And while California is doing better than many other states, said Cameron Kaiser, the health officer for Riverside County, it’s certainly not cause for celebration. “At this point we’re clearly doing better, but our trends are not good either. When you’re talking about the relative impact of different tragedies, I’m not sure you’d call that a success.”

Even as it frustrates some residents, California’s tiered reopening system has won praise nationally. The system draws on three COVID metrics to guide restrictions: new cases per population; the share of people tested for the coronavirus who are positive; and, in larger counties, an equity measure to ensure cases are low across the county, including in high-risk communities. Under revised guidelines released this week, county tier assignments can change from week to week — and more than once a week if data indicates a county is losing ground.

“We think it’s a best practice nationally and globally,” said Dr. Tom Frieden, a former director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “This is not about closure — this is about adjusting what is open when.”

Still, the state blueprint isn’t perfect, health officers say. In its early stages, there were inconsistencies around which businesses could stay open. For example, nail salons were treated differently from hair salons, though the exposure conditions are fairly similar. The state has taken feedback, said Sisson, and tried to make improvements.

And perhaps the biggest weakness is how little data exists to determine which businesses present the greatest risks for exposure and transmission, said Sisson and other health officers. While restaurants and bars are broadly considered high-risk because people remove their masks while eating and drinking, not much is known about viral spread at places like gyms and movie theaters, where it’s possible to reduce occupancy and wear masks.

That’s part of what frustrates Davis in Santa Cruz. Pacific Edge has reduced occupancy to just 30 people in the sprawling old factory building and instituted a range of protective measures. “Compare that to Costco. I honestly believe we are just as safe if not safer than other businesses,” Davis said.

Measuring California’s success in navigating the pandemic depends on what your goal is, said Marm Kilpatrick, an infectious disease researcher at the University of California-Santa Cruz who has been advising local government and businesses, including Pacific Edge, on reopening. The state has prioritized both keeping businesses open and keeping cases down, which means neither can be done perfectly.

Still, he’s not sure the whiplash of openings and closings is the best the state can do. He worries the tiered system may inadvertently send the wrong signals: Again and again, public health officials have watched in dismay as residents whose counties move into less-restrictive tiers revert to socializing in large groups and shedding basic safety protocols like masks and social distancing — followed by a dangerous upsurge in infections and hospitalizations.

Dr. Mark Ghaly, the state’s Health and Human Services secretary, has acknowledged as much, stressing that cases are linked to both social gatherings and businesses. Ultimately, he said on Monday, the state is taking a “dual approach” that includes changes to business practices, and asking individuals to be disciplined in wearing masks outside the home, regularly sanitizing hands, staying 6 feet apart, and socializing outdoors and in small gatherings.

Meanwhile, the holiday season looms. The most recent spike in cases directly correlates to Halloween, several health officers said, just as previous spikes were linked to Memorial Day, the Fourth of July and Labor Day. With Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Year’s on the horizon, officials wonder whether they might have to recommend a farther-reaching stay-at-home order to keep cases under control.

“I’m very worried about Thanksgiving,” said Dr. Chris Farnitano, health officer for Contra Costa County. “The tradition of so many families is to get together with their extended families, and that means gatherings with groups of people, and that’s where the virus wants to spread.”

In addition, Farnitano said, given the realities of commerce and travel, what happens in other states affects California. “Having other states with the same restrictions would help California,” he said.

What’s really needed, several public health officials said, is a coordinated national message and strategy.

“I’m hoping we’re gonna have the new president come in and take the reins very firmly,” said Steffanie Strathdee, associate dean of global health at UC-San Diego. “He has the right people around him advising him. But, by then, winter will be half over and we’re going to be facing 400,000 deaths. Digging ourselves out of that mess is going to take awhile.”

This story was produced by KHN, which publishes California Healthline, an editorially independent service of the California Health Care Foundation.

KHN (Kaiser Health News) is a nonprofit news service covering health issues. It is an editorially independent program of KFF (Kaiser Family Foundation), which is not affiliated with Kaiser Permanente.

Oregon Posts Workplace Outbreaks; California Has No Such Plan

Lea este artículo en español. 

California and Oregon were lauded for their early response to the pandemic, with swift and broad shutdowns aimed at slowing the spread of coronavirus. In reopening their economies, both states imposed stringent requirements for masks and face coverings. 

But eight months into the public health crisis, the neighboring states have made starkly different choices on tracking and reporting workplace outbreaks — decisions that shape how much the public knows about the spread of coronavirus as hotspots appear at meat-packing plantsstadium construction siteswarehouses and other essential worksites.

Since May, Oregon has used a centralized tracking system, which has enabled health officials there to release weekly reports that list the names and addresses of every known business with at least 30 employees where five or more positive COVID-19 cases are identified. For outbreaks of more than 20, the Beaver State issues special daily reports.

California, in contrast, doesn’t post workplace outbreaks. The state lets its 58 counties handle coronavirus data, with wide variety in how each county tracks and reports workplace outbreaks. The distinction has workers and public health experts worried.

“It’s fundamental data that should be readily available,” said Dr. Melissa Perry, epidemiologist and chair of the Environmental and Occupational Health department at George Washington University. 

Throughout the pandemic, the Golden State has advised, but did not mandate, employers to notify workers of positive cases among employees. This means millions of workers in the fifth-largest economy in the world receive less information than they could about whether it’s safe to go to work. It also means low-wage essential workers carry greater risks: A joint investigation by CalMatters and The Salinas Californian for the California Divide revealed hundreds of unreported outbreaks among guest farmworkers throughout California this summer. 

While business groups say it’s not productive to publicly shame companies, public health experts say posting workplace outbreaks would be helpful in controlling the virus, as pandemic-fatigued residents seek to return to school and work. More than 18,000 Californians have died from the virus with Latino and Black people infected at a significantly higher rate than white and Asian people. Such information, experts say, may improve scientific tracking and enable targeted responses amid a third wave of outbreaks.

What Oregonians know but Californians don’t

Like most states, California isn’t taking the extra step to post workplace outbreaks. But a few states, including Oregon, ArkansasNew Mexico and Colorado, do disclose where workers have contracted the virus. Iowa will disclose outbreaks if 10% of a business’ employees test positive for the virus. 

In Oregon, health officials made an early pivot with public support.

State health officials came under heavy criticism last spring in choosing not to disclose two outbreaks at Townsend Farms, a Portland-based fruit company. On May 28, the department made an administrative decision to track outbreaks statewide using lab results and data from healthcare providers. Oregon posts reports that include workplace outbreaks along with those in schools, child care facilities and senior living and care facilities. 

“There was a demand for transparency,” said Oregon Health Authority director Patrick Allen. “We had to shift.”

Today, Oregonians know nearly as much as their public health officials about the number of workers who have died or been infected as a result of workplace exposures. It’s 37 deaths and 8,605 cases. 

Californians don’t know. 

“It immediately paints a patchwork quilt picture of data,” said Perry, the George Washington University epidemiologist. “Very incomplete, very selective.”

The two states are very different in size and economy. Oregon has just over a tenth of California’s population, which accounts in part for the state’s low infection rate. But the state’s coronavirus case rate is still 1,116 per 100,000, the sixth lowest rate in the country. California’s rate is more than double that, with 2,412, according to a New York Times database. 

Though it’s difficult to know if Oregon’s reporting contributed to a lower fatality rate, officials there believe sharing information has helped.

California resists naming and shaming

California’s reluctance was on display in Sacramento this legislative cycle as lawmakers pushed for greater transparency. A bill signed in September by Gov. Gavin Newsom aims to give workers timely notice, but a key requirement to disclose worksite outbreaks to the public got stripped out of the final draft. 

Because some counties ask businesses to self report outbreaks, local officials say they fear employers won’t participate if they publicly post outbreaks. Instead, when the bill takes effect Jan. 1, California will only report the total number of outbreaks by industry sector without naming employers. 

“The opposition was very strong against the bill,” said Assemblymember Eloise Gómez Reyes (D-San Bernardino), who authored the bill. “They were basically saying, ‘Trust us, we’ll do the right thing.’”

Her bill, AB 685, which cited the Divide’s guest worker investigation, initially required the state health department to post online the location of every outbreak. But that provision got struck out along with a $10,000 penalty for failure to notify workers in a timely fashion. 

Instead of disclosing workplace outbreaks, the California Department of Public Health plans to publish aggregated data by job sectors. The department, which provides “guidance documents” to local health departments and employers, declined requests for a phone interview and said in an email statement that with regard to information about coronavirus at workplaces, county health departments “would be the appropriate agency to contact regarding outbreaks.”

Business groups led by the California Chamber of Commerce call disclosure a “name and shame” tactic, noting employers aren’t always to blame for virus outbreaks. Diane O’Malley, a lawyer at Hanson Bridgett, a San Francisco-based firm which represents employers, said California’s new law is a “backdoor way of getting where Oregon is without making it so splashy.” 

‘Pushback was gentle’

But things in Oregon weren’t that splashy. 

Some individual businesses were upset at health officials’ decision to disclose, but “mostly the organizational pushback was gentle,” said Allen, the state health director. 

“Oregon’s smaller, we all know each other personally,” said Sandra McDonnough, president and CEO of Oregon Business and Industry, adding that business interests felt heard after several conversations with the state. Still, McDonnough worried disclosure might act as a disincentive for workers and businesses to get tested. 

Allen believes transparency has built confidence. And to protect patient privacy, Oregon only posts known infections — not deaths — by employer. Perhaps an indirect measure is how comfortable workers feel about filing complaints with their state workplace safety agency: California has received about 7,300 pandemic-related complaints so far, compared to 11,600 in Oregon. 

“People know what’s going on,” Allen said. “They don’t feel like anything is being hidden.”

California, on the other hand, continues to debate workplace disclosure in county board meetings.

In Sonoma County, residents are demanding coronavirus updates to include locations of workplace infections even though the local health officer says that information would add little value since people should be cautious wherever they go.

In September, it took the Santa Rosa Police Department two weeks before notifying Cal/OSHA that an employee had died after contracting COVID-19 at work. And it took three weeks for the Santa Rosa Memorial Hospital to inform staff of positive cases. 

Surveys have shown many workers don’t think their employers will notify them.

Although Los Angeles County posts currently known workplace outbreaks, most counties do not. In Santa Clara County, some county supervisors have been pushing their own health officials to release more. 

“I like to be establishing best practices, not following best practices,” said Supervisor Dave Cortese, who represents San Jose, Milpitas and Sunnyvale. “It shows somewhere along the line Oregon made a commitment to transparency. So shame on us.”

This article is part of the California Divide, a collaboration among newsrooms examining income inequality and economic survival in California.

CalMatters.org is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media venture explaining California policies and politics.


Company to Streamline Rebuilding Process for CZU Fire Victims

0

Santa Cruz County will hire a company to handle the permitting process for residents rebuilding homes damaged or destroyed in the CZU Lightning Complex fire.

The county Board of Supervisors on Tuesday unanimously approved the plan to hire Pleasanton-based engineering firm 4Leaf, Inc. to set up and manage a Recovery Permit Center in the County Building.

County officials say the move was a way to ease the already cumbersome permitting process for residents looking to rebuild.

A key part of that effort, said Assistant Planning Director Paia Levine, is contracting with a firm with experience handling the issues that arise after a large-scale disaster such as the CZU fires.

“The county is very committed to providing integrated, and dedicated, expedited permit processing services for the rebuilding effort after the fire,” she said. 

4Leaf is performing similar services in Sonoma County and in Paradise, both areas that sustained major damage from fires. 

The CZU fire destroyed a total of 1,490 structures and damaged 140. Permit requests are expected to pour in over the next three years as residents prepare to rebuild.

“The goal is to take an application from clearance and intake through review and inspection,” Levine said.

4Leaf was chosen after a request for proposals process and two interviews by a wide range of county staff, Levine said. The company will be paid by a percentage of the permit revenue fees once they start coming in, which Levine said will take about one year. Until then, the county will pay a monthly minimum fee, in an amount “not to exceed $6.2 million,” according to the county.

The supervisors also heard a report on how the county has spent its $27.7 million share of the federal Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act.

Approved by Congress and President Donald Trump in March, the money is intended to help local jurisdictions weather the Covid-19 pandemic. The money must be spent by Dec. 31 and only for a narrow range of costs specifically related to dealing with the virus.

According to Santa Cruz County Budget Manager Christina Mowry, the county spent $6.7 million from March through June, largely on disaster service workers, public health and mental services and social distancing compliance.

This also includes $3.8 million to 93 businesses, and nearly $1 million in rent and utility assistance for 109 families. The funds have also gone to shelter for the homeless, and to the Great Plates Program, which pays restaurants to prepare meals for elderly residents. 

The county has $20.9 million leftover.

Hallcrest Vineyards’ Outstanding and Intense Merlot 2018

John Schumacher produces such a wide variety of wines at his Hallcrest Vineyards that it’s difficult to choose any particular one. But the 2018 Merlot I found at the Summit Store in Los Gatos is a special wine that’s hard to beat. 

And when you taste wines from Hallcrest, you’re also tasting a piece of history. Nestled in the Santa Cruz Mountains, it was founded in the 1880s by the Hall family—initially as a retreat from their home in San Francisco. A vineyard was planted in 1941, and the first vintage was in  1946.

Nowadays, Hallcrest is owned and operated by Schumacher, and after decades in the business he’s making some outstanding wines. The 2018 Muro Vineyard Merlot ($48) is a testament to his skills, and it’s a perfect wine for the upcoming holidays. “The flavor profile,” says Schumacher, “is firm and well-made—with intense brambly fruit along with sage tea and nutmeg. I am so proud to release this.”

Schumacher also operates a wholly organic line of wines under his Organic Wine Works label. Folks looking for 100% organic without added sulfites should head to Hallcrest’s tasting room to sample them, plus all their other wines. Covid-19 rules change often, so check first if they’re open. 

Hallcrest Vineyards, 379 Felton Empire Road, Felton. 831-335-4441, hallcrestvineyards.com.

Taquitos Nayarit

Picture this: A lush vineyard on a bright sunny day in October. This was the setting for a friend’s invitation to a gathering in his vineyard. As well as an abundance of wines to try, a taco truck also awaited to serve tasty food to hungry guests.

Taquitos Nayarit cooks up terrific nosh, that’s for sure. Once you have selected chicken, pork or beef on your taco, then you simply add all the trimmings—including spicy peppers and hot sauce. Based in Castroville, Maria and Ernesto travel all over with their taco truck. We shared a table with Jimmy Sampson, a manager at his parents’ company Airtight Vinyl Siding and Windows in Soquel.

Taquitos Nayarit, Merrit Street, Castroville. Maria’s cell: 831-588-8168; Ernesto’s cell: 831-227-1287.

Things To Do in Santa Cruz: Nov. 18-24

Because many in-person events across Santa Cruz County have been canceled or postponed during the pandemic, Good Times is compiling a weekly list of virtual events hosted by local nonprofits, artists, fitness instructors and businesses. To submit your virtual event, send an email to ca******@*******es.sc

ARTS AND MUSIC 

FRIENDS OF THE SANTA CRUZ PUBLIC LIBRARY BOOKSTORE Visit us to see the treasures we have! Our Bookstore sells great low priced books of many genres for adults and children. Sales support the Santa Cruz Public Library system. Open every day. Mondays-Thursdays: 10am-6pm, Fridays and Saturdays: 10am-4pm, and Sundays: 1-4pm. Staffed by volunteers, the store is located in the Downtown Public Library at 224 Church St. in Santa Cruz. 

SHE ADVENTURES FILM TOUR VIRTUAL SCREENING This collection of the most inspirational, heartwarming and entertaining films celebrates women in adventure from independent filmmakers around the globe. The She Adventures Film Tour includes a unique selection of films of varying lengths and styles covering topics relevant to women in the outdoors who aren’t afraid to get dirty in their pursuit of adventure. Our aim at the She Adventures Film Tour is to build a community who support adventurous women. By showcasing and celebrating the female adventurous spirit, we hope to make women in the outdoors more visible. But She Adventures isn’t just for women. She Adventures is for all of us to celebrate diversity and inclusion and the inspiring ladies of the adventure world. Presented by the Rio Theatre. Nov. 12-22 only. Once you start viewing the program you have 48 hours to finish watching it or until midnight on Nov. 22, whichever comes first. Learn more: riotheatre.com/events-2/2020/11/11/she-adventures-film-tour

SALSA SUELTA IN PLACE FREE ZOOM SESSION For all dance-deprived dancers! Free weekly online session in Cuban-style Salsa Suelta for experienced beginners and up. May include Mambo, ChaChaCha, Afro-Cuban Rumba, Orisha, Son Montuno, Cuban-Salsa. Ages 14 and up. Thursdays at 7pm. Contact to get Zoom link: salsagente.com

CHRISTMAS CAROL 2: SCROOGE STRIKES BACK This year Scrooge strikes back with one night of jingle hell carnage. Take a fog-soaked comedy carriage ride through Zoom-era London where Scrooge, newly refreshed with the Christmas Spirit, turns his greed into zealotry. Armed with a new and fanatical devotion to Christmas, Ebenezer is launching an offensive offense on the holiest of holiday seasons. It’s up to a handful of ghosts, urchins, the father of modern psychiatry, and an obsessed detective to stop him or face one unholy night of jingle hell carnage! Live Zoom viewing: 7:30 pm on Nov. 20–21, and 3pm on Nov. 22. More Info: arts.ucsc.edu/news_events/christmas-carol-2-scrooge-strikes-back. Free and open to the public. 

MY FIRST BOOK CLUB Reading is thinking—know a virtual learner who would benefit from participating in an engaging book club? Watsonville Public Library’s “My First Bookclub” program will meet online twice a month to read a picture book, have a discussion, and enjoy a fun activity. School-age children in grades 1-3 and 4-5 are encouraged to participate. To register visit: bit.ly/wplfirstclub. 3pm. Watsonville Public Library, 275 Main St., Suite 100, Watsonville.

CLASSES

TECH TALKS: STORAGE & BACKUPS (IPHONE/IPAD) Know your strategy for backing up your mobile data. Are you confident that your iPhone/iPad device is backed up? Join us on Zoom as we review the options and strategies for managing files and keeping backups. Register now at: santacruzpl.libcal.com/event/7215794. 11am. Santa Cruz Public Libraries, Downtown Branch, 224 Church St., Santa Cruz.

CORE TEACHINGS OF THE BUDDHA (ONLINE) Core Teachings of the Buddha: A Walking the Dhamma Path class series. This course is offered to any student wishing to dive a little deeper into Buddhism’s basic teachings. The 16-week Monday evening class has been divided into four units. Each 1.5 hour program will include time for practice and a dharma talk, as well as discussion time. While we are asking that interested students register for the course, it is not necessary to commit to each offering, and all are welcome. Online Meeting ID: 870 9882 0580. Zoom Link: us02web.zoom.us/j/87098820580?pwd=bkg4cVhkUnFGZjJkZ1pPVC8vd01UQT09. Please register by emailing Carol Morgan: ca*************@***il.com with subject “Registration for Core Teachings.” 6:30pm Monday, Nov. 23.

COMMUNITY 

RESTORATIVE SELF CARE FOR CZU WILDFIRE SURVIVORS The CZU fire has wreaked havoc on our community. Even now, weeks later, you may notice that you’re still experiencing a disruption to your sleep patterns, being in emotional pain, suffering from incessant worry, feeling unsafe or easily startled, or just completely overwhelmed with all that you are dealing with. If so, you are not alone. Since the fires broke out in August, our community has suffered greatly, yet we’ve also shown the ability to come together to support one another, confide in one another, and encourage one another. This six-week series is a time to meet with other community members to help begin the healing process. Each evening we will explore different practices to help you manage the impact of the upheaval you’ve been through, using breathing, gentle stretching, guided meditation, journaling and time for connecting with each other. 7-8:30pm. Luma Yoga And Family Center, 1010 Center St., Santa Cruz.

GROUPS

OVEREATERS ANONYMOUS The new time of 6:30pm begins May 6, 2020. All our OA meetings have switched to being online. Please call 831-429-7906 for meeting information. Do you have a problem with food? Drop into a free, friendly Overeaters Anonymous 12-Step meeting. All are welcome! This meeting is bilingual, English and Spanish. La nueva hora de las 6:30 pm comienza el 6 de mayo de 2020. Todas nuestras reuniones de OA han pasado a estar en línea. Llame al 831-429-7906 para obtener información sobre la reunión. ¿Tienes algún problema con la comida? Participe en una reunión gratuita y amistosa de 12 pasos para comedores anónimos. ¡Todos son bienvenidos! Esta reunión es bilingüe, inglés y español. 6:30-7:30pm. Watsonville Volunteer Center, 12 Carr St. Watsonville, Santa Cruz.

VIRTUAL YOUNG ADULT (18-30) TRANSGENDER SUPPORT GROUP A weekly peer support group for young adults aged 18-25 who identify as transgender, non-binary, genderqueer, agender, or any other non-cisgender identity. This is a social group where we meet and chat among ourselves, sharing our experiences and thoughts in a warm, welcoming setting. Our meetings will be held on Discord during the shelter-in-place order. For more info, contact Ezra Bowen at tr***@*************er.org.

LGBTQNBI+ SUPPORT GROUP FOR CORONAVIRUS STRESS This weekly LGBTQNBI+ support group is being offered to help us all deal with stress during the shelter-in-place situation that we are experiencing from the coronavirus. Feel free to bring your lunch and chat together to get support. This group is offered at no cost and will be facilitated by licensed therapists Shane Hill, Ph.D., and Melissa Bernstein, LMFT #52524. Learn how to join the Zoom support group at diversitycenter.org/community-calendar

OUTDOOR

TIBETAN SOUND HEALING MEDITATION (OUTDOORS) Sound healing is a sacred and powerful meditative practice that has grown enormously in popularity in recent years. Come join a small, socially distanced, outdoor gathering in our meadow. Let Kalden’s soothing sound meditation bring ease to your nervous system and aid in the expression of positive feelings such as peace, joy and connectedness. 4pm. Land of Medicine Buddha, 5800 Prescott Road, Soquel.

Biden’s Election Brings DACA Recipients New Hope

Biden said DREAMers and their parents should have a path to citizenship

‘Love You Madly’ Livestream Features Bonnie Raitt, Boz Scaggs and More

Fire relief campaign bringing out eye-opening efforts from local and national musicians

LGBTQ Community Makes Big Strides in Local Elections

Incoming mayors Jimmy Dutra and Donna Meyers reflect on diversity

Ballet Theatre Filming Virtual ‘Nutcracker’ Performance

Alumni-driven film will replace the annual stage version put on by the Santa Cruz Ballet Theatre

New Environmental Report Out on Highway 1 Widening, Bus Lanes

Traffic
Comment period is now open on draft EIR for auxiliary lanes

As Broad Shutdowns Return, Weary Californians Ask ‘Is This the Best We Can Do?’

Backward slide on reopening represents another financial setback in a bleak year

Oregon Posts Workplace Outbreaks; California Has No Such Plan

California shields businesses so as not to shame them about Covid-19 outbreaks

Company to Streamline Rebuilding Process for CZU Fire Victims

Engineering company 4Leaf is performing similar services following fires in Sonoma County and Paradise

Hallcrest Vineyards’ Outstanding and Intense Merlot 2018

The 2018 Muro Vineyard Merlot is perfect for the upcoming holidays

Things To Do in Santa Cruz: Nov. 18-24

Tech talks, restorative self care, sound meditation, and more things to do in the week ahead
17,623FansLike
8,845FollowersFollow