Live music highlights for the week of Oct. 31, 2018.
WEDNESDAY 10/31
BRAZILIAN
SAMBADÁ
Two decades is a long time for a band, but local Santa Cruz institution SambaDá seems like it’s just getting started. What started out as a modest dance project in 1998 by Brazilian native Papiba Godinho has blossomed into a lively ensemble of local hotshots. The group has earned the reputation as the go-to Brazilian band on the West Coast. At this show, they will be celebrating their anniversary by featuring players who have played with the group over the years. Oh, and it’s Halloween, so wear something this year! AARON CARNES
On Halloween, the Suborbitals are going to set their dark and original music to the 1922 silent film Häxan. As the creepy black-and-white film sputters out archaic images of witchcraft and demonology, the Suborbitals will play both ringmaster and hypnotist, transfixing the audience with their soft and haunting emo-lounge tones. Their clever lyrics, often laying benign under the surface of gothy-jazz, will undoubtedly rise and come to life in joyous morbidity when paired with the grainy otherworldliness of a film so old and subversive it might crumble in the harsh daylight. AMY BEE
INFO: 8 p.m., Michael’s on Main, 2591 Main St., Soquel. $10. 479-9777.
THURSDAY 11/1
CAJUN
JIMMY BREAUX TRIO
Few people are more steeped, stewed and sauteed in Cajun music than Jimmy Breaux. The fourth-generation Louisianan has Creole melodies in his veins; as a member of preeminent Cajun band Beausoleil (where his accordion was often the star) he was an ambassador for America’s Southern music, and as a solo artist he is a Le Cajun Music Awards “Album of the Year” winner. Get ready for a set of Cajun classics, as well as originals. MIKE HUGUENOR
INFO: 9 p.m. The Crepe Place, 1134 Soquel Ave., Santa Cruz. $10. 429-6994
FRIDAY 11/2
FOLK-ROCK
AUSTIN LOUNGE LIZARDS
Banana Slugs rejoice! The Austin Lounge Lizards are back in town, ready to dazzle with humorous, progressive zingers and serious bluegrass/country songwriting. The best spoof songs are the ones where the audience forgets it’s a spoof and abandons pretense to sing along wholeheartedly. Most of the Lizards’ repertoire is just like that: clever enough to laugh at, skilled enough to be catchy and also musically sincere—like Weird Al, but more overtly left-leaning and anchored securely in a folksy motif. The Lizards have universal appeal, from the literary high-minded to anyone who admires a great chorus coupled with a killer punchline. AB
Mark Twain once said “Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry and narrow-mindedness”—and by those standards, Saritah is one woke musician. The reggae singer was born in Seoul, lived in England and currently resides in Australia. With such a broad perspective on life, she drops upbeat reggae tunes filled with love, laughter and hope. Oh, and she loves Santa Cruz, as evident in the 2012 “Tears of Joy” video that she shot at the Boardwalk, Cowell’s Beach and Ocean View Park. She will be joined at the Appleton Grill in Watsonville with the jinky sounds of Scooby and the Mystery Machine. MAT WEIR
After years of reworking songs, Steven Denmark released his debut album Cold Wind last year, packing it full of outlaw honkytonk and roadhouse tunes. Denmark might look young, but after listening to his album, it’s clear this artist has an old soul. He’ll be joined on stage with Santa Cruz County’s own outlaw rockers Southern Pacific. MW
They’ve been covered by Bonnie Raitt and Los Lobos. They count Bob Dylan and Elvis Costello as fans, and have even been the house band on The Simpsons. And 49 years later, the opening moments of NRBQ’s 1969 debut still sounds like they’re from another dimension. After one of the best shrieks in rock music, the “New Rhythm and Blues Quartet” open their (recently reissued) debut by bursting forth into the mutant boogie of “C’mon Everybody” before going straight into a Sun Ra cover. And that’s just the beginning for an album that fearlessly illustrates the genre-exploding possibilities of one of American rock’s best kept secrets. MH
It’s one thing to know Benny Green’s resume, how the 19-year-old Berkeley High graduate was discovered by legendary jazz vocalist Betty Carter. He landed his dream job with Art Blakey, started recording as a leader, and was embraced by Oscar Peterson was a worthy heir. It’s another matter to read about these events from Green’s point of view. As generous and heartfelt a writer as a he is a player, he’s one of jazz’s great raconteurs. His tales are full of humor, wisdom and drama. Green makes his annual fall appearance at Kuumbwa with his superlative trio featuring bassist David Wong and drummer Kenny Washington. ANDREW GILBERT
INFO: 7 p.m. Kuumbwa Jazz, 320-2 Cedar St., Santa Cruz. $33.60/adv, $38.85/door. 427-2227.
TUESDAY 11/6
SOUL
URAL THOMAS AND THE PAIN
The public’s thirst for old-school authentic soul led to the surprising (and deserved) late-in-life careers of Sharon Jones and Charles Bradley. The next guy to make that list could be almost-80-year-old Ural Thomas, a high energy soul singer, bubbling with a geyser of emotion underneath his finely crafted velvety voice. Thomas released a few singles in the late ’60s and gigged with everyone from the Rolling Stones to Otis Redding, but never made it out of obscurity. He came out of retirement in 2013 and released his debut LP with the Pain in 2016. He and his band will remind you of Stax era R&B jams that feel fresh and infectious. AC
Halloween issues are always fun, but usually we write something about ghosts, hauntings and other things that go bump in the night. This year, we thought we’d delve into a different rich vein of spooky fun: aliens. The trick is that Wallace Baine’s cover story about Frank Drake, the founder of the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence, is actually a serious and thoughtful look at the state of our understanding of the universe. NBD! The treat is … well, that it’s a serious and thoughtful look at the state of our understanding of the universe. And that Drake himself is such a fascinating figure. And that SETI is experiencing a rebirth right now, and the future is bright for the science of interplanetary relations.
This week is also our final installment of the election guide that we’ve been doling out over the last three weeks. Kudos to Jacob Pierce and the whole news team for an excellent job on a huge task. Don’t forget to vote Nov. 6!
I think a lot about the housing situation of the many people I depend on to make my life work well. I depend on the medical assistant at my healthcare clinic, the server at my favorite café, the young teacher at my niece’s school, the worker who maintains my favorite parks, the farmworker who picks the vegetables I eat, and the ambulance driver who might someday assist my family.
I want my neighbor’s daughter, who’s lived here her whole life and helps disabled seniors, to be able to remain here. If these family members and neighbors and service providers aren’t able to live somewhere in the county, the quality of our lives will be diminished. These points are at the heart of why so many, including homeowners like me, support Measure H, which will provide affordable housing for working families and vulnerable people in our community. Vote Yes on H.
Don Lane
Santa Cruz
Effects of Rent Control
Google the long term effects of rent control and you will find studies that show that after a few years it reduces the supply of rentals, which leads to higher rents. Having lived through the inception of rent control in Santa Monica in the ’70s, I can agree with that and some other findings. Landlords gravitated to the most affluent tenants who would often pay for their own maintenance. The weekly papers which preceded Craigslist had many ads offering “key fees,” thousands of dollars for referrals to rent-controlled apartments. Apartment buildings were abandoned, unpainted and landscaping non-existent. And some folks on fixed incomes or low incomes were allowed to stay.
Santa Cruz needs lots of new affordable apartments. Compared to other coastal cities, we have lots of vacant land and low-rise buildings. The city government can make this happen by expediting the permit process and taxing vacant land and providing public housing for the poor. Telling someone what to charge for something they own is cumbersome and counterproductive.
Paul Cocking
Santa Cruz
PHOTO CONTEST WINNER
Submit to ph****@*******es.sc. Include information (location, etc.) and your name. Photos may be cropped. Preferably, photos should be 4 inches by 4 inches and minimum 250dpi.
GOOD IDEA
Volunteers have opened the Annual Holiday Gift Shop at Valley Churches United in Ben Lomond for the season. This year’s experience includes an “exquisite shabby chic décor,” according to a press release from executive director Lynn Robinson. The store has toys, jewelry, vintage items, Christmas decorations, and household items. Through Christmas Eve, it is open weekdays from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. and weekends from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Proceeds support the Valley Churches United food pantry. For more information, call 336-8258.
GOOD WORK
The city has shuttered its homeless camp on River Street, and with it the Harvey West storage facility. Luckily, the Warming Center’s Brent Adams and other activists have started the Day & Night Storage Program. Located at 150 Felker St. Suite H, in Santa Cruz, the center will throw a party 7:30-9:30 p.m on Saturday, Nov. 3. There will be “scrumptious appetizers,” juice, and “adult libations,” according to a press release from Adams, who says the program has been operating for five months.
QUOTE OF THE WEEK
“Life teaches you how to live it, if you live long enough.”
Marketing and communications professional Liv O’Keeffe always did love plants. A California native, at age eight she nicknamed her first house plant and caught polliwogs at the nearby swamp. A few years ago, she left her corporate job to join one of the world’s most influential botanical conservation organizations and has since bridged the botanical world with communications to spread the love of our natural world.
INFO: 7 p.m. Thursday Nov. 1. UCSC Arboretum, Horticulture II Building, 1156 High St., Santa Cruz. 502-2998, arboretum.ucsc.edu. Free.
Art Seen
12×12 Exhibition
12 inches by 12 inches isn’t a large size for a canvas, but you’ll be surprised what artists can do within this simple square. Cabrillo’s 12×12 exhibit and fundraiser is back again, featuring work that can be larger than life, but must fit into a 12×12 box. The show is open to any and all California artists, so there will be a wide variety of work from across the state. Make sure to cast your vote for your favorite pieces—three will win the popular vote awards.
It’s not New Year’s yet, but the Santa Cruz Public Library is already out with the old and in with the new. Just in time for Halloween the library is giving out free books because they are overstocked and trying to make more space. It’s like trick or treating at the library, but they are giving out books instead of candy. There’s guaranteed to be a wide assortment of books for any and all bookworms. Who said nothing in life is free?
INFO: 12:30-2:30 p.m. Downtown Santa Cruz Public Library. 224 Church St., Santa Cruz. 427-7707. fscpl.org. Free.
Saturday 11/3
Día de los Muertos Festival
Join the Museum of Art and History in celebrating the Day of the Dead, Día de los Muertos, the Mexican holiday remembering and respecting those who have died. Followed by All Saints’ and All Souls’ Day on Nov. 1, Día de Los Muertos is traditionally celebrated by dedicating altars or ofrendas to loved ones and decorating them with marigolds and calaveras (sugar skulls). The celebration features live music, face painting, dance performances and an altar contest. The event begins on Cooper Street and in Abbott Square and will continue through downtown Santa Cruz to the Evergreen Cemetery. Feel free to join in and follow the procession at the start, or meet them along the way.
INFO: 12:30-6 p.m. Begins at 118 Cooper St., Santa Cruz. santacruzmah.org. Free.
Sunday 11/4
UCSC Farm Tour
Summer is slow to leave, but who is complaining? It’s almost November, and the farmers markets are still packed with peppers, tomatoes and other summer goodies. Early fall is one of the best harvest times of the year, with all of the pumpkins and winter squash coming in, and there are few better places to see it all in action than UCSC’s 30-acre organic farm. The Farm features tractor-worked fields, hand-worked gardens, orchards, greenhouses, and a children’s garden. There are free tours on the first Sunday of every month, but rain cancels them so check it out while the weather is still promising.
INFO: 2-3:30 p.m. Park and start at Cowell Ranch Historic Haybarn. 459-3240. casfs.ucsc.edu. Free, no reservations necessary.
Winemaker Barry Jackson has taken the Fiano grape and turned it into a lovely white wine. Fiano, native to the southern Italian province of Campania, is aromatic, crisp and delicate. A high-quality white Italian grape, Fiano has intense floral aromas and notes of honey and spice.
Expert winemaker Jackson has made an intriguing Fiano, which I first happened to try when in his tasting room to sample his Equinox sparkling wines. Fiano can be nutty and rich, and some people find it piney and herbaceous. Jackson’s well-made Fiano is extremely flavorful with a lovely smoky minerality. It’s always exciting to venture out and try lesser-known wines, and Jackson is an ace at making artful libations.
The Fiano sells for $26 a bottle and you can find it at the Equinox/Bartolo tasting room. Jackson and his wife Jennifer moved into the busy Surf City Vintners complex a couple of years ago from their previous location on Swift Street. They’re located opposite Santa Cruz Mountain Brewing and next door to West End Tap & Kitchen—an ideal spot for food, wine and brewskies.
Equinox/Bartolo, 334 Ingalls St., Unit C, Santa Cruz, 471-8608. equinoxwine.com.
Children’s Etiquette Class for Ages 9 to 13
Just in time for the holiday season, Karen Anne Murray, proprietress of Eddison and Melrose Oats and Scones Tea Cottage, will be doing a two-part class on etiquette for children—including eye contact, handshakes, table manners, electronic-device manners, and table setting. Tea and treats will be included, and each student will get a certificate of completion. Murray, who hails from England, says that in our modern world, some old-fashioned values are still required. Classes are 1:45-3 p.m. Nov. 3 and Nov. 10 and the cost is $65. I took a friend to Oats and Scones for afternoon tea recently and we loved the dainty sandwiches, English scones, sausage rolls, and cupcakes, all served beautifully on fine china. Murray’s tea room is charming, and I love the touches of dear old Blighty.
Oats and Scones Tea Cottage, 1180 Forest Ave., Suite G, Pacific Grove, 601-4851. eddisonandmelrose.com.
The first time that local experimental psych rock band Marmalade Knives played a gig, it was at a record store in Oakland as a trio.
Guitarist Clinton Wilkins and Justin Spivey—who’d been collaborating on spaced-out instrumental jams—got Spivey’s girlfriend to join them for the show on synths. The trio played a low-key 25-minute set.
“The crowd was very enthusiastic, but it appeared that they were anticipating more,” Wilkins says. “We were like, ‘That’s it.’”
Spivey and Wilkins had already been talking about getting a bassist and drummer to join them. After witnessing how the band after them—who had a full rock set-up—absolutely killed, they knew they had to add more members.
Eventually they found bassist Mark Robinson and drummer Kyle Partridge to join their group. The new set-up added some structure to the chaos they’d been creating as two sonically adventurous guitarists jamming together. They see these two polar opposite impulses as elements to be balanced with one another.
“We’re constantly trying to tweak the formula and bring in more elements of that former experimentation, and touches of minimalism, but at the same time really wanting to be heavy and full-tilt in this vein of ‘free rock,’ which is what I like to call it,” Wilkins says.
One thing they held on to fully from the old days is being a strictly instrumental band. That may change in the future, but for now, they like the creative freedom it provides.
“There’s so much going on instrumentally that in a way it’s hard to find space for it,” Wilkins says of adding vocals. “The way I look at it with a lot of the guitar lines, they’re singing. There are a lot of melodies that are being framed by the guitar.”
Currently, the group is working on an album, and hopes to have it finished and pressed on vinyl by the end of the year.
Sergio Di Sarro, co-owner of Star Bene on East Cliff Drive, has some news to announce.
He and his wife Julieta Fernandez Vidal areplanning to open a new location in the Scotts Valley area focused on banquets, catering, weddings and receptions. Di Sarro, a surfer, moved to Santa Cruz in the late 1990s, while in pursuit of “the perfect wave,” he says.
He and Fernandez Vidal bought Star Bene, an Italian restaurant, 11 years ago, and quickly incorporated elements from their native Argentina. Curious customers, Di Sarro says, sometimes ask why he combined Argentine and Italian cuisines.
Di Sarro, whose parents immigrated to Argentina from Italy, doesn’t think of his restaurant as some quirky brand of fusion food. To him, his menu is no more surprising than those found at New York-Italian restaurants, created by the descendants of families that traveled to the United States in the aftermath of World War I. “Because immigration,” he says.
What’re you doing right now?
SERGIO DI SARRO: I’m cooking a Bolognese sauce. It’s the sauce you use for ground beef. You cook it with fresh herbs, garlic, strong red wine, fresh tomato, a little bit of homemade marinara.
What vibe do you try to create?
Star Bene used to be more like a fine dining room, but I saw this as a very casual town full of surfers. I’m a surfer, OK? I said, “How come surfers don’t come to Star Bene?” My vibe is best-friendly. We have a special patio. We tend to create a family business feel, because grandma will come to the table, or my brother will come to the table or my 16-year-old son. If you want a romantic corner, we do have a romantic corner, as well. Valentines’—we decorate. But we create a vibe for family. It’s a casual restaurant. I’m trying to make you feel like you’re in your home.
Pizza or empanada?
Empanada, buddy. Soon in the next place, we’re gonna do a little more empanada. You’ll be able to request flavors. You can get big orders. We’re happy and so grateful for this town.
Star Bene. 2-1245 East Cliff Drive, Santa Cruz, 479-4307.
Beyond the trivialities of everyday life and the freak show of contemporary culture, there are only three questions truly worth pondering: Is there life after death? What is the fate of humanity? Are we alone in the universe?
Frank Drake may have opinions on the first two—who doesn’t? On the third, though, he might be as close to an empirical answer as any person, living or dead, has ever been. In the broad field of study known as the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI), Drake is the essential figure.
In fact, he’s SETI’s George Washington.
Almost 60 years ago, as a young Harvard-educated physicist, he conducted SETI’s first serious experiment, convened its first all-star scientific conference and drew up the famous Drake Equation that forms the fundamental framework scientists still use to estimate the number of technologically advanced civilizations that might exist in our galaxy.
Now, at 88, Drake is tracking from his home in Santa Cruz County an unlikely turn of events only slightly less miraculous than contact with an alien species: A second life for SETI.
The Great Martian Chase
In 1993, Congress zeroed out government funding for the SETI program administered by NASA; the program was lampooned by the senator who introduced the amendment to kill it as “The Great Martian Chase.” From that point forward, SETI was pushed to science’s back burner, muddling along on inconsistent private donations and struggling to maintain research momentum.
But today things are dramatically different for SETI, largely thanks to Russian-born Silicon Valley venture capitalist Yuri Milner—who was born the same year as the Drake Equation, and was named after Soviet cosmonaut Yuri Gagarin. In 2015, Milner announced the establishment of Breakthrough Listen, an enormous moonshot SETI project to which he has pledged $100 million.
“It’s changed everything,” says Drake. “We’re not scrounging around trying to raise money anymore. He’s guaranteed $10 million a year for 10 years. One of the problems we’ve had is that we could never plan for the future. We couldn’t create a program beyond a year because we never had the funding. Now we do.”
Does this mean that Close Encounters is now close? Probably not, say some who are involved in SETI. But the Breakthrough Listen funding, along with access to new and powerful telescopes, represents an expanding of vision. Where once we were looking through a narrow window in a small room, now we can step outside to see a bigger piece of sky.Before 1960, American pop culture was awash in aliens, especially at the drive-in theater—It Came From Outer Space, The Thing From Another World, Invasion of the Saucer Men, among many others all exploited a template established by the H.G. Wells novel War of the Worlds.
At the time, the idea of life elsewhere in the universe was firmly in the realm of cheesy sci-fi paranoia, but that was merely a sign of the times. Contemplating other worlds has been a human preoccupation for eons. As far back as 300 B.C., the Greek philosopher Epicurus was pushing the idea that there must be other worlds like our own.
But before the Drake Equation, no one had applied the rigor of science to the question.
“Frank turned into a science,” says astrophysicist Andrew Siemion, the director of the Berkeley SETI Research Center. “He took something that was at the time philosophically important—almost a religious question—and brought it into the realm of modern scientific inquiry.”
A Beautiful Equation
Siemion occupies the Bernard M. Oliver Chair of SETI Research at the SETI Institute in Mountain View, and is a lead researcher at Breakthrough Listen. “It’s impossible to overstate Frank’s importance to the field on so many levels,” he says. “He was the general in the battle to create the field, and he was the statesman that allowed it to flourish.”
In 1960 at the Green Bank Observatory in West Virginia, Drake aimed a radio telescope at two nearby stars to see if he might be able to detect radio waves coming from other civilizations. He called the experiment Project Ozma, borrowed from L. Frank Baum’s The Wizard of Oz.
The idea was simple: Radio signals on certain frequencies can leave a planet’s atmosphere and, theoretically, travel to distant points in the galaxy, thus providing proof of a technological civilization. (Some of our civilization’s earliest, and thus farther out in space, signals are broadcasts of Nazi propaganda including Hitler speeches, providing a potentially awkward moment if they ever reach otherworldly ears).
In ’61, Drake presided over a secret meeting at Green Bank featuring some of the marquee names in the field—including a young Carl Sagan—in a meeting that SETI people like to call “The Order of the Dolphin,” because the work of one of the attendees was an attempt to decode dolphin language.
From that meeting came the Drake Equation, which even today is to SETI scientists what Stairway to Heaven is to fans of dad rock: That One Thing Everybody Knows.
CONSTANT QUEST A photo of scientist Frank Drake from early in his career.
The Drake Equation is less an equation to be solved and more of a way to think about the probabilities of communicating with an alien culture. It is essentially a string of variables, each one narrowing the probabilities that any given Earth-bound scientist on any given day might encounter a radio signal from another world. The variables include the number of stars like the sun; the number of those stars with a planetary system; the number of planets in those systems in a habitable zone for life; the number of those planets where life is likely to have emerged in some way; the number of those life-friendly planets in which “intelligent” life might have evolved; the number of the intelligent-life planets that might have developed technology that could be transmitted and detected; and the length of time civilizations are likely to last.
“[The equation] is not really about a number,” says astrophysicist Griffin Foster, another Breakthrough Listen researcher. “It’s more about a philosophy.” Foster says the beauty of the equation is how it invites engaged minds from other sciences and even the humanities. Some of the variables are less about physics than about biology and chemistry. What constitutes “intelligent” life or a “technological” society is something that social scientists can chew on. And the length of time that a civilization typically lasts is a question for the historian.
“It’s not for any single individual to solve,” says Foster. “It’s a societal question. The scope of the problem is so big that it’s not about trying to find some basic law of physics, but really about how we fit in the universe.”
The Drake Equation is durable even in other fields, such as exoplanet research or astrobiology, the field that explores planets in the “Goldilocks zone” for signs of water or other indicators of primitive life. MIT’s Sara Seager, one of the most prominent exoplanet researchers in the field, has come up with a riff on Drake’s equation (yep, it’s the Seager Equation) that is more adaptable to her interests.
“I asked him about it,” she says by phone from her office at MIT. “I just wanted to make sure it was all OK with him. No one wants to have someone take their work and mangle it. What I’ve done is more of a tribute [to the Drake Equation] than anything else. He was actually very nice about it.”
Beaming Into Space
Who knows what kind of breathtakingly cool art hangs in the elite private homes of the Bay Area? But it’s hard to conceive of anything more badass than what Frank Drake has in the house near Aptos that he shares with his wife Amahl. It is a stained-glass window version of “The Arecibo Message,” a pictorial illustration transmitted into space in 1974 from the Arecibo radio telescope in Puerto Rico. The message, designed by Drake, transmits information about atoms, DNA, and the basics of the solar system.
It looks like the crudest prototype of a videogame, and Drake himself says, “In my judgment, it’s pretty bad.” But it’s been hurtling out into space at the speed of light for 44 years. No one else can make such a claim for their interior décor.
A few years after creating the Arecibo Message, Drake was also involved in the creation of “the Golden Record,” a double-disc copper-plate phonograph recording featuring a number of sounds and music to represent Earth, from Stravinsky’s Rite of Spring to Chuck Berry’s Johnny B. Goode. The recording was packed onboard the Voyager space probe, which today is the most distant human-made object from Earth.
“There’s long sections of sounds from Earth: chainsaws, airplanes, babies crying,” says Drake, hovering over a replica of the Golden Record, speculating on some potential curious alien intercepting the Voyager. “Once they figure out how to use the stylus, we tell them how fast to spin the record.”
Even before Breakthrough Listen, Drake was not prone to sit around wallowing in nostalgia. His CV is peppered with honors and prestigious positions in the sciences. The former Dean of Natural Sciences at UC Santa Cruz has also sat for years on the board of the SETI Institute.
But Breakthrough Listen has given an adrenaline boost to Drake’s life-long quest to find evidence of other civilizations. Not only has Milner’s millions brought new muscle to SETI, but the new, bleeding-edge MeerKAT radio telescope in South Africa, which launched just three months ago, promises to open up vast new possibilities for the project.
The MeerKAT, the Parkes Telescope in Australia and the Green Bank Telescope, at the site where SETI was born with Project Ozma, are the three major points where Breakthrough Listen has raised the stakes of listening in on the universe’s radio waves.
Griffin Foster, a researcher at Oxford University who is also a visiting scholar at the Berkeley SETI Research Center and has worked for Breakthrough Listen at MeerKAT in South Africa, says the approach of Breakthrough Listen has been primarily to spend its time and money on the big telescopes.
“There was a lot of talk about the best way to scale this up,” he says. “The idea was let’s not just fund some research project. Let’s buy telescope time. Let’s do thousands of hours of observing. And instead of looking at just a few stars, let’s look at thousands. And now with MeerKAT, we can look at millions of stars.”
In less than 60 years, SETI has gone from analyzing one radio channel to using spectrum analyzers that can handle 10 billion channels at one time. And yet the work is still the same: to look for electromagnetic signals that are different from those natural objects produce.
“The only thing that’s different about [Breakthrough] Listen from what Frank did,” says Andrew Siemion, “is simply scale and intensity. We’re doing more and more observing, with better instruments and faster computers. But we’re still using the Drake Equation. We can plot Frank’s experiments on a graph with the experiments we do today, and we can make comparisons between them because his experiments are as fundamentally and scientifically credible today as they were back in 1960 when he was doing them.”
The telescopes in the Southern Hemisphere are especially valuable, because, from a SETI point of view, that’s the most compelling angle at which to view the Milky Way.
“What’s interesting about the Southern Hemisphere,” says Foster, “is that’s where you can see the galactic center the best. If there’s an extraterrestrial technology out there, they might put beacons near the galactic center. So, that’s a very exciting region to look at.”
“SETI is much better and in a more stable state than it has ever been,” says Drake. “The rate we’re observing now, we’re doing as much searching in a couple of days as we did with all the previous searching put together.”
Waiting for the Signal
Frank Drake is a scientist, which means he doesn’t have much use for fantasy. In the Hollywood narrative, when the friendly advanced civilization finally answers our call, Frank would be the respected elder flown in by helicopter by the president for the honor of representing the Earth.
“The idea that you’re going to communicate, that you’re going to ask questions and get answers, that’s absurd,” he says. “That’s not going to happen. The nearest technological civilization is probably a thousand light-years away. That means any signal you get is already going to be a thousand years old. The hope is that you can detect a signal through the noise, watch their television, so that you can learn a lot about them without asking them anything.”
Drake says he’s an optimist, that in 10 to 20 years, given the vast space the new instruments will be covering, we may have some evidence of another technological civilization, even if it’s a long-extinct one.
“Mathematically, there has to be,” he says. “To say the universe is an empty void is not only presumptuous, but stupid. I think there may be an earlier discovery, that we’ll find [primitive] life elsewhere in the solar system. That will make concrete that the origins of life are common.”
As for SETI, says Drake: “It’s a lottery. The chance of winning is still very remote. But we’re buying a whole lot of tickets.”
[This is part three of our guide to the Nov. 6 election. Read about city and county candidates here, or area ballot measures here. — Editor]
U.S. Senate
Dianne Feinstein
Democrat
For 26 years, Dianne Feinstein has represented California in the U.S. Senate. Feinstein has long been a formidable presence in controversial national debates, from a 10-year assault weapon ban she has spent the last several years trying to revive to battles over post-9/11 surveillance measures. Most recently, it was Feinstein’s office that fielded sexual assault allegations against Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh. Feinstein is attempting to weather appeals for a post-Trump shakeup of the Democratic Party by touting a record of both state and national advocacy.She is emphasizing support for the Affordable Care Act, women’s health and immigrant rights.
Kevin de León
Democrat
After ascending the ranks in Sacramento, California Sen. Kevin de León has painted himself as the Golden State incarnation of the Bernie Sanders progressive wave. A native of San Diego, de León speaks often about growing up with his Guatemalan single mother and struggling to pay for housing, education and health care. In his first bid for federal office, he won the California Democratic Party endorsement over Feinstein, attacking the complacency of Washington politicians and the number of millionaires in the U.S. Senate. “The Washington status quo is either unwilling or incapable of fighting back,” de León wrote in his candidate statement. “Californians deserve a Senator who will fight for their futures.”
U.S. House of Representatives, 18th District
Anna Eshoo
Democrat
After 13 terms in Congress, Rep. Anna Eshoo shook up her congressional leadership roles last year, relinquishing her ranking position on the Communications and Technology Subcommittee to focus on health care. Now, in her campaign for re-election to represent the 18th District spanning the counties of Santa Cruz, San Mateo and Santa Clara, Eshoo has been targeted by drug pricing watchdog Patients for Affordable Drugs Action, which has stated that it planned to spend $500,000 to oppose Eshoo for “cozy ties to the drug industry.” Eshoo, meanwhile, has raised $1.3 million for her campaign, including more than $136,000 from pharmaceutical and health care companies. Eshoo is also attempting to head off discontent with the status quo, offering a “We Can Do Better” list of eight priorities for Capitol Hill, including overturning the Citizens United decision on campaign spending, barring former lawmakers from becoming lobbyists, outlawing gerrymandering and passing an updated Voting Rights Act.
Christine Russell
Republican
A Silicon Valley chief financial officer, 18th District challenger Christine Russell is putting fiscal restraint front and center in her campaign to upset 13-term incumbent Rep. Anna Eshoo. Russell, who has served as finance chief for tech companies including UniPixel, Vendavo, EAG, Virage Logic and OuterBay Technologies, is running on a platform to re-examine government from the ground up. Her campaign website includes a plan to “have all the agencies come before a committee and justify their existence and their budget.” Russell has also argued that “Technology should be introduced into the operations of all agencies” to cut costs and increase efficiency.
U.S. House of Representatives, 20th District
Jimmy Panetta
Democrat
U.S. Rep. Jimmy Panetta is seeking a second term in Congress after winning the seat of former Central Coast Rep. Sam Farr in 2016. Panetta, son of former Secretary of State and CIA Director Leon Panetta, worked as a deputy district attorney in Monterey County after completing a tour in Afghanistan in 2007 as a Navy Reserve intelligence officer. Currently a member of House committees on armed services and agriculture, Panetta has raised $1.1 million for his re-election campaign, including from donors in the ag business, banking and national defense. His platform centers on immigration reform with a pathway to U.S. citizenship, protecting the Central Coast environment by advocating for climate action and against offshore drilling. He is endorsed by a range of Democratic Party and labor groups. “I’ll continue to bring energy and new ideas to Congress and work together with all sides to get things done,” Panetta said in a candidate statement.
Ronald Paul Kabat
No Party Preference
Tax accountant and independent challenger Ronald Paul Kabat is contesting Panetta’s seat with a campaign focused on building a wall on the U.S.-Mexico border, reversing immigration sanctuary city policies and advocating for a government effort to build new housing units for homeless veterans. Kabat, who also ran for this same seat against Sam Farr in 2014, says he’s not accepting campaign funds from political action committees (PACs), labor unions or businesses. Still, his campaign website asserts that he is endorsed by the anti-property tax group the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association PAC. In addition to his hardline immigration stances, which his website says includes creating “a biometric tracking system” to monitor people with U.S. visas, Kabat is critical of government spending on safety net programs like social security. He did not file an official candidate statement in the 2018 race.
State Assembly, 29th District
Mark Stone
Democrat
Environmental protection and housing have been two dominant issues for Mark Stone since he joined the state Assembly in 2012—and he expects it to stay that way if re-elected to represent the 29th district covering the coast of Santa Cruz and Monterey counties, plus a swath of San Jose. An attorney and former county supervisor and coastal commissioner from Scotts Valley, Stone counts climate resilience issues like sea-level rise among those he has prioritized, along with reform for foster youth and juvenile justice. Should he return to Sacramento, Stone says he expects housing issues, such as state funding for local construction projects, to grow in urgency. “Whether it’s service workers, teachers—the people who make our economy work are not always able to live close to where they work,” he says.
Vicki L. Nohrden
Republican
District 29 Republican challenger Vicki Nohrden is aiming to parlay past involvement in the Central Coast justice system into a campaign for state assembly that puts public safety front and center. “I felt like I could make a difference,” says Nohrden, who is endorsed by area Republican groups, the California Pro-Life Council and Santa Cruz County Supervisor Greg Caput. “We’ve come to this place where across our district, it’s really been about party politics.” Since moving to the Monterey Peninsula in the 1980s, Nohrden has led family outreach for Monterey County Jail and the juvenile justice system. She’s also serves as a court appointed special advocate for foster youth. She hopes to reassert law enforcement authority and curb further government involvement in housing and homelessness. “We can’t just keep enabling this,” Nohrden says.
State Assembly, 30th District
Neil G. Kitchens
Republican
“I have a very eclectic background,” says rancher, forest manager, home health care business owner, former arena football player, and District 30 Assembly candidate Neil Kitchens. A political newcomer running as a Republican, Kitchens moved to the Salinas Valley at age 19 from Arkansas. He says a family background in forest management instilled a desire to more actively maintain and add emergency paths to area forests, which he blames “tree huggers” for making more vulnerable to wildfires. Kitchens similarly argues that first-hand experience running mental institutions after Reagan-era slashes to state psychiatric services has been similarly enlightening. “I’ve been on the ground doing this stuff, working with people,” Kitchens says, criticizing Sacramento lawmakers for “soft on crime” stances. “Nothing that we do here in California makes sense to me,” says Kitchens. “The rest of the country mocks and laughs at us, and I love this area.”
Robert Rivas
Democrat
After surviving a contentious Democratic primary and some $300,000 in opposition spending by oil and gas industry firms, San Benito County Supervisor and anti-fracking advocate Robert Rivas has entered the final phase of his campaign to replace termed-out Assemblymember Anna Caballero. Rivas, who grew up with his Mexican mother in farm worker housing near Hollister, is now endorsed by neighboring District 29 Assemblymember Mark Stone, state Sen. Bill Monning and the California Democratic Party. In his bid for statewide office, Rivas has hinged his campaign on advocating for adding jobs while maintaining affordability and improving infrastructure and access to social services like health care. “We need to give our communities the resources to keep our neighborhoods safe,” Rivas said in a campaign statement. “I’ll fight to make sure this remains the land of opportunity.”
It tookdecades for Joey Piscitelli to come forward with his story of abuse and another three years after that to take his accused rapist, Father Stephen Whelan, to court. But the Salesians of Don Bosco—the Catholic order that employed Whelan at a Bay Area all-boys high school where he was said to have assaulted Piscitelli from 1969 to 1971—treated the allegations as a joke.
In closing arguments during a 2006 jury trial, the Salesians compared Piscitelli to James Frey, the author who famously tried to pass off his novel A Million Little Pieces as a gritty addiction memoir. The defense produced a short video, which showed a mock book cover titled My Story of Abuse by Joey Piscitelli before flashing the word “fiction” in big, bold letters across the screen.
“They just made a mockery out of it,” Piscitelli, a 63-year-old East Bay resident, recalls. “Their lead attorney would laugh at me.”
Though he ultimately won two appeals anda $600,000 judgment, it wasn’t until a dozen years later—at 2 p.m. on Sept. 26—that he felt a measure of vindication.
That was the day last month when high-ranking officials from California Attorney General Xavier Becerra’s office, in response to a Sept. 8 letter from Piscitelli, summoned him, two fellow Bay Area members of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests—known as SNAP—and two frombishop-accountability.org to a 20th-floor conference room in a secure building on Harrison Street in downtown Oakland.
Melanie Fontes Rainer, a special assistant and chief healthcare adviser to Becerra, and AG researcher Daniel Bertoni joined them at a long oval conference table along with a handful of investigators in expensive-looking suits. From a wide screen on the wall, about 10 other state agents teleconferenced in for the meeting.
“We did most of the talking,” Piscitelli says. “They asked us about clergy exchanging child porn on the internet, taking kids from county to county or across state lines. They wanted to know which bishops were responsible for certain decisions to relocate known abusers. They wanted to know about human trafficking, child trafficking.”
Finally, he thought, a moment of reckoning would come.
The long-running Catholic clergy sex abuse scandal burst into public view with the Boston Globe’s storied “Spotlight” investigation in 2002 and Metro Silicon Valley’s reporting on the San Jose Diocese in the early 1990s. But the recent 900-pagecivil grand jury report exposing extensive coverups involving 300 “predator priests” abusing 1,000 children at six dioceses in Pennsylvania seems to mark an inflection point.
While individual priests have been charged with crimes by local police and some complicit superiors pushed into retirement by the powers that be, the U.S. government never probed the criminality of higher-ranking church leadership or organizational practices that exposed children to known abusers.
With the Justice Department launching a federal inquiry into clergy abuse in Pennsylvania this past month, law enforcement has fundamentally altered its relationship with the U.S. Catholic Church by reclaiming authority from the Vatican to police for its stateside criminal activities. David Hickton, former U.S. attorney for the Western District of Pennsylvania,told CNN that based on questions authorities are asking about human trafficking and child porn, he believes prosecutors are planning a racketeering case against church officials—the same tactic used to take downorganized crime syndicates.
Now, it appears that Becerra’s agents are looking into similar problems in California, which houses the largest population of Catholic clergy and parishioners in the country.
‘A culture of secrecy’
Renewed public outrage and intense legal scrutiny prompted Catholic church officials to make an effort to come clean. When the San Jose Diocese last week released the names of 15 priests credibly accused of sexual misconduct and pedophilia, Bishop Patrick McGrath said the move marked the end of “a culture of secrecy in the church” and the start of an era of transparency and accountability.
Events over the ensuing days made McGrath’s gesture look like something else entirely—less a show of good faith than a cynical attempt to get ahead of a fast-developing story and an unprecedented multi-jurisdictional criminal probe into clergy abuse.
Most of the abuse alleged against the list of 15 priests took place decades ago, with the most recent case in the early 2000s. Only six of the named priests are still alive: Don Flickinger, Robert Gray, Angel Mariano, Alexander Larkin, Phil Sunseri andHernan Toro. Seven had not previously been publicly identified as abusers. At least two—Toro, who’s in San Jose’s Main Jailon new molestation charges, and Leonel Noia—were reassigned to the ministry even after being criminally convicted of sex abuse.
It quickly became clear, however, that McGrath left a lot out.
The diocese failed to mention clergyaccused of abusing adults. It also failed to name priests not directly authorized by the diocese, such as Society of St. Pius X priest Benedict Van der Putten, who allegedly molested a teen girl in 2000 at St. Aloysius Retreat House in Los Gatos.
Last week, the Mercury Newspublished an exposé about an exorcist at Santa Clara’s Our Lady of Peace accused of sexually abusing a rape survivor from late 2011 through 2012. The priest, Rev. Gerardus Hauwert Jr., reportedly offered to help the victim when she went to confession seeking forgiveness for a trauma-induced sex addiction.
Two days later, Jeff Anderson & Associates, a Minnesota-based law firm,unveiled a 66-page report naming 263 priests in San Jose, Oakland and San Francisco dioceses credibly accused of sexually abusing kids. Using open-source data, the first-of-its-kind report identifies 135 accused abusers in the Archdiocese of San Francisco, 95 in Oakland and 33 in the San Jose diocese.
The Bay Area dioceses “subjected its parishioners to a public safety nightmare,” the Anderson report claims, calling the San Jose Diocese a “dumping ground” for “deviant priests.”
Historically, the Bay Area dioceses, like many of their counterparts throughout the state and around the nation, knew full well that priests endangered children and vulnerable adults but chose to keep their crimes secret, according to the Anderson report. Strict internal policies kept the scope of the problem hidden from the public throughout much of the 1980s and 1990s, despite government mandated reporting laws.
Over the past 15 years, policymakers have resisted laws to extend the statute of limitations for abuse survivors. Gov. Jerry Brown,who trained to be a Jesuit priest, vetoed two such bills, to the dismay of SNAP and other victim advocacy groups.
Jeff Anderson, who representssexual assault survivor Thomas Emens in a suit filed earlier this month in Los Angeles County Superior Court against all 12 of California’s Catholic bishops, including San Jose’s McGrath, says the church continues to hide information about sexually abusive priests. The lawsuit claims that the bishops continue to move problem priests between and among dioceses without notifying the community.
That shuffling around makes it difficult to determine their whereabouts—even now.
“As far as I know,” Piscitelli says, “my abuser is still out there. And that’s a shame.”
As the afternoon sun crests a ridge of redwoods, it sets the spindly leaves of some 120 cannabis plants aflame in every shade of green imaginable. A closer look at the foliage reveals purples, reds, yellows, and the oranges and browns of fine crystalline fur. Here, on a sundrenched slope high above Boulder Creek, is a pristine garden of cannabis so diverse its flowering colas span every continent except Antarctica.
“Amazingly, there seem to be cannabis appreciators in every nook and cranny of this planet where they can grow it. Each one is a living expression of their culture, terrain, and intent,” says Jeff Nordahl, who is hosting this garden of 25 heirloom strains for Wo/Men’s Alliance for Medical Marijuana (WAMM). The owner of Jade Nectar, a small cannabis farm that produces non-psychoactive tinctures for various medicinal uses, Nordahl says he hadn’t touched cannabis for 10 years before he rediscovered it as the only thing that gave him relief from a long battle with Lyme disease, and began growing it.
“I’ve been collecting and amassing seeds for a while, but never had an opportunity to pop them,” says Nordahl. “Each one is a mystery. We didn’t know what any of these were going to turn into. You could read about them on the internet, but you didn’t know. So, now, we know,” he says.
As large monocrops set the tone for post-legalization profits, WAMM’s new garden is a unique oasis far from commercial ag drift, where, in the absence of pressure to generate revenue, quality of experience and preservation of strains on the fast track to extinction avail over the trend to grow bigger, faster, more potent varieties.
“These aren’t designed for maximizing yield. They’re actually the antithesis of a production plant,”saysNordahl. “Smell this one,” he says, of the sweet-smelling Malawi Gold, a sativa from Africa. “That is probably my favorite.” But he’ll say the same about several other strains as we walk through a virtual spice rack of cannabis, paying homage to Jamaica’s Natural Mystic, Afghan Gold, Tajikistani, the zany looking Zamal, Columbian Gold—a strain many boomers will remember from the ’70s—and so many others.
“My sense, just by experiencing some of the plants that we’ve already harvested,” says Nordahl, “is that you’re getting a much broader spectrum of cannabinoids. And, in the end, are we just trying to impress people with lab results that show 30 percent or higher THC numbers? My sense is that actually something in the 15-percent range of THC with a whole wide spectrum of other plant compounds, cannabinoids and terpenes, is actually going to be a much richer experience than a one-dimensional wall of THC.”
Beyond being a living museum for long-cherished domesticated and landrace strains, the garden also thrums with a sweet irony: the people among us who need cannabis the most, but can’t afford it after legalization, will now have access to some of the rarest heirloom strains in the world. For free.
“This garden is a thank you gift to WAMM,” says Nordahl. “For its commitment. Instead of backing off or cutting some deal when they were raided by the feds all those years ago, they stood up for what they believed in. If they had backed down, no change would have come.”
Valerie Corral, co-founder of WAMM and co-author of Prop 215, sits at a picnic table under an oak tree, overlooking the expanse of green. In contrast to our last meeting in the sleepless throes of uncertainty just before legalization, Corral is glowing with gratitude. Which is not uncommon for her, but there’s something else, too—she’s excited. Corral did not know Nordahl when he approached her about hosting the garden, but the door he opened, along with his shared values for the plant as medicine, couldn’t have led to a more synergistic collaboration.
“This has opened up WAMM,” says Corral. “It’s much more of a shared journey. It always has been. But now that it’s legal, we have to speak in different terms. It’s an investment in true return for gifting. It gives the opportunity for everybody to give.” The garden is closer to the original WAMM garden in its variety, she says, and she and Nordahl look forward to companion planting with other medicinal herbs in the years to come.
There were times last year that Corral thought she might even leave Santa Cruz, but that’s all changed, and the only move WAMM is making now is across town to the Sullivan Building on Soquel Avenue early next year. “The dispensary will be a small part of it, and then the rest of it will be a community center for health awareness,” says Corral. WAMM’s new center will offer palliative care, workshops and potlucks on all topics of health, including regular visits from Nonna Marijuana, Corral’s 95-year-old mother of YouTube fame. “No single thing heals,” says Corral. “I’m so grateful to the city and the county for the recognition, and honoring the work, and trusting.” She adds that it has always been in her mind that new WAMMs would pop up in other communities, “but now it’s far more practical than it has ever been before.”
The garden takes up only a tiny fraction of Nordhal’s 250-acre property, the site of a former camp in disrepair that was overgrown with Scotch broom when he bought it. “Not one single tree is being taken down,” he says. “The entire property is a beautiful sanctuary in nature. We want to preserve that and be the most responsible stewards of the land as possible.”
The botanical garden is the cornerstone of a slowly blossoming dream: a regenerative and sustainable Jade Grove Farm & Wellness Center. In time, individuals will be able to make reservations to come out and spend a day decompressing in nature, taking hikes through the forest, sweating in saunas, learning about (and consuming) landrace strains of cannabis, and absorbing plant energy of all kinds.
“We see cannabis as a gateway to plant medicine,” says Nordahl. “If we can provide access to this plant in the purest way that we know, and if this can benefit people’s lives and connect them to nature in some way, that is the magic we’re after.”